Grey's Anatomy > Shonda Rhimes: Derek Loves Meredith! > Comments Page 2
I agree, george and Izzie do have real love. They are lucky as they like each other and love each other too, and I think they are the only couple on the show that fits this criteria.
Who is trying to turn George into a McStud? He is a great guy (not to mention after seeing the elevator kiss, a wonderful kisser), who wouldn't fall in love with a cute, sweet funny guy like him? I know I would fall in love with him in a second.
Give me George over Derek, Alex and Mark combined any day?
And seriously, not all relationships are based on physical, George and Izzie have the emotional and physical connections, which makes them all the mroe special.
George and izzie are amazing, they have true love. They are so much more than about physical appearances and it is sad that some people seem to be stuck into physical appearances. Hot girls do get with guys that are not the definition of studs. Look at katherine heigl's real-life fiance or Ellen Pompeo's one. They are not McSteamy or McDreamy, but they have so much more going for them. Josh is funny, talented, can cook and is an amazing guy.
So hot girls are suppose to go only with hot guys? what a shallow, limited view of the world.
IMHO, George is hotter than Alex or Mark any day.
Alex and Mark have hot bods, but not much substance to go with.
George is the sensitive, funny, caring amazing guy and I have to tell you, girls are drawn to that. The bad boy with a heart of gold cliche wears out real fast.
I am not a big Gizzie fan but I am a huge George and Izzie fan separately. I hope that they mend their indiscretions and get on to more interesting story lines. If you look at the overall themes of this show it really strongly reflects how sexually repressed Americans are and in being so how obsessed they are with SEX at all times. It is sad how a platonic relationship like Gizzie could not have been just left alone. I hope that Derek gets some more interesting plot twists and more air time since P.Dempsey is great to watch as an actor and needs more exposure on the show (sorry to P.D. for wanting him to work more!). I am not going to watch Private Practice since it so far looks like a weak attempt to capitalize on G.A. success. I will miss K.Walsh but so be it. Hopefully the new season will be lighter and more interesting with better plots and better medical moments. My interest in the show did wane last year.....I did buy Season 3 but have not even opened it yet, whereas, with the Se
Happy to hear the Derek stil loves Meredith, hopefully that means she is going to return the feeling, by the preview I saw tonight, she looked ready to fight for him. I think that Meredith and Derek need to stop forcing the relationship and just let their love work everything out. Still can't stand Izzie and George. Think that the friendship was ruined and really be hard to get back, because even if they get together it won't stick and then what.
Derek and George should never be compared. They are completely different. Derek is dreamy and sexy and George is cute. That is not an insult either! The thing is ya can't change who ya are so dramatically. They're tryin to turn George into mcstud and he so isn't meant to be that! He's supposed to be cute like a puppy. Not the one who gets all the hot girls. KNOW YOUR ROLE!
Wow, so much comments, but given those are the two most-talked about couples on the show, I am not that surprised. BTW, I am an O'Stevens (George and Izzie, do not like the Gizzie nickname) and MerDer fan, love them both and want them to be happy. I feel privileged to have two couples that I love so much. George and Izzie were a beautiful surprise to me, I was shocked at what a great couple they make and how much they could love one another. Breaks my heart but in a good way.
guys guys chillll everyone is talking about not watching the show anymore but wat if they get together l8r and you miss it or their might be some other great couple or story line.. quiting the show over one measly break up means you must not have been watching Greys anatomy for the past seasons....i am on the mer der team myself but SERIOUSLY CHILL!!!! mer/der all the way
i love derek and meredith sooooooo much. there perfect together so LEXI GREY needs to pee off xxxx MER DER 4EVA
I'm no longer going to waste my time talking about George and Izzie. No one is going to change my mind about them and I'm sure I'm not going to change anyone elses. But, I will give them this, maybe they are becoming bigger the Mer/Der cuz it seems like everyone here is just talking about them. I'm still not a fan though. I don't really even like Mer/Der the best. I watch the show for Christina and Alex, hopefully they will get some good stories this year. I wish Burke would have stuck around.
And Alicia I agree with you about Derek, it pisses me off that he doesn't forgive Mark too, but I think that they're going to mend their friendship this year since Burke is gone.
I think Izzie loved Denny deeply, but he died and she had to move on, and I believe she has always been a bit in love with George. I loved Denny and Izzie, I do love george and Izzie more.
As for MerDer, they are the main couple, noone is denying that. But there can be two great couples on this show, why the competition between the two group of fans? I love both and I think they both bring a lot to the show.
Those ship wars get a bit irritating.
How do I know george is a great kisser? Because didn't you see that elevator kiss? The way their faces just meet and their lips touch with their eyes close and they sort of lean into each other and then his hand goes tenderly on her neck and sort of caresses it. I just about died, that was one of the most sensuous thing I ahd ever seen and Izzie's face when George breaks it off shows just how much she was into it, her face is all red and she is all breathless.
I have seen even people who don't like them say that kiss was one hot moment. Just take a look at the number of times it has eben put on Youtube and the comments on it, I am def. not the only one who thinks he is a good kisser.
I liked Burke, too bad Isaah had to be an ass, because I loved Burke and George's friendship, I did hate how he ried to control ristina so much and change ehr. To me, that was abusive.
I hate Derek, I hate how he won't forgive Mark no matter how hard Mark tries. I hate that he called Mer a whore a
Ok Alicia how do you know that George is a great kisser? Give me a break! Your forgetting that during all that history that you Gizze fans are popping off is that during most of that time Izzie was supposed to be so in love with Denny, now I will agree that I thought Izzie has had a thing for George every since Callie came in the picture, but what about Denny. Wasn't he supposed to be the love of her life. I mean I don't really even like Izzie anymore because of all this. And I agree George used to be funny but know he is all depressed all the time. I'm sick and tired of watching him and Izzie give each other these long I'm so in love looks. I enjoyed both of their characters more in season one.
And I 100% stand beside my choice of McDreamy over George.
And I totally seriously miss Burke already.
ok so people who are saying thank you about mer and der are dumb. cuz obviously he loves and obviously they are gonna end up together. i mean what would friends be without ross and rachael, boy meets world without cory and topanga. they are gonna be together, we just gotta be patient. and i like george and izzie. its gonna be kinda hard to just put an end to it since she loves him.
the thing about O'Mizzie is -- and to me this is what matters -- every relationship is not about forever. Their relationship is not meant to parallel Meredith & Derek. They are both fighting to escape. It's not ideal and I can understand all points of view. But...to me, their coupling, so to speak, is like life. Messy and not necessarily rational and goal oriented. It happens.
I like MerDer, but I find them a bit on the boring side, and all my friends pretty much feel the same way. That they are ok, but forgettable. I guess I don't mind them, I just don't really care about them at all. I love Meredith on her own, but Derek is a disgusting pig after the way he treated both Meredith and Addison.
As for Meredith, she seems to love her friends like Cristina, George and Izzie more than she loves Derek.
George and Izzie, to me, are perfect as they are best friends and lovers and they have fabulous chemistry. The timing is all off and I hate the affair, but if they can get George divorced and then have him and Izzie find their way to each other the rigth way and not too fast, I would love it.
I want George to be alone for a while and then him and Izzie to find their way slowly to each other without his marriage or any lies hanging over them.
They are funny, cute and so darn hot, that elevator kiss was wow!
Who knew our cute little georgie was such a
Derek might have been separated when he first slept with Mer, but when he slept with her at the prom, he definitely was married and had promised Addison he would be her husband full-time and he was committed to teir marriage. The prom thing happened after he called Mer a slut and pursued her for months, without an ounce of guilt.
George has done his best to stay away from Izzie, despite the fact he loves her. He was even willing to never speak to any of his friends again so he would do the right thing. They slept together once while they were drunk and had the kiss. There is obviously a lot of evry deep feelings between George and Izzie and an intense physical attraction but George has done his best to respect his marriage wishes as he does not believe in divorce. It is obvious his heart belong with Izzie though.
I'd pick Bambi over boring asshole Derek absolutely any day of the week. George has the sweetest, most adorable face and he is funny as heck. And I'd take cute, good kis
So this is about George's looks? How shallow! And I'd dather George over McAss, oops McDreamy any day. Derek is the most boring character on the entire show. ASll he does is stand there and look handsome, yawn. The guy has no personality and no story without Meredith. George is funny, adorable, an amazing kisser, is sweet, smart and has a great big huge heart. Not to mention he has the most gorgeous blue eyes ever.
Derek has a cute face but that is about it, he does nothing for me.
And Meredith and Derek have more history, LMAO.
What history? The history where he met her drunk in a bar, took her home to have sex with her and proceeded to lie to her about being married. Or the history where he chose his wife over her after she pathetically begged him to pick her, choose her (that scene made me physically ill). And then after picking his wife, he ended up chasing after Meredith like a puppy, treating his wife like a dog and calling Meredith a whore when she tried to move on. Yes
I totally see the chemistry between George and Izzie. However the relationship is misplaced and ill-timed. The writers needed to jump on this bandwagon in season one.
I totally agree with BrightandShiny, George and Izzie are just like Will and Grace, no chemistry whatsoever. And to everyone that says this is just a show, we know that, but this is a Grey's Anatomy website where people can give their opinions, we just having a little fun discussing what we like and what we don't like, don't take it so seriously, SERIOUSLY! And once again for the record I cannot stand George and Izzie, and they should never be compared to Meredith and Derek. Mer/Der have way more history then Gizze and way more passion, and who would you rather have pining after you McDreamy or 007. Come on look at their nicknames, you have McDreamy and Bambi! Give me a break, no contest. Go Mer/Der, end Gizze. Its bad enough that we lost Burke and Addison, but don't make me sit through anymore of Gizze Shronda! I can't take it!
i tend to disagree. ever scince they hooked up i felt the chemestry. i never liked callie but she despratly loves gorge. i just happen to love izzy more. on the otherhand i feel so bad for derek. i hope merideth loved him. but of course, she has to, or the show would be terrible.
Ok. When i first heard that George and izzie were hookin up i was happy because i love them. When i actually saw it i nearly vomited. Absolutely no chemistry whatsoever. Wrong wrong wrong. They are so Will and Grace! also my boyfriend is so sick to death of me talkin about MerDer all the time and their chemistry. But we both sat down last night and looked at My Favourite Mistake on the DVD. Ya know the last scene where Derek was tellin Meredith that he was distracted durin the Board Interview and she said how bad. He said eight and she kept kissin him until it got to one. That was sizzling. My boyfriend couldn't stop talkin about it and how real they were and how totally into one another they were and how naturally they fit. He's addicted now. MerDer forever.
Maybe every side should respect the other's opinions. It is pretty obvious a lot of people love George and Izzie and a lot of people don't. People will love different things.
I love George and Izzie and I don't need to explain why, I just do.
I am hating this site, there seems to be no one controlling what is being said at all.
Talking about having nothing to do, Maddie, you must have nothing to do too as half the comments on there seem to come from you. You sure spend a lot of energy talking about a couple you don't like.
I watch soap operas and I work. This is what PVR (or DVR in the States) are for. I work 40 hours a week and get to watch my shows too.
I might be the only one, but I thought Izzie was falling in love with george when Denny was still alive and she didn't notice it. Just the way she talked about him all the time, to anyone who would listen, even Denny.
The Denny thing was always mroe like Romeo and Juliette t me, the whole tragic thing appealing to Izzie. Not saying she didn't love him, but the tragic part of it did play a part in their love story. Not sure they would have worked if he lived as they really did not know anything about achh other.
George and Izzie on the other hand know each other so well and love each other. Like Shonda said, George loves Izzie, all of her, even he
to Alexandra: you are trying so desperately to find a reason to show that I have twisted moral values as well with your comment concerning derek and meredith..but im sorry that is something you are completely making up as you can see in NO comments of mine anything about MerDer's affair.im actually neutral about that. and looking back, there WAS a difference though, derek was separated and wasn't sleeping with 2 people AT THE SAME TIME;)
george is leading callie on, not admitting he's cheated on her AND promising her a baby!im sorry but he's weak and i have no sympathy for him. he's unfair to izzie and callie not having the guts to make up him mind.
and concerning the moving on thing: it really wasnt a year, it was more like within months that izzie moved on..and even if people do move on soon after a loved one has died, there is no documented proof for the reasons they do it. my bet is they move on because of fear of loneliness and because they want someone who would ease their pain
to Karevsanatomy:i completely agree with you!
And to Amanda, i don't see the reason why you feel the need to justify yourself..i dont care if you are french and you have worked for 25 years and please,think as you wish,you are entitled to your opinion, it's what democracy is all about. i just expressed my happiness that those people who dont like that soap opera style farfetched drama between izzie and george are finally speaking up because previously, all i read was a la "yay, love gizzie, they are the only reason i watch the show..gizzie forever, etc..".
as to stay-at-home moms, im sorry, but look at the statistics, they are the main audience of soap operas in the united states..other people would just not be able to watch them as they are either at work or at school at the time these shows are on. dont take it personally.these are just facts and before becoming all emotional, i never said anywhere that stay-at-home moms have nothing to do all day.so next time, before writing h
You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.
Remember My Info