American Idol Shocker: Goodbye, Michael Johns! Comments (Page 2)
51 Comments
Jade
April 11th, 2008 6:20 PM
The show is getting more and more ridiculous. How people like Jason are getting by just like Sanjaya last year is insane. Jason looks like he's stoned half of the time and I wouldn't doubt it or he's really not very bright. I didn't like at all the way Ryan did the spin with the shock factor and almost made one believe that Johns wasn't going home. I am sorry, I like Ryan but that was tasteless and he owes Johns an apology. Host or no host whatever writers idea that was, he should have refused to handle the elimination in the way he did. It showed little or no class. The voting process needs a big change. Take Dancing with the Stars, so many votes per phone line and that's it.
MICHAEL VARVERIS
April 11th, 2008 12:16 PM
THE NAME IS VARVERIS,
Michael Vaecweua
April 11th, 2008 12:13 PM
I'M AN OLD-TIMER WHO STILL FEELS SINATRA WAS HE BEST NATURAL SINGER OF ALL-TIME I'M NOT A FAN OF ROCK .WHEN I SEE A SINGER WITH A GREAT SET OF PIPES AND STAGE PRESENCE GET BUMPED OFF, THERE'S SOMETHING WRONG WITH THE IDOL VOTING. MICHAEL JOHNS CAN SING "FLY ME TO HE MOON" AND MAKE IT SOUND GREAT. WHEN I HEARD HIM SING, I TOLD EVERY ONE HE SHOULD WIN IT THIS YEAR. I EVEN SAID HE COULD MAKE ME LIKE ROCK MUSIC. YOU CAN UNDERSTAND EVERY WORD WHEN HE'S SINGING, NOT SO WITH MANY OTHER ERICK SINFRS
Chris
April 11th, 2008 11:35 AM
Michael Johns should not being eliminated! He's really definitely one of the best singer in the competition and I just can't believe that he was out, especially before that idiot, freak Jason Castro. He can't even sing! I just don't understand what's so good about him! AI is really not a talent competition, it is a popularity contest. I'm just wishing all the best for Michael. I'm sure he'll make a great record, just as big as Carrie Underwood or Chris Daughtry. Michael, you can be the next Daughtry and I know that!
Will
April 11th, 2008 11:07 AM
Easily one of the most entertaining artists on the show. My family was incredibly shocked...and Seacrest's move was hopefully just a slip up of thinking fast on live TV.
I am not sure how Jason lives on and Johns goes home.
Looking forward to more music from Johns post Idol!
Brian S
April 11th, 2008 10:30 AM
I think the judges, save Simon, were genuinely shocked. Simon takes AI for what it is for him; winning the lottery.
Brian S.
April 11th, 2008 10:21 AM
AI ceased being a talent contest last night. The thought of having one bad night be the reason to get voted off is ludicrous. Kristy Lee is a joke, Syesha is a joke, David A. is at best an opening act for Barry Manilow or Clay Aiken. David C., Jason, Carly, Brooke, and Michael are true talents. But it doesn't matter. Howard Sterns cohorts used the ridiculous voting system to keep Sanjaya on last year and until it's changed, talent will lose out to target-market based popularity.
Michael
April 11th, 2008 10:17 AM
Well, America is getting what it deserves, whether it is president election or American Idol...Texas/Utah/Mid-West country/cowboys/people who do not know where is Canada voters rule the country and get what they want...
How come that awfull country girl is still in the competition...well for same reason.
Now the best most charismatic singer is gone but hey it is same with everything in America... Nice job cowboys...!
ms
April 11th, 2008 10:06 AM
Michael Johns should not have been eliminated last night. There isn't one person I spoke to prior to the show who thought that Syesha was going to stay, and neither did I. Michael was one of the best singers they have ever had along with Carly. Wow, very disappointed.
Brett
April 11th, 2008 10:04 AM
this was long overdue...
my opinion about Micheal Johns is that he certainly has the performance chops, but not as a singer. he hands down had the worst voice in the competition. his pitch was always shakey and he opted to yell the high notes instead of actually hit them. i think the reason the judges have been so impressed with him is that the live audience recieves a different energy than those of us watching at home. in the heat of a live show, you are more willing to forgive mistakes. a good example is Switchfoot. Jon Foreman is an incredible performer, but SF's tv appearances have clearly shown that, at least live, he has some troubl with higher notes. however, in the energy of SF show, it's easy to look past. this is why Johns was voted off. he needs alot of vocal training before he can really hold his own as a performer.
that being said, this is WHY David Cook WILL win. he can do both, perform well and create energy. he is hands down the most confident, capable, and market
Suz
April 11th, 2008 9:32 AM
HUGE, HUGE mistake regarding Michael Johns' departure from AI. However, with his talent I expect to see great things from him. AI is becoming a "let's vote for the cutest" instead of voting for the most talented. Being a member of the 50 and over club, I listen to the voices and the music...Michael, you shouldn't have any problems getting a record deal..I certainly will purchase your first album...oops.....cd. Keep smilin' dude...you've got what it takes and then some!!!!
KathyLagler
April 11th, 2008 9:32 AM
Last nite was like watching Chris Daughtry all over again. Michael should definitely have made it to the end. He was my favorite. When he sang Bohemian Rhapsody it gave me the chills, sounded almost exactly like Freddie. They say everything happens for a reason--I think he'll do good for himself. Look at Daughtry, he said losing on Idol was a good thing because he can do his own thing. Good luck to Michael.
Ajana
April 11th, 2008 8:57 AM
Michael Johns was my absolute favorite. I hope someone picks him up as a solo artist and he comes out with an album soon. I can't wait to hear more of him. I didn't vote...I assumed he'd make it to the end. Perhaps that's what a lot of his fans did. This is a teeny bopper contest anyway. MJ YOU ROCK! As last night's elimination proved...AI is a popularity contest based on other factors outside of pure talent.
Sarah W
April 11th, 2008 8:46 AM
Ohh, and to all of you who thought he would win... you're stupid. Archulta is going to win because he appeals to the most viewers, wether or not he's the best artist is moot. The best Johns could have ever gotten was 2nd.
Sarah W
April 11th, 2008 8:45 AM
I definately don't think that Michael Johns was the BEST performer in this bunch, but I don't think he deserved to go this week either. I would have given him somewhere in the top 5.
Teri
April 11th, 2008 8:21 AM
America can never be accused of having good taste in music after last night. Don't care now if I even want to watch the rest of the season; it should have come down to Johns and Cook. Makes you wonder if they're skewing the votes in favor of the teenybopper favorites.
Diane
April 11th, 2008 8:18 AM
I am speechless and shocked!! I predicted Michael Johns to win the competition. At this point I cannot watch the rest of the competition. Michael will come out on top with a phenomenal album and surprise everyone. To be honest, I think a recount of votes needs to be done.
Ana Matias-Roe
April 11th, 2008 8:08 AM
I hated watching last night. I agree that the voting is compelted ruled by the youngsters and they can vote more than once, right? I can never vote as I am working and watch it late at night. I couldn't sleep after that! Jason Castro has a huge following...sorry but he should go before Carly but look where he was. The guy looks like a fall out from the hippie days with a twist of Tiny Tim! Michael Johns for sure should have been in the top three. My husband thinks maybe they will bring him back next week? Wishful thinking?
Charles
April 11th, 2008 6:17 AM
I agree with so many of the posters. This totally unfair. This could affect ratings as many aren't interested in watching any longer. Crazy or not, write AL to have Johns reinstated. Stranger things have happened.
Cathy
April 11th, 2008 6:09 AM
I'm shocked beyond belief. I've voted for Michael every week and have been a big fan since Bohemian Rhapsody. He could have won this contest. I'm sure he'll still do well and I'll buy what he puts out. This has been a great season, and I'll miss seeing Michael every week. All my votes go to Jason now. Everyone better vote or else we'll lose another of our favorites!
Angelamaria
April 11th, 2008 3:38 AM
My husband and I were both shocked. Michael was one of the best singers on this year. I also agree that the voting system should be changed. Look what happened last year. Just because one is young and the 13-15 year olds can vote 50 or more times for them from their cell phones doesn't make sense. They made a mistake this year with Michael. Good luck to that young man, I hope he makes it big in the music industry..
Dove
April 11th, 2008 2:51 AM
At this stage of the competition, I really cant stand to see anyone leave.This season has the best goup of competitors since Idols conception. I am so fond of all of them and someone had to go. I will miss Michael and no doubt he has a bright future ahead of him. I cannot wait to see him perform live on the Idol tour.
Victor
April 11th, 2008 2:25 AM
Carl, have you ever listen to vocalist's music? The man is a natural singer at par with Kelly Clarkson. I don't think your ill wish can really shut him out. He will have a big career, you will see!
Carl
April 11th, 2008 1:34 AM
Come on, can't you just admit that he SUCKED???
GOOD BYE MICHAEL JOHNS!!!!
Jimena Cisneros
April 11th, 2008 1:06 AM
I live in Costa Rica and I watch the TV show every single day that it is transmited. To me it was very disspointing that Michael Johns was eliminated. I hope that all american people that can vote throw their toll free numbers realize that we have to aprrove other rythms than pop or blues. Michael is a great singer and I hope he gets a cd contract, because he deserves it. Please open your minds ando vote for David Cook. He is the best of them.
April 11th, 2008 6:20 PM
The show is getting more and more ridiculous. How people like Jason are getting by just like Sanjaya last year is insane. Jason looks like he's stoned half of the time and I wouldn't doubt it or he's really not very bright. I didn't like at all the way Ryan did the spin with the shock factor and almost made one believe that Johns wasn't going home. I am sorry, I like Ryan but that was tasteless and he owes Johns an apology. Host or no host whatever writers idea that was, he should have refused to handle the elimination in the way he did. It showed little or no class. The voting process needs a big change. Take Dancing with the Stars, so many votes per phone line and that's it.
April 11th, 2008 12:16 PM
THE NAME IS VARVERIS,
April 11th, 2008 12:13 PM
I'M AN OLD-TIMER WHO STILL FEELS SINATRA WAS HE BEST NATURAL SINGER OF ALL-TIME I'M NOT A FAN OF ROCK .WHEN I SEE A SINGER WITH A GREAT SET OF PIPES AND STAGE PRESENCE GET BUMPED OFF, THERE'S SOMETHING WRONG WITH THE IDOL VOTING. MICHAEL JOHNS CAN SING "FLY ME TO HE MOON" AND MAKE IT SOUND GREAT. WHEN I HEARD HIM SING, I TOLD EVERY ONE HE SHOULD WIN IT THIS YEAR. I EVEN SAID HE COULD MAKE ME LIKE ROCK MUSIC. YOU CAN UNDERSTAND EVERY WORD WHEN HE'S SINGING, NOT SO WITH MANY OTHER ERICK SINFRS
April 11th, 2008 11:35 AM
Michael Johns should not being eliminated! He's really definitely one of the best singer in the competition and I just can't believe that he was out, especially before that idiot, freak Jason Castro. He can't even sing! I just don't understand what's so good about him! AI is really not a talent competition, it is a popularity contest. I'm just wishing all the best for Michael. I'm sure he'll make a great record, just as big as Carrie Underwood or Chris Daughtry. Michael, you can be the next Daughtry and I know that!
April 11th, 2008 11:07 AM
Easily one of the most entertaining artists on the show. My family was incredibly shocked...and Seacrest's move was hopefully just a slip up of thinking fast on live TV.
I am not sure how Jason lives on and Johns goes home.
Looking forward to more music from Johns post Idol!
April 11th, 2008 10:30 AM
I think the judges, save Simon, were genuinely shocked. Simon takes AI for what it is for him; winning the lottery.
April 11th, 2008 10:21 AM
AI ceased being a talent contest last night. The thought of having one bad night be the reason to get voted off is ludicrous. Kristy Lee is a joke, Syesha is a joke, David A. is at best an opening act for Barry Manilow or Clay Aiken. David C., Jason, Carly, Brooke, and Michael are true talents. But it doesn't matter. Howard Sterns cohorts used the ridiculous voting system to keep Sanjaya on last year and until it's changed, talent will lose out to target-market based popularity.
April 11th, 2008 10:17 AM
Well, America is getting what it deserves, whether it is president election or American Idol...Texas/Utah/Mid-West country/cowboys/people who do not know where is Canada voters rule the country and get what they want...
How come that awfull country girl is still in the competition...well for same reason.
Now the best most charismatic singer is gone but hey it is same with everything in America... Nice job cowboys...!
April 11th, 2008 10:06 AM
Michael Johns should not have been eliminated last night. There isn't one person I spoke to prior to the show who thought that Syesha was going to stay, and neither did I. Michael was one of the best singers they have ever had along with Carly. Wow, very disappointed.
April 11th, 2008 10:04 AM
this was long overdue...
my opinion about Micheal Johns is that he certainly has the performance chops, but not as a singer. he hands down had the worst voice in the competition. his pitch was always shakey and he opted to yell the high notes instead of actually hit them. i think the reason the judges have been so impressed with him is that the live audience recieves a different energy than those of us watching at home. in the heat of a live show, you are more willing to forgive mistakes. a good example is Switchfoot. Jon Foreman is an incredible performer, but SF's tv appearances have clearly shown that, at least live, he has some troubl with higher notes. however, in the energy of SF show, it's easy to look past. this is why Johns was voted off. he needs alot of vocal training before he can really hold his own as a performer.
that being said, this is WHY David Cook WILL win. he can do both, perform well and create energy. he is hands down the most confident, capable, and market
April 11th, 2008 9:32 AM
HUGE, HUGE mistake regarding Michael Johns' departure from AI. However, with his talent I expect to see great things from him. AI is becoming a "let's vote for the cutest" instead of voting for the most talented. Being a member of the 50 and over club, I listen to the voices and the music...Michael, you shouldn't have any problems getting a record deal..I certainly will purchase your first album...oops.....cd. Keep smilin' dude...you've got what it takes and then some!!!!
April 11th, 2008 9:32 AM
Last nite was like watching Chris Daughtry all over again. Michael should definitely have made it to the end. He was my favorite. When he sang Bohemian Rhapsody it gave me the chills, sounded almost exactly like Freddie. They say everything happens for a reason--I think he'll do good for himself. Look at Daughtry, he said losing on Idol was a good thing because he can do his own thing. Good luck to Michael.
April 11th, 2008 8:57 AM
Michael Johns was my absolute favorite. I hope someone picks him up as a solo artist and he comes out with an album soon. I can't wait to hear more of him. I didn't vote...I assumed he'd make it to the end. Perhaps that's what a lot of his fans did. This is a teeny bopper contest anyway. MJ YOU ROCK! As last night's elimination proved...AI is a popularity contest based on other factors outside of pure talent.
April 11th, 2008 8:46 AM
Ohh, and to all of you who thought he would win... you're stupid. Archulta is going to win because he appeals to the most viewers, wether or not he's the best artist is moot. The best Johns could have ever gotten was 2nd.
April 11th, 2008 8:45 AM
I definately don't think that Michael Johns was the BEST performer in this bunch, but I don't think he deserved to go this week either. I would have given him somewhere in the top 5.
April 11th, 2008 8:21 AM
America can never be accused of having good taste in music after last night. Don't care now if I even want to watch the rest of the season; it should have come down to Johns and Cook. Makes you wonder if they're skewing the votes in favor of the teenybopper favorites.
April 11th, 2008 8:18 AM
I am speechless and shocked!! I predicted Michael Johns to win the competition. At this point I cannot watch the rest of the competition. Michael will come out on top with a phenomenal album and surprise everyone. To be honest, I think a recount of votes needs to be done.
April 11th, 2008 8:08 AM
I hated watching last night. I agree that the voting is compelted ruled by the youngsters and they can vote more than once, right? I can never vote as I am working and watch it late at night. I couldn't sleep after that! Jason Castro has a huge following...sorry but he should go before Carly but look where he was. The guy looks like a fall out from the hippie days with a twist of Tiny Tim! Michael Johns for sure should have been in the top three. My husband thinks maybe they will bring him back next week? Wishful thinking?
April 11th, 2008 6:17 AM
I agree with so many of the posters. This totally unfair. This could affect ratings as many aren't interested in watching any longer. Crazy or not, write AL to have Johns reinstated. Stranger things have happened.
April 11th, 2008 6:09 AM
I'm shocked beyond belief. I've voted for Michael every week and have been a big fan since Bohemian Rhapsody. He could have won this contest. I'm sure he'll still do well and I'll buy what he puts out. This has been a great season, and I'll miss seeing Michael every week. All my votes go to Jason now. Everyone better vote or else we'll lose another of our favorites!
April 11th, 2008 3:38 AM
My husband and I were both shocked. Michael was one of the best singers on this year. I also agree that the voting system should be changed. Look what happened last year. Just because one is young and the 13-15 year olds can vote 50 or more times for them from their cell phones doesn't make sense. They made a mistake this year with Michael. Good luck to that young man, I hope he makes it big in the music industry..
April 11th, 2008 2:51 AM
At this stage of the competition, I really cant stand to see anyone leave.This season has the best goup of competitors since Idols conception. I am so fond of all of them and someone had to go. I will miss Michael and no doubt he has a bright future ahead of him. I cannot wait to see him perform live on the Idol tour.
April 11th, 2008 2:25 AM
Carl, have you ever listen to vocalist's music? The man is a natural singer at par with Kelly Clarkson. I don't think your ill wish can really shut him out. He will have a big career, you will see!
April 11th, 2008 1:34 AM
Come on, can't you just admit that he SUCKED???
GOOD BYE MICHAEL JOHNS!!!!
April 11th, 2008 1:06 AM
I live in Costa Rica and I watch the TV show every single day that it is transmited. To me it was very disspointing that Michael Johns was eliminated. I hope that all american people that can vote throw their toll free numbers realize that we have to aprrove other rythms than pop or blues. Michael is a great singer and I hope he gets a cd contract, because he deserves it. Please open your minds ando vote for David Cook. He is the best of them.