"The Other Side of This Life" Forums Live, Open For Reader Comments Comments (Page 4)
98 Comments
MJ
May 3rd, 2007 11:48 PM
I didn't feel a connection to any of the characters, not even Taye Diggs. I say let's get back to the nine main characters (Burke, Cristina, Mer, Derrick, George, Izzie, Alex, Bailey and The Chief), and just bring in guest.
Jen
May 3rd, 2007 11:35 PM
HATE the spin-off crap. It was so boring I had to splash cold water on my face to stay awake. I can't stand Addison at all in the new setting. Kate Walsh sucks as an actress. I definitely won't be watching this show.
Volk
May 3rd, 2007 11:31 PM
i dont know where to start...maybe by saying that this episode SUCKED!!!! my god!! i love addison i think her character can grow so much ..but at greys!!! no in this spin off..personally i think they killed tonight's show...i was waiting for this ep so badly..specially cuz of last week's cliffhanger but now i feel dissapointed...
=(
i want addison back at grey's...and i want a REAL EPISODE NEXT WEEEK!
sky
May 3rd, 2007 11:27 PM
Just a comment: it sucks.
I am too depressed for burktina right now...Why???? I hate the trianlge and Mereidth and Derek are so different...
lea
May 3rd, 2007 11:25 PM
Horrible, that's all.
Now I am sure that Bang won't get married, so I can avoid to watch the last two episodes. All the storylines don't make sense.
Belgian Grey
May 3rd, 2007 10:51 PM
I haven't been able to watch it but read the resume on a fan-site and I am in no hurry to get it. What is going on? For me Shonda wants to do HARA-KIRI with GA. She has no respect for the viewers, this always happens with that type of creators we make them rich and then they have no respect for their fans. Well it is known that real love only lasts for 3 years!!!
Stacia
May 3rd, 2007 10:42 PM
And what was with this epesode all in LA??? I watch Grey's to watch what's going on with the charactors in it, not with what's going on in a new show. I wish that they wouldn't have done that. I was sooo excited only to be shut down.
Stacia
May 3rd, 2007 10:39 PM
I am soooo mad at Derek!! I just watched the new epesode and cannot believe that he didn't go and talk to her at the end. I have this horrible feeling that he is going to leave her. I think that is a bunch of bull....
As far is George is concerned...well, don't even get me started on that one. What is he doing????
MerDer4ever
May 3rd, 2007 10:29 PM
i agree with you Laura... i also thought Meredith was done with the whole dark and twisty thing. and i swear derek said that he's going to always be there no matter what. he'll always going top come back to her after they fight. and he said he's going to be her knight and shinning whatever. i'm about to cry... i hated this episode. SERIOUSLY!!!
MerDer4ever
May 3rd, 2007 10:23 PM
i had such a hard time watching tonight's greys. i swear, i started yelling at my tv. i mean, seriously... the scenes in LA was too painful to watch. and how much more crap can meredith take? mommy died like 4 or 5 episodes ago or so... and now they kill step-mommy. wtf?!? and derek... don't get me started. what's with him and flirting with another woman? ugHh!!! oh and i swear they cut out a lot of scenes in the whole christina and them looking for dresses. they had so much pictures from that scene and we got like a minute... wtf?!? ugHhhhhhhhh!!! i say we all voice our feelings about tonight's episode and the potential spinoff in the grey's site. i hated that they spent 90% of tonight's episode in LA.
wendy
May 3rd, 2007 10:20 PM
I Love Greys anatomy But tonight it was more Addison's anatomy instead .. Dont' get me wrong the new spin off seems interesting but i wait all week for thursday to see mer/der geo/izzy and the rest of the gang .. it seemed like we got teased by their apperances. then they switched over to the new spinoff show.. if it was goin to be like that then the spin off should have had its own time slot not Grey's time.. Just my opinion. I just didn't get enuff of the characters to last me for another week.. I was cheated on my Fix lmao.. Still in love w/ the show
Laura
May 3rd, 2007 10:14 PM
o and 1 more thing
did mer's dad actually hit her?? like wth!!????
you can sorta tell shondas running out of ideas and panicing....
once again i am soooooo pissed that kate walsh is officially off the show!!
merder haveee to stay together or you might as well bomb the whole hospital, have everyone but the chief die, and make a whole new show with that!!!!!!!
LIKE SERIOUSLYYY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!???????
Laura
May 3rd, 2007 10:11 PM
ewww its getting really annoying how they're always trying to spilt up mer and der!!!!!!!!!!
i swear i am going to stop watching soon!!!
n no more kate walsh?? might as well jump off a cliff
now alex is deffinatley stuck with weird girl..
n i had a great twist that they shud've done!!!
der chooses job over mer
marc hits on mer more till they finally go out
der plans his meeting to be at the same resturant when he finds out
der dumps chief to be with mer
mer has 2 guys again.....
then she cud do the rest...
i also find it nasty how they're making almost everything happen!!!
i mean george and izzy?? seriously???!!!
alexaholic
May 3rd, 2007 10:11 PM
Lena, I totally agree. Taye Diggs would make a good addition to Grey's. I did not care for any of the other characters. Addison definitely needs to return to SGH--she is smart, funny, self-effacing, and brings a tremendous amount of skill and heart to the show. The MerDer storyline is getting totally out of hand, and I cannot stand the Izzie/George arc. Someone said that the viewpoint is all from their side without factoring in Callie's point of view. I agree---that being said, the only honest and true relationship IS Burktina, because, despite their flaws, they LOVE each other and remain true to that love. The entire rest of the hospital (from nurses up to the Chief) are a bunch of whoring, VD-carrying narcissistic whiners.
Lena
May 3rd, 2007 10:05 PM
I didn't really like this episode. It was too slow and too confusing. Bring Taye Diggs to Greys. Leave Addison on Greys.
i
May 3rd, 2007 9:45 PM
The basis of this show was always mcdreamy and meredith, first she had him, and didn't really want him, then when she wanted him his wife shows up, now she finally has him...and what do they do...they screw it up! I was just watching the season 2 finale this morning and it was real grey's...eveything is so confusing and weird now...i totally want george and izzie to make it, but mcdreamy and meredith HAVE to stay together, what is the show going to be like without them, and the end of the preview with the chief and someone laying on the floor...who could it be? Dr. Bailey maybe?? All I can say is...this new show blows and we need to get back to real greys!!!
alexaholic
May 3rd, 2007 9:23 PM
Okay, my worst fears have been realized....This is nothing but greed taking over good sense and ruining what WAS the best show on TV. The spinoff is TERRIBLE. I could not care less about those goofy LA a-holes, and there was some major false advertising going on since this show was not about Grey's or Seattle Grace, other than to try and sucker us into watching it. I too went to my computer more than once during the show........because there were WAY too many commercials, the characters are not developed enough and besides they are not LIKABLE in any way shape or form, and they took the best role model for a woman (besides Bailey) and turned her into a morose, idiotic, goof, with a ticking biological clock and no self-control. Besides, the "Man Candy" was not that tasty--For my money I'd stay at SGH and work on Alex or even McSteamy, or heck, throw down with the Chief (at least there's a brain between those two ears, which is more than one could say about the surfer-dude-reception
Felicia
May 3rd, 2007 9:17 PM
This season is about over. Maybe they can recover and get back their drive in season 4. Sometimes I think they need to go back to the original nine. I just don't know.
Laura
May 3rd, 2007 9:15 PM
Top 5 reasons why this episode seriously sucked:
1. The spin-off incorporated into the same episode of Grey's is horrible. It would've been so much better if they would've had an episode of Grey's and then ended it with Addison leaving, then had the second hour of it be the spin-off. Then we could've all turned off our tvs instead of being forced to watch it.
2. Killing off Susan? Seriously? Why do the writers feel it necessary to kill off BOTH of Meredith's moms within two months?! Why do they hate her so much and feel it necessary to put her through all of this? Just when we all thought that Meredith was done being dark and twisty, poor thing. I was actually starting to like Susan too.
3. Derek and Meredith? Excuse me. I thought that they had this whole thing figured out. They talked, she told him not to give up on her and he seemed like he agreed. Then in the preview for next week it shows him at the bar accepting a drink from some random hoe?! If Derek and Meredith aren't back b
Thing 4 Ferry Boats
May 3rd, 2007 9:12 PM
The writers do hate Meredith. And what's with McDreamy hitting on other women in the preview????????!!!!!!! NOOOOOOO!!!!! Poor, poor Meredith!!!! The spin-off isn't gonna happen...although, I wouldn't mind if McElevator showed up at Seattle Grace....
cmd05b
May 3rd, 2007 9:06 PM
GREY'S TONIGHT WAS THE GAYEST SHOW I'V EVER SEEN!!!!!!! TERRIBLE!!!!!! Spent too much time in LA and why did the step mom. I swear if derrick and meridth break up i will be pissed!!!! But tonight was aweful!!!! Tonight was bad bad bad.
Adam
May 3rd, 2007 9:03 PM
Oy....does that preview for next week look really, really bad? Seriously, did the creators make a bet with someone on how fast they can lose their audience? Because right now, based on the evidence so far, they're gonna lose it fast
Jack
May 3rd, 2007 8:55 PM
GREY'S really sucks tonight.
Whitney
May 3rd, 2007 8:53 PM
this episode is ridiculous.
i have never changed the channel for grey's and tonight i did.
who are these people??
real sad. fix it quick.
Meredith: People change, but they don't change.
May 3rd, 2007 11:48 PM
I didn't feel a connection to any of the characters, not even Taye Diggs. I say let's get back to the nine main characters (Burke, Cristina, Mer, Derrick, George, Izzie, Alex, Bailey and The Chief), and just bring in guest.
May 3rd, 2007 11:35 PM
HATE the spin-off crap. It was so boring I had to splash cold water on my face to stay awake. I can't stand Addison at all in the new setting. Kate Walsh sucks as an actress. I definitely won't be watching this show.
May 3rd, 2007 11:31 PM
i dont know where to start...maybe by saying that this episode SUCKED!!!! my god!! i love addison i think her character can grow so much ..but at greys!!! no in this spin off..personally i think they killed tonight's show...i was waiting for this ep so badly..specially cuz of last week's cliffhanger but now i feel dissapointed...
=(
i want addison back at grey's...and i want a REAL EPISODE NEXT WEEEK!
May 3rd, 2007 11:27 PM
Just a comment: it sucks.
I am too depressed for burktina right now...Why???? I hate the trianlge and Mereidth and Derek are so different...
May 3rd, 2007 11:25 PM
Horrible, that's all.
Now I am sure that Bang won't get married, so I can avoid to watch the last two episodes. All the storylines don't make sense.
May 3rd, 2007 10:51 PM
I haven't been able to watch it but read the resume on a fan-site and I am in no hurry to get it. What is going on? For me Shonda wants to do HARA-KIRI with GA. She has no respect for the viewers, this always happens with that type of creators we make them rich and then they have no respect for their fans. Well it is known that real love only lasts for 3 years!!!
May 3rd, 2007 10:42 PM
And what was with this epesode all in LA??? I watch Grey's to watch what's going on with the charactors in it, not with what's going on in a new show. I wish that they wouldn't have done that. I was sooo excited only to be shut down.
May 3rd, 2007 10:39 PM
I am soooo mad at Derek!! I just watched the new epesode and cannot believe that he didn't go and talk to her at the end. I have this horrible feeling that he is going to leave her. I think that is a bunch of bull....
As far is George is concerned...well, don't even get me started on that one. What is he doing????
May 3rd, 2007 10:29 PM
i agree with you Laura... i also thought Meredith was done with the whole dark and twisty thing. and i swear derek said that he's going to always be there no matter what. he'll always going top come back to her after they fight. and he said he's going to be her knight and shinning whatever. i'm about to cry... i hated this episode. SERIOUSLY!!!
May 3rd, 2007 10:23 PM
i had such a hard time watching tonight's greys. i swear, i started yelling at my tv. i mean, seriously... the scenes in LA was too painful to watch. and how much more crap can meredith take? mommy died like 4 or 5 episodes ago or so... and now they kill step-mommy. wtf?!? and derek... don't get me started. what's with him and flirting with another woman? ugHh!!! oh and i swear they cut out a lot of scenes in the whole christina and them looking for dresses. they had so much pictures from that scene and we got like a minute... wtf?!? ugHhhhhhhhh!!! i say we all voice our feelings about tonight's episode and the potential spinoff in the grey's site. i hated that they spent 90% of tonight's episode in LA.
May 3rd, 2007 10:20 PM
I Love Greys anatomy But tonight it was more Addison's anatomy instead .. Dont' get me wrong the new spin off seems interesting but i wait all week for thursday to see mer/der geo/izzy and the rest of the gang .. it seemed like we got teased by their apperances. then they switched over to the new spinoff show.. if it was goin to be like that then the spin off should have had its own time slot not Grey's time.. Just my opinion. I just didn't get enuff of the characters to last me for another week.. I was cheated on my Fix lmao.. Still in love w/ the show
May 3rd, 2007 10:14 PM
o and 1 more thing
did mer's dad actually hit her?? like wth!!????
you can sorta tell shondas running out of ideas and panicing....
once again i am soooooo pissed that kate walsh is officially off the show!!
merder haveee to stay together or you might as well bomb the whole hospital, have everyone but the chief die, and make a whole new show with that!!!!!!!
LIKE SERIOUSLYYY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!???????
May 3rd, 2007 10:11 PM
ewww its getting really annoying how they're always trying to spilt up mer and der!!!!!!!!!!
i swear i am going to stop watching soon!!!
n no more kate walsh?? might as well jump off a cliff
now alex is deffinatley stuck with weird girl..
n i had a great twist that they shud've done!!!
der chooses job over mer
marc hits on mer more till they finally go out
der plans his meeting to be at the same resturant when he finds out
der dumps chief to be with mer
mer has 2 guys again.....
then she cud do the rest...
i also find it nasty how they're making almost everything happen!!!
i mean george and izzy?? seriously???!!!
May 3rd, 2007 10:11 PM
Lena, I totally agree. Taye Diggs would make a good addition to Grey's. I did not care for any of the other characters. Addison definitely needs to return to SGH--she is smart, funny, self-effacing, and brings a tremendous amount of skill and heart to the show. The MerDer storyline is getting totally out of hand, and I cannot stand the Izzie/George arc. Someone said that the viewpoint is all from their side without factoring in Callie's point of view. I agree---that being said, the only honest and true relationship IS Burktina, because, despite their flaws, they LOVE each other and remain true to that love. The entire rest of the hospital (from nurses up to the Chief) are a bunch of whoring, VD-carrying narcissistic whiners.
May 3rd, 2007 10:05 PM
I didn't really like this episode. It was too slow and too confusing. Bring Taye Diggs to Greys. Leave Addison on Greys.
May 3rd, 2007 9:45 PM
The basis of this show was always mcdreamy and meredith, first she had him, and didn't really want him, then when she wanted him his wife shows up, now she finally has him...and what do they do...they screw it up! I was just watching the season 2 finale this morning and it was real grey's...eveything is so confusing and weird now...i totally want george and izzie to make it, but mcdreamy and meredith HAVE to stay together, what is the show going to be like without them, and the end of the preview with the chief and someone laying on the floor...who could it be? Dr. Bailey maybe?? All I can say is...this new show blows and we need to get back to real greys!!!
May 3rd, 2007 9:23 PM
Okay, my worst fears have been realized....This is nothing but greed taking over good sense and ruining what WAS the best show on TV. The spinoff is TERRIBLE. I could not care less about those goofy LA a-holes, and there was some major false advertising going on since this show was not about Grey's or Seattle Grace, other than to try and sucker us into watching it. I too went to my computer more than once during the show........because there were WAY too many commercials, the characters are not developed enough and besides they are not LIKABLE in any way shape or form, and they took the best role model for a woman (besides Bailey) and turned her into a morose, idiotic, goof, with a ticking biological clock and no self-control. Besides, the "Man Candy" was not that tasty--For my money I'd stay at SGH and work on Alex or even McSteamy, or heck, throw down with the Chief (at least there's a brain between those two ears, which is more than one could say about the surfer-dude-reception
May 3rd, 2007 9:17 PM
This season is about over. Maybe they can recover and get back their drive in season 4. Sometimes I think they need to go back to the original nine. I just don't know.
May 3rd, 2007 9:15 PM
Top 5 reasons why this episode seriously sucked:
1. The spin-off incorporated into the same episode of Grey's is horrible. It would've been so much better if they would've had an episode of Grey's and then ended it with Addison leaving, then had the second hour of it be the spin-off. Then we could've all turned off our tvs instead of being forced to watch it.
2. Killing off Susan? Seriously? Why do the writers feel it necessary to kill off BOTH of Meredith's moms within two months?! Why do they hate her so much and feel it necessary to put her through all of this? Just when we all thought that Meredith was done being dark and twisty, poor thing. I was actually starting to like Susan too.
3. Derek and Meredith? Excuse me. I thought that they had this whole thing figured out. They talked, she told him not to give up on her and he seemed like he agreed. Then in the preview for next week it shows him at the bar accepting a drink from some random hoe?! If Derek and Meredith aren't back b
May 3rd, 2007 9:12 PM
The writers do hate Meredith. And what's with McDreamy hitting on other women in the preview????????!!!!!!! NOOOOOOO!!!!! Poor, poor Meredith!!!! The spin-off isn't gonna happen...although, I wouldn't mind if McElevator showed up at Seattle Grace....
May 3rd, 2007 9:06 PM
GREY'S TONIGHT WAS THE GAYEST SHOW I'V EVER SEEN!!!!!!! TERRIBLE!!!!!! Spent too much time in LA and why did the step mom. I swear if derrick and meridth break up i will be pissed!!!! But tonight was aweful!!!! Tonight was bad bad bad.
May 3rd, 2007 9:03 PM
Oy....does that preview for next week look really, really bad? Seriously, did the creators make a bet with someone on how fast they can lose their audience? Because right now, based on the evidence so far, they're gonna lose it fast
May 3rd, 2007 8:55 PM
GREY'S really sucks tonight.
May 3rd, 2007 8:53 PM
this episode is ridiculous.
i have never changed the channel for grey's and tonight i did.
who are these people??
real sad. fix it quick.
May 3rd, 2007 8:48 PM
Seriously...why do the writers hate Meredith?