American Idol Fashion Face-Off: Carrie Underwood vs. Kellie Pickler

at . Comments

Carrie Underwood won a pair of country music awards earlier this week.

But some people are more concerned about the fashion choices of various celebrities. With that in mind, let's break down two country crooners from American Idol seasons past.

Carrie appears nice and understated, but Kellie Picker is practically falling out of her dress. Looks like those new "shoes" she bought recently are taking on a life of their own.

Carrie and Kellie

But what do you think, readers? Which look is better?

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.


I think Kelly is trying too hard and Carrie is herself. so therefore Carrie looks better! I love Carrie Underwood. I look up to her.


I actually thinks kellie dress is so cute & different. thats why i like it alot. i love carrie style but this dress just looks like easter sunday to me.


What a question. Kellie looks like a wanna-be-mixture of Mariah and Britney. No style, faked boobs. Don't know why she does it. Carrie looks great, as always.


Carrie by FAR looks better!!!!!