Erica: "There is right, and there is wrong. And this was wrong."
YES! It *was* wrong to have you let go, especially like this!?!
Are they crazy? That was so out of character, even for a strong-minded, highly professional woman like Erica. - The whole Izzie situation had nothing to do with her and Callie, and no one can convince me that an intelligent person like Erica would think so.
Her last sentences about Callie made no sense at all. Ridiculous, that's what this is.
The scene where Erica fights with Dr. Webber? Great acting (once more) by Brooke Smith! - The expression on her face before she leaves the room? I think that was Brooke letting out all the frustration about being "let go" by ABC for no logical reason.
She's such a talented actress, an her character had so much spark. How could they end it, especially like this?? (Stupid "dyke drama", anyone?)
Julz
November 7th, 2008 6:30 AM
AWWWWR that wan absolutely AMAZING episode!!!
I think Maddiexoxo really got the point, I was thinking the same.
I loved how the pictured izzies struggles about denny, that was soo .. itense?
I can't really describe it, but it was great...
First, I really loved Dr Hunt, then, when he came back, he was such a jackass, I couldn't even believe, but then again, this ep when he talked about having respect and stuff, I kinda started to like him again..
and then, Cristina opening up to him so much, that was just GREAT, I think it shows that she really cares about him!!
And of course Mark, haha, that was soooo hilarious, I loved loved LOVED it!!!!!!!! :D
And George.
OMG George
that was sooooo sweet, him trying to keep this stan robot alive omg I laughed so much, I am not a big george fan, but that was just awsome!!!!
What do you think, who will get the solo surgery?
After this ep I thought it might be george... but it may also be cristina or izzie??
(BTW: Izzies storyline re
valentain22
November 7th, 2008 5:12 AM
I just watched it, and I liked it
but I realiced they have soo many characters that they can never show enough of any of them so every story line goes so on baby steps... it becomes frustrating!
and it still keeps me watching.
Can't wait to watch this week's episode..it sounds interesting..hope to see MERDER..sigh!
Concerned... Rank: Guest Star
November 7th, 2008 4:37 AM
Is it true that Hahn gets killed?? It would explain the fact that Callie totally falls apart next week...I'll be so sad if that's how they're going to have Brooke Smith aka Erica Hahn leave, totally kill her off for good. OMG!!! Shocked yet again...
JakiChan
November 7th, 2008 2:34 AM
If anyone can ID the last song in the episode I would love it. Thanks!
kim
November 7th, 2008 1:28 AM
Okay I know Denny has been dead for three seasons but I still love seeing him and izzie interact! It makes me all happy inside!
The Mark and Christina "flirting" was absolutely hilarious!
Grey's Anatomy is back! Yes!!!!
fredd
November 7th, 2008 1:05 AM
K, so no new Gizzie scenes. I miss their friendship, too - they were great together. But I guess Izzie's got Alex now, who's not being a total jerk for a change.
My def favorite scenes/relationship was the Cristina-Dr. Hunt ones. I see a dramatic yet rewarding future for those two!
I was a bit upset at first about Hahn's character being dissed out, but now that I think about it, i never REALLY liked Hahn in the first place, what really annoyed me a little bit is HOW they did it. So sudden, so random.
I love that Derek's starting to adapt to life with Meredith, trying to understand her friendship with Cristina and all, thought that was nice... turning out to be a pretty healthy relationship SO FAR (tho I'm sure we'll see more drama, i mean it's MERDER, right?)
Maddiexoxo Rank: Guest Star
November 7th, 2008 12:51 AM
Ok so i finally watched this episode. My reaction...
I ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT!!!! OMG! I cried a lot!
I mean yeah there wasn't must MerDer at all. The parts they did have were cute and stuff... and funny. Haha. Derek is right they do need counseling. They need a lot of things. But, they are happy together. I saw that.
This episode to me was about Izzie... and Hahn. About their struggles.
Sure i would have loved the 5 minutes of MerDer i want each week... but anywho.
I really enjoyed this episode. For me... it was an emotional roller coaster. I was really looking forward to it... because I love the dramatic stuff in this show. This episode really did live up to my expectations.
I love MerDer... and if there isn't any of them next week.. THEN I WILL BE REALLY ANGRY!
But for now... I am satisfied. I have great hope for them. Mer opened up about her NDE! WOW! Not in depth but still. It's something. Not much Mer this episode but as i said... the point was Izzie/Hahn.
Me
Sabrina
November 7th, 2008 12:29 AM
George and Izzie stole the show for me even though they again didn't share any scenes. Katie was amazing as always. She gave me goosebumps and it was so good seeing our beautiful Denny again. Poor Izzie is going nuts. George was so so funny. TR is hilarious. He does physical comedy so well.
Alex was an ass as always. Seriously I have had more than enough of him. He can go back to backburner city for all I care.
Hathir Daiss
November 7th, 2008 12:19 AM
Thank you Bill Harper tonight was an awesome episode.Keep up the great writting!
Megan
November 7th, 2008 12:10 AM
I didn't watch but they again didn't give us George and Izzie scene? Really? George was majorly involevd in this story. I am so tired of it. At least we got some Dizzie. After Gzizie, they were my favorite couple, and now it is not contradictory. Both guys brought out the best in Izzie, and Denny was with George my favorite makle character.
Sara
November 6th, 2008 11:42 PM
I loved the George and Alex scenes, so so funny. George singing made me laugh. Katie was great. I may hate Izzie an Alex and not like Izzie those days because of that, bu Katie is brilliant. I still want more GI scenes,. as friends or more. They made a great couple.
I think that it would be cool if they wrote a show like lost with all their pasts and maybe how they crossed paths and didn't even realize it.
laura
November 6th, 2008 10:57 PM
i think that would be really cool to learn about derek and mark's past and their college years. actually i think they should have a whole episode on everyones past! that would be really cool!
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
November 6th, 2008 10:53 PM
Well, yeah because I remember in the PP pilot, Derek implied he knew Sam and Naomi and I assume that Mark also knows them. I think that their interaction would be really awesome to see, maybe give us a glimpse of Mark and Derek's past too. Or college past. Something.
I think that it would be great for PP and Greys to do a cross over. I would like to see the interaction between all the characters. I would think it would be awesome and that would be like a ultimate two nights of Greys!
I think that I would have thought that it was stupid show if we didn't know that Hahn was leaving. But I think that it was a great show. I think that it was touching that Christina was talking about her father and Meredith was talking about her near life experience.
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
November 6th, 2008 10:35 PM
Really? Bummer...I can't say that I'll miss her but killing her just like that is...I don't know. This whole Erica situation is really disturbing.
Anna
November 6th, 2008 10:32 PM
I love Private Practice. As much as I miss Addie on Grey's, she does seem happier on Private Practice.
xxCallieFanxx Rank: Extra
November 6th, 2008 10:29 PM
No I did not make up that Erica dies. It was released as a spoiler. I found it on the Erica_Callie LiveJournal Community. It stated that her patient finally receives the heart he needed from a 41 year female. Turns out to be Erica.
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
November 6th, 2008 10:27 PM
Oh, I've been trying to watch PP but sometimes it bores me. Gotta admit that I like seeing a happier Addie. I just read in TVGuide.com that GA and PP will be having cross-over episode for February sweeps...how cool does that sound?
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
November 6th, 2008 10:26 PM
Haha...everyone should go to Dr. Wyatt. I remember watching an interview somewhere (maybe in the season 4 DVD?) where Patrick said that he'll like to see Meredith and Derek going to therapy together. THAT would be good.
Yeah, Derek really does love her. He has to be McDreamy doesn't he? Where can I get one of those?
By the description of Sadie, I think she'd be right for Sloan. LOL...Mark and Derek dating former bf's. Fun stuff.
Paddisonluvr Rank: Guest Star
November 6th, 2008 10:23 PM
This episode was great - finally, we get something other than nonstop relationship drama. George was hilarious, Mark/Derek were great, Callie was finally being a doctor, Izzy was great (whatever your opinions of Katherine Heigl, she is an amazing actress). But I do really want MerDer scenes - just talking, at least. Love Denny, love him. This episode really reminded me of Season 2 (and no, not just because Denny was there.)
Grey's is amazing. I'm looking forward to seeing where the storyline goes from here, especially with all of the Erica/Brooke controversy.
By the way - have you all been watching Private Practice? Because you should be - it's fantastic.
November 7th, 2008 7:27 AM
Erica: "There is right, and there is wrong. And this was wrong."
YES! It *was* wrong to have you let go, especially like this!?!
Are they crazy? That was so out of character, even for a strong-minded, highly professional woman like Erica. - The whole Izzie situation had nothing to do with her and Callie, and no one can convince me that an intelligent person like Erica would think so.
Her last sentences about Callie made no sense at all. Ridiculous, that's what this is.
The scene where Erica fights with Dr. Webber? Great acting (once more) by Brooke Smith! - The expression on her face before she leaves the room? I think that was Brooke letting out all the frustration about being "let go" by ABC for no logical reason.
She's such a talented actress, an her character had so much spark. How could they end it, especially like this?? (Stupid "dyke drama", anyone?)
November 7th, 2008 6:30 AM
AWWWWR that wan absolutely AMAZING episode!!!
I think Maddiexoxo really got the point, I was thinking the same.
I loved how the pictured izzies struggles about denny, that was soo .. itense?
I can't really describe it, but it was great...
First, I really loved Dr Hunt, then, when he came back, he was such a jackass, I couldn't even believe, but then again, this ep when he talked about having respect and stuff, I kinda started to like him again..
and then, Cristina opening up to him so much, that was just GREAT, I think it shows that she really cares about him!!
And of course Mark, haha, that was soooo hilarious, I loved loved LOVED it!!!!!!!! :D
And George.
OMG George
that was sooooo sweet, him trying to keep this stan robot alive omg I laughed so much, I am not a big george fan, but that was just awsome!!!!
What do you think, who will get the solo surgery?
After this ep I thought it might be george... but it may also be cristina or izzie??
(BTW: Izzies storyline re
November 7th, 2008 5:12 AM
I just watched it, and I liked it
but I realiced they have soo many characters that they can never show enough of any of them so every story line goes so on baby steps... it becomes frustrating!
and it still keeps me watching.
Rank: Extra
November 7th, 2008 4:53 AM
Can't wait to watch this week's episode..it sounds interesting..hope to see MERDER..sigh!
Rank: Guest Star
November 7th, 2008 4:37 AM
Is it true that Hahn gets killed?? It would explain the fact that Callie totally falls apart next week...I'll be so sad if that's how they're going to have Brooke Smith aka Erica Hahn leave, totally kill her off for good. OMG!!! Shocked yet again...
November 7th, 2008 2:34 AM
If anyone can ID the last song in the episode I would love it. Thanks!
November 7th, 2008 1:28 AM
Okay I know Denny has been dead for three seasons but I still love seeing him and izzie interact! It makes me all happy inside!
The Mark and Christina "flirting" was absolutely hilarious!
Grey's Anatomy is back! Yes!!!!
November 7th, 2008 1:05 AM
K, so no new Gizzie scenes. I miss their friendship, too - they were great together. But I guess Izzie's got Alex now, who's not being a total jerk for a change.
My def favorite scenes/relationship was the Cristina-Dr. Hunt ones. I see a dramatic yet rewarding future for those two!
I was a bit upset at first about Hahn's character being dissed out, but now that I think about it, i never REALLY liked Hahn in the first place, what really annoyed me a little bit is HOW they did it. So sudden, so random.
I love that Derek's starting to adapt to life with Meredith, trying to understand her friendship with Cristina and all, thought that was nice... turning out to be a pretty healthy relationship SO FAR (tho I'm sure we'll see more drama, i mean it's MERDER, right?)
Rank: Guest Star
November 7th, 2008 12:51 AM
Ok so i finally watched this episode. My reaction...
I ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT!!!! OMG! I cried a lot!
I mean yeah there wasn't must MerDer at all. The parts they did have were cute and stuff... and funny. Haha. Derek is right they do need counseling. They need a lot of things. But, they are happy together. I saw that.
This episode to me was about Izzie... and Hahn. About their struggles.
Sure i would have loved the 5 minutes of MerDer i want each week... but anywho.
I really enjoyed this episode. For me... it was an emotional roller coaster. I was really looking forward to it... because I love the dramatic stuff in this show. This episode really did live up to my expectations.
I love MerDer... and if there isn't any of them next week.. THEN I WILL BE REALLY ANGRY!
But for now... I am satisfied. I have great hope for them. Mer opened up about her NDE! WOW! Not in depth but still. It's something. Not much Mer this episode but as i said... the point was Izzie/Hahn.
Me
November 7th, 2008 12:29 AM
George and Izzie stole the show for me even though they again didn't share any scenes. Katie was amazing as always. She gave me goosebumps and it was so good seeing our beautiful Denny again. Poor Izzie is going nuts. George was so so funny. TR is hilarious. He does physical comedy so well.
Alex was an ass as always. Seriously I have had more than enough of him. He can go back to backburner city for all I care.
November 7th, 2008 12:19 AM
Thank you Bill Harper tonight was an awesome episode.Keep up the great writting!
November 7th, 2008 12:10 AM
I didn't watch but they again didn't give us George and Izzie scene? Really? George was majorly involevd in this story. I am so tired of it. At least we got some Dizzie. After Gzizie, they were my favorite couple, and now it is not contradictory. Both guys brought out the best in Izzie, and Denny was with George my favorite makle character.
November 6th, 2008 11:42 PM
I loved the George and Alex scenes, so so funny. George singing made me laugh. Katie was great. I may hate Izzie an Alex and not like Izzie those days because of that, bu Katie is brilliant. I still want more GI scenes,. as friends or more. They made a great couple.
Rank: Guest Star
November 6th, 2008 11:21 PM
I think that I want to see Motorcycle riding Derek
Rank: Guest Star
November 6th, 2008 11:20 PM
I think that it would be cool if they wrote a show like lost with all their pasts and maybe how they crossed paths and didn't even realize it.
November 6th, 2008 10:57 PM
i think that would be really cool to learn about derek and mark's past and their college years. actually i think they should have a whole episode on everyones past! that would be really cool!
Rank: Regular Character
November 6th, 2008 10:53 PM
Well, yeah because I remember in the PP pilot, Derek implied he knew Sam and Naomi and I assume that Mark also knows them. I think that their interaction would be really awesome to see, maybe give us a glimpse of Mark and Derek's past too. Or college past. Something.
Rank: Guest Star
November 6th, 2008 10:48 PM
I think that it would be great for PP and Greys to do a cross over. I would like to see the interaction between all the characters. I would think it would be awesome and that would be like a ultimate two nights of Greys!
Rank: Guest Star
November 6th, 2008 10:44 PM
I think that I would have thought that it was stupid show if we didn't know that Hahn was leaving. But I think that it was a great show. I think that it was touching that Christina was talking about her father and Meredith was talking about her near life experience.
Rank: Regular Character
November 6th, 2008 10:35 PM
Really? Bummer...I can't say that I'll miss her but killing her just like that is...I don't know. This whole Erica situation is really disturbing.
November 6th, 2008 10:32 PM
I love Private Practice. As much as I miss Addie on Grey's, she does seem happier on Private Practice.
Rank: Extra
November 6th, 2008 10:29 PM
No I did not make up that Erica dies. It was released as a spoiler. I found it on the Erica_Callie LiveJournal Community. It stated that her patient finally receives the heart he needed from a 41 year female. Turns out to be Erica.
Rank: Regular Character
November 6th, 2008 10:27 PM
Oh, I've been trying to watch PP but sometimes it bores me. Gotta admit that I like seeing a happier Addie. I just read in TVGuide.com that GA and PP will be having cross-over episode for February sweeps...how cool does that sound?
Rank: Regular Character
November 6th, 2008 10:26 PM
Haha...everyone should go to Dr. Wyatt. I remember watching an interview somewhere (maybe in the season 4 DVD?) where Patrick said that he'll like to see Meredith and Derek going to therapy together. THAT would be good.
Yeah, Derek really does love her. He has to be McDreamy doesn't he? Where can I get one of those?
By the description of Sadie, I think she'd be right for Sloan. LOL...Mark and Derek dating former bf's. Fun stuff.
Rank: Guest Star
November 6th, 2008 10:23 PM
This episode was great - finally, we get something other than nonstop relationship drama. George was hilarious, Mark/Derek were great, Callie was finally being a doctor, Izzy was great (whatever your opinions of Katherine Heigl, she is an amazing actress). But I do really want MerDer scenes - just talking, at least. Love Denny, love him. This episode really reminded me of Season 2 (and no, not just because Denny was there.)
Grey's is amazing. I'm looking forward to seeing where the storyline goes from here, especially with all of the Erica/Brooke controversy.
By the way - have you all been watching Private Practice? Because you should be - it's fantastic.