This Memorial Day edition of the Caption Contest - the 57th - was a competitive one. But who prevailed?

We loved the captions by McDreamyLover, McYummyMyTummy, Kim, Jamie and Christy. But ultimately, we had to go with the entry emailed by the mysterious elevatorGod.

Congratulations to the winner, the honorable mentions, and all who took part in this fun weekly feature. The winning entry appears beneath the image. Scroll down to read the full list of responses we got.

Thank you for playing and making this the top Greys Anatomy fan site online. Visit us often for cast news, This week's Caption Contest image:

"Damn it, Mark! For the last time, NO, I don't want your pickle!"

Steve Marsi is the Managing Editor of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Google+ or email him here.