Grey's Anatomy Emmy Award Submissions Comments (Page 2)
79 Comments
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
June 9th, 2009 7:51 PM
Ellen can't submit herself as Supporting. It'd mean that Grey's Anatomy is just...Anatomy?
@JFCR, Actors are not allowed to submit episodes until they are officially nominated for the Emmy. That means that if their names are announced on July 16th, they'll be able to submit their episodes.
Also, JDM's name has been removed from the guest star Emmys nomination ballot. He's no longer avaible for nomination.
@jukk, I understand your frustation. Although I have finally understood his motives. He really doesn't stand a chance agaist Hugh Laurie or Jon Hamm, in terms of airtime to be consider at the Leading Actor. He has the talent but I can't really see what's the point of pushing him back.
And yeah...why didn't he submit himself as a guest star on PP?
This could actually be PD's choice of not to be consider for this Emmy.
jukk
June 9th, 2009 12:56 PM
I am finding it a bit hard to fathom why Patrick Dempsey can put himself forward in the supporting actor category. Wasn't he the on pictured cutting the 100th episode celebration cake? Also couldn't he put himself forward in the guest star category for his appearance on Private Practice; hasn't Kate Walsh put herself forward for the guest actor award for when she returned to GA this season? I find the Emmy set up just wierd
AiLing
June 9th, 2009 6:34 AM
But if Ellen was running for Best Supporting Actress category, she would face tough competition from her own fellow Grey's cast members....(Katherine, Sandra, Chandra)
JFCR
June 9th, 2009 2:39 AM
Sure bets:
- Grey's for Drama Series
- Eric Stoltz AND Jeffrey Dean Morgan for Guest Actor
- Justin Chambers for Supporting Actor
- Katherine Heigl for Supporting Actress
Doubtful:
- Sandra Oh and Chandra Wilson (only if they don't find anybody else... but they've been nominated before...)
- I honestly think James Pickens, Jr. has a shot this year
- If Ellen was running for supporting, she'd be a shoe-in. In Lead... Meh.
- Kevin McKidd has a shot (it depends on which episode they submitted for him to be considered)
I don't know... Not feeling that Sandra and Chandra will be considered. I bet Heigl, Rachel Griffiths (Brothers&Sisters), Marcia Gay Harden (Damages), Lisa Edelstein (House) and Diane Wiest/Hope Davis/Alison Phil (In Treatment) will be the nominees.
And as for Ellen. I believe she'll be considered or she'll be in their shortlist at the very least. Sally Field, Glenn Close, Elizabeth Moss, Anna Paquin, Holly Hunter, January Jones, Kyra Sedgwick, Pat
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
June 9th, 2009 12:45 AM
I'm going to sound like a horrible person but I really want Maura Tierney (Abby on ER) to take the Supporting Actress Emmy. Either her or Sandra. Those are the only two choices I'm preparing to see.
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
June 9th, 2009 12:38 AM
Actually, the guest stars official submissions have changed.
According to the link provided:
The following posts on this page now contain all of the contenders from the actual Emmy Awards ballots released last night. These are the official lists (with category changes by several people and quite a few situations where actors/actresses did not submit their names for the ballot).
Guest actor in a drama series:
Grey's Anatomy (George Coe)
Grey's Anatomy (Hector Elizondo)
Grey's Anatomy (Ben Shenkman)
Grey's Anatomy (Eric Stoltz)
No JDM and Bernadette Peters was missing.
@Caroline, the ballot process comes in two phases. Right now they just fini
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
June 8th, 2009 9:38 PM
In this site or in another official site?
Caroline
June 8th, 2009 6:03 PM
I can't find Jeffrey Dean Morgan in the offical list! This are the only listed actors: Grey's Anatomy (George Coe)
Grey's Anatomy (Hector Elizondo)
Grey's Anatomy (Ben Shenkman)
Grey's Anatomy (Eric Stoltz)
What happened?
E&P Rank: Recurring Character
June 8th, 2009 3:42 PM
I really like Sympathy for the Devil!
I think Ellen Pompeo really deservs it. She made a great job in this season. She always do. She's just an amazing actress. For me she's the best actress ever.
Supporting Actress: Katherine Heigl, Chandra Wilson, Sandra Oh! They made a great job. But i would also be happy with Chyler Leigh. But I think Katherine, Chandra and Sandra deserv it more than the others.
Supporting Actor: Patrick Dempsey! He did a brilliant job playing dark&twisty Derek. But Justin Chambers would deserve it, too. Because I think he made his best season ever.
Gues Actress: For me 100% Kate Walsh! She's a great actress and I miss her so much in the show. I was so happy when she came as a guest actress.
Guest Actor: Eric Stoltz, Jeffrey Dean Morgan! Eric played his role so great. And Jeffrey Dean Morgan was a great ghost of Denny.
drcookchick Rank: Guest Star
June 8th, 2009 11:22 AM
I hope T.R. gets nominated and he wins.
Dimples61
June 7th, 2009 9:05 PM
If Heigl wins I will be so pissed. That will show if ya wine like a big baby you can win. I think that Dr Bailey should win. For her scene in the OR when she ask Derrick not to save the serial killer. Cause they needed his organs for her little patient. That scene was heart wrenching. As was the scene when Merridith went to the exacution of the SK. When it was over and she was talking to Derrick her acting was never done so well as it was at that moment. Loved it!!!! As much as I love Callie I don't think that she got enough good story lines to be considered. I so think that Erica Hahn should be in the running for her "Glasses" scene and win. That was one of the best scenes I've ever seen on Grey's. I also think that Dr Bailey should be considered for her scene with Callie talking about the sour dough beard. That was to funny. I have to take back what I said about Callie not getting anything this year. The scene with she and Bailey talking about her going on a date with Erica was sooo
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
June 7th, 2009 4:34 PM
Here are some more of Grey's Emmy submission episodes.
From the Emmy ballots:
Writing submissions:
What A Difference A Day Makes
Not Good At Saying Sorry (One More Chance)
Directing Submissions:
Stairway to Heaven
Now or Never
Elevator Love Letter
Editing Submissions:
What a Difference a Day Makes
Stairway to Heaven
There's No I in Team
Elevator Love Letter
I'm not really sure with the writing submissions (I'd place Stairway to Heaven and ELL as first choice or even Brave New World) but Not Good At Saying Sorry was a pretty good episode.
zooz
June 7th, 2009 12:42 PM
just please give the emmy to the serial killer guy..he was AMAZING!!!
and of course Justin Chambers
Sophie
June 7th, 2009 9:12 AM
Justin definitely deserves one!! He's the actor we heard less about and to me he's the best on the show, especially this season! He brought so much emotion to the storyline with Izzie.
I think Katherine, Chandra and Sandra are amazing but I guess with this year's storyline Katherine is most likely to win.
Ellen is also amazing but we didn't see enough of her this year and she couldn't demonstrate enough of her talent compared to her fellow residents + Bailey
Lara
June 6th, 2009 2:26 PM
I think the only people who deserve a nomination this year are: Ellen Pompeo; Katherine Heigl; Justin Chambers; Sandra Oh; Chandra Wilson; Kevin McKidd.
I actually think it's funny how people think Sara Ramirez or Chyler Leigh should be nominated...Are you guys high? Yes, Sara Ramirez is a good actress, but this season Callie's storylines were just RIDICULOUS. Sort of entertaining, but so, so silly. And Chyler Leigh...she's endearing, but that's all.
eliry
June 6th, 2009 9:38 AM
Ellen has showed repeatedly she is a good actress, just look at range of what she had to show in her storylines. I think the odds are it will be a film star actress who wins the Emmy, the voters seem to be stuck/overawed that a film actress would dain to do a tv series! I am disappointed that Patrick didn't submit himself for the best actor, there must be a hot favorite for the Emmy. Have to say I wasn't convinced by Chandra's acting at times, I do like her though. I did find Eric Stoltz very creepy and deserving of some sort of acknowledgment for sending chills down me every time he was on screen
_°
June 6th, 2009 8:35 AM
Ellen Pompeo is really the best actress!!She made a great season. She always do. And she really deservs it. The way she acts is just amazing.
Supporting Actress:
Katherine Heigl! She did a brilliant job in this season. But I also think Chandra Wilson, Sandra Oh and Chyler Leigh deserve it...
Supporting Actor: Patrick Dempsey!!! He made a really great season. I also think he made a great job playing dark & twisty Derek. But I also would be happy if Eric Dane wins.
Guest Actress: Kate Walsh! I miss her so much in the show. And I was so happy when she came as a guest actress.
Guest Actor:Jeffrey Dean Morgan. He played the ghost of Denny very well.
.. god i love "stairway to heaven"...ellen and eric stolz were flawless...i really think eric stoltz should be nominated...and chandra wilson...this year should be hers!...her performance was a big part of what made this season a strong drama....and kevin mckidd and justin chambers were also very very good ...
Terri
June 6th, 2009 12:24 AM
TBH, I don't think Ellen will get the nomination for best lead actress. I think it's too competitive. Even though she did a good job, I think she should have tried for supporting. I don't think she was really a "lead" actress this season. Just MHO.
For supporting actress...I think Sara, Chandra, and Sandra are all deserving of a nomination...especially the later two.
Guest actress: Faye, Kate, and Melissa all were superb.
Kathleen
June 5th, 2009 3:42 PM
I think ellen should def be nominated so should patrick and justin and in actresse (supporting) chandra and izzie and ben schenkman or eric stoltz Guest stars and than Mary mcdonalls or tyne daly (guest stars
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
June 5th, 2009 1:41 PM
@Kuik,
I posted earlier about PD's probable motives for submitting himself as supportive and not lead. I personallly blame KH's big "I'm not giving Emmy worthy material" ego to push back PD. In theory, both PD and EP should be the only ones allowed for Lead. Not really sure how that works since I have no one idea under what conditions the cast was casted as (supportive, lead, etc).
Ellen has the Emmy material but Emmy's have been known for giving awards for popularity or big CV's. Disappointing but true.
As for the salary, both EP and PD recieve Lead salaries. Last time I read, both earned about $250,000 per episode ($6,000,000 a season) and KH didn't. I believe that there were reports surfaced where she wanted to make around the same that EP and PD made but because she was casted as supportive, contract negotiations didn't work out. Next contract negotiations are after season 7, if the show does go on.
lovingslexie Rank: Guest Star
June 5th, 2009 1:09 PM
I think Ellen Pompeo will be nominated for the lead but won't win.
For Supporting Actress I hope Sandra Oh takes it. Or Chandra Wilson. They're both fantastic.
For Supporting Actor I think Patrick Dempsey could take it. But it would be great to see Eric Dane or Kevin Mckidd take it home.
For guest Actress I'm absolutely pulling for Amy Madigan. She's one heck of a therapist. I need her in my life. If not her then any one of the following: Tyne Daly-hilarious, Faye Dunaway-compelling, Sharon Lawrence-heartbreaking, Samantha Mathis/Jennifer Westfeldt-very real and sympathetic.
For Guest Actor I would absolutely have to give it to Geoffrey Dean Morgan. No other guest has had a greater impact on the show. But some top contenders would be Ben Shenkman and Eric Stoltz. Their stories were definitely the most creative and affecting.
As for the Drama entries- I really like both. they both featured some of mark and lexie's more humorous and tender moments. either won w
Kuik
June 5th, 2009 11:35 AM
Patrick Dempsey as a supporting actor??? He seems to have already surrendered if he doesn't consider himself as the lead actor, I bet he gets a lead actors salary. Yes for Ellen, but I think the odds are she will be continually overlooked. The others, why?
Ali
June 5th, 2009 10:24 AM
I realllllly hope Katherine Heigl gets the emmy this year, she's an amazing acctress & she totally deserves it!
judy
June 5th, 2009 10:05 AM
I agree leader actress ELLEN POMPEL 'll win,she is great actress.Her acting's very well.
For supporting actress Sandra Ho'll be the one nom. I agree PD'll be the leader actor for nom.
Rank: Regular Character
June 9th, 2009 7:51 PM
Ellen can't submit herself as Supporting. It'd mean that Grey's Anatomy is just...Anatomy?
@JFCR, Actors are not allowed to submit episodes until they are officially nominated for the Emmy. That means that if their names are announced on July 16th, they'll be able to submit their episodes.
Also, JDM's name has been removed from the guest star Emmys nomination ballot. He's no longer avaible for nomination.
@jukk, I understand your frustation. Although I have finally understood his motives. He really doesn't stand a chance agaist Hugh Laurie or Jon Hamm, in terms of airtime to be consider at the Leading Actor. He has the talent but I can't really see what's the point of pushing him back.
And yeah...why didn't he submit himself as a guest star on PP?
This could actually be PD's choice of not to be consider for this Emmy.
June 9th, 2009 12:56 PM
I am finding it a bit hard to fathom why Patrick Dempsey can put himself forward in the supporting actor category. Wasn't he the on pictured cutting the 100th episode celebration cake? Also couldn't he put himself forward in the guest star category for his appearance on Private Practice; hasn't Kate Walsh put herself forward for the guest actor award for when she returned to GA this season? I find the Emmy set up just wierd
June 9th, 2009 6:34 AM
But if Ellen was running for Best Supporting Actress category, she would face tough competition from her own fellow Grey's cast members....(Katherine, Sandra, Chandra)
June 9th, 2009 2:39 AM
Sure bets:
- Grey's for Drama Series
- Eric Stoltz AND Jeffrey Dean Morgan for Guest Actor
- Justin Chambers for Supporting Actor
- Katherine Heigl for Supporting Actress
Doubtful:
- Sandra Oh and Chandra Wilson (only if they don't find anybody else... but they've been nominated before...)
- I honestly think James Pickens, Jr. has a shot this year
- If Ellen was running for supporting, she'd be a shoe-in. In Lead... Meh.
- Kevin McKidd has a shot (it depends on which episode they submitted for him to be considered)
I don't know... Not feeling that Sandra and Chandra will be considered. I bet Heigl, Rachel Griffiths (Brothers&Sisters), Marcia Gay Harden (Damages), Lisa Edelstein (House) and Diane Wiest/Hope Davis/Alison Phil (In Treatment) will be the nominees.
And as for Ellen. I believe she'll be considered or she'll be in their shortlist at the very least. Sally Field, Glenn Close, Elizabeth Moss, Anna Paquin, Holly Hunter, January Jones, Kyra Sedgwick, Pat
Rank: Regular Character
June 9th, 2009 12:45 AM
I'm going to sound like a horrible person but I really want Maura Tierney (Abby on ER) to take the Supporting Actress Emmy. Either her or Sandra. Those are the only two choices I'm preparing to see.
Rank: Regular Character
June 9th, 2009 12:38 AM
Actually, the guest stars official submissions have changed.
According to the link provided:
The following posts on this page now contain all of the contenders from the actual Emmy Awards ballots released last night. These are the official lists (with category changes by several people and quite a few situations where actors/actresses did not submit their names for the ballot).
Guest actress in a drama series:
Grey's Anatomy (Kathy Baker)
Grey's Anatomy (Tyne Daly)
Grey's Anatomy (Melissa George)
Grey's Anatomy (Mariette Hartley)
Grey's Anatomy (Sharon Lawrence)
Grey's Anatomy (Mary McDonnell)
Grey's Anatomy (Bernadette Peters)
Grey's Anatomy (Kate Walsh)
Grey's Anatomy (Jennifer Westfeldt)
Guest actor in a drama series:
Grey's Anatomy (George Coe)
Grey's Anatomy (Hector Elizondo)
Grey's Anatomy (Ben Shenkman)
Grey's Anatomy (Eric Stoltz)
No JDM and Bernadette Peters was missing.
@Caroline, the ballot process comes in two phases. Right now they just fini
Rank: Regular Character
June 8th, 2009 9:38 PM
In this site or in another official site?
June 8th, 2009 6:03 PM
I can't find Jeffrey Dean Morgan in the offical list! This are the only listed actors: Grey's Anatomy (George Coe)
Grey's Anatomy (Hector Elizondo)
Grey's Anatomy (Ben Shenkman)
Grey's Anatomy (Eric Stoltz)
What happened?
Rank: Recurring Character
June 8th, 2009 3:42 PM
I really like Sympathy for the Devil!
I think Ellen Pompeo really deservs it. She made a great job in this season. She always do. She's just an amazing actress. For me she's the best actress ever.
Supporting Actress: Katherine Heigl, Chandra Wilson, Sandra Oh! They made a great job. But i would also be happy with Chyler Leigh. But I think Katherine, Chandra and Sandra deserv it more than the others.
Supporting Actor: Patrick Dempsey! He did a brilliant job playing dark&twisty Derek. But Justin Chambers would deserve it, too. Because I think he made his best season ever.
Gues Actress: For me 100% Kate Walsh! She's a great actress and I miss her so much in the show. I was so happy when she came as a guest actress.
Guest Actor: Eric Stoltz, Jeffrey Dean Morgan! Eric played his role so great. And Jeffrey Dean Morgan was a great ghost of Denny.
Rank: Guest Star
June 8th, 2009 11:22 AM
I hope T.R. gets nominated and he wins.
June 7th, 2009 9:05 PM
If Heigl wins I will be so pissed. That will show if ya wine like a big baby you can win. I think that Dr Bailey should win. For her scene in the OR when she ask Derrick not to save the serial killer. Cause they needed his organs for her little patient. That scene was heart wrenching. As was the scene when Merridith went to the exacution of the SK. When it was over and she was talking to Derrick her acting was never done so well as it was at that moment. Loved it!!!! As much as I love Callie I don't think that she got enough good story lines to be considered. I so think that Erica Hahn should be in the running for her "Glasses" scene and win. That was one of the best scenes I've ever seen on Grey's. I also think that Dr Bailey should be considered for her scene with Callie talking about the sour dough beard. That was to funny. I have to take back what I said about Callie not getting anything this year. The scene with she and Bailey talking about her going on a date with Erica was sooo
Rank: Regular Character
June 7th, 2009 4:34 PM
Here are some more of Grey's Emmy submission episodes.
From the Emmy ballots:
Writing submissions:
What A Difference A Day Makes
Not Good At Saying Sorry (One More Chance)
Directing Submissions:
Stairway to Heaven
Now or Never
Elevator Love Letter
Editing Submissions:
What a Difference a Day Makes
Stairway to Heaven
There's No I in Team
Elevator Love Letter
I'm not really sure with the writing submissions (I'd place Stairway to Heaven and ELL as first choice or even Brave New World) but Not Good At Saying Sorry was a pretty good episode.
June 7th, 2009 12:42 PM
just please give the emmy to the serial killer guy..he was AMAZING!!!
and of course Justin Chambers
June 7th, 2009 9:12 AM
Justin definitely deserves one!! He's the actor we heard less about and to me he's the best on the show, especially this season! He brought so much emotion to the storyline with Izzie.
I think Katherine, Chandra and Sandra are amazing but I guess with this year's storyline Katherine is most likely to win.
Ellen is also amazing but we didn't see enough of her this year and she couldn't demonstrate enough of her talent compared to her fellow residents + Bailey
June 6th, 2009 2:26 PM
I think the only people who deserve a nomination this year are: Ellen Pompeo; Katherine Heigl; Justin Chambers; Sandra Oh; Chandra Wilson; Kevin McKidd.
I actually think it's funny how people think Sara Ramirez or Chyler Leigh should be nominated...Are you guys high? Yes, Sara Ramirez is a good actress, but this season Callie's storylines were just RIDICULOUS. Sort of entertaining, but so, so silly. And Chyler Leigh...she's endearing, but that's all.
June 6th, 2009 9:38 AM
Ellen has showed repeatedly she is a good actress, just look at range of what she had to show in her storylines. I think the odds are it will be a film star actress who wins the Emmy, the voters seem to be stuck/overawed that a film actress would dain to do a tv series! I am disappointed that Patrick didn't submit himself for the best actor, there must be a hot favorite for the Emmy. Have to say I wasn't convinced by Chandra's acting at times, I do like her though. I did find Eric Stoltz very creepy and deserving of some sort of acknowledgment for sending chills down me every time he was on screen
June 6th, 2009 8:35 AM
Ellen Pompeo is really the best actress!!She made a great season. She always do. And she really deservs it. The way she acts is just amazing.
Supporting Actress:
Katherine Heigl! She did a brilliant job in this season. But I also think Chandra Wilson, Sandra Oh and Chyler Leigh deserve it...
Supporting Actor: Patrick Dempsey!!! He made a really great season. I also think he made a great job playing dark & twisty Derek. But I also would be happy if Eric Dane wins.
Guest Actress: Kate Walsh! I miss her so much in the show. And I was so happy when she came as a guest actress.
Guest Actor:Jeffrey Dean Morgan. He played the ghost of Denny very well.
Rank: Extra
June 6th, 2009 8:05 AM
.. god i love "stairway to heaven"...ellen and eric stolz were flawless...i really think eric stoltz should be nominated...and chandra wilson...this year should be hers!...her performance was a big part of what made this season a strong drama....and kevin mckidd and justin chambers were also very very good ...
June 6th, 2009 12:24 AM
TBH, I don't think Ellen will get the nomination for best lead actress. I think it's too competitive. Even though she did a good job, I think she should have tried for supporting. I don't think she was really a "lead" actress this season. Just MHO.
For supporting actress...I think Sara, Chandra, and Sandra are all deserving of a nomination...especially the later two.
Guest actress: Faye, Kate, and Melissa all were superb.
June 5th, 2009 3:42 PM
I think ellen should def be nominated so should patrick and justin and in actresse (supporting) chandra and izzie and ben schenkman or eric stoltz Guest stars and than Mary mcdonalls or tyne daly (guest stars
Rank: Regular Character
June 5th, 2009 1:41 PM
@Kuik,
I posted earlier about PD's probable motives for submitting himself as supportive and not lead. I personallly blame KH's big "I'm not giving Emmy worthy material" ego to push back PD. In theory, both PD and EP should be the only ones allowed for Lead. Not really sure how that works since I have no one idea under what conditions the cast was casted as (supportive, lead, etc).
Ellen has the Emmy material but Emmy's have been known for giving awards for popularity or big CV's. Disappointing but true.
As for the salary, both EP and PD recieve Lead salaries. Last time I read, both earned about $250,000 per episode ($6,000,000 a season) and KH didn't. I believe that there were reports surfaced where she wanted to make around the same that EP and PD made but because she was casted as supportive, contract negotiations didn't work out. Next contract negotiations are after season 7, if the show does go on.
Rank: Guest Star
June 5th, 2009 1:09 PM
I think Ellen Pompeo will be nominated for the lead but won't win.
For Supporting Actress I hope Sandra Oh takes it. Or Chandra Wilson. They're both fantastic.
For Supporting Actor I think Patrick Dempsey could take it. But it would be great to see Eric Dane or Kevin Mckidd take it home.
For guest Actress I'm absolutely pulling for Amy Madigan. She's one heck of a therapist. I need her in my life. If not her then any one of the following: Tyne Daly-hilarious, Faye Dunaway-compelling, Sharon Lawrence-heartbreaking, Samantha Mathis/Jennifer Westfeldt-very real and sympathetic.
For Guest Actor I would absolutely have to give it to Geoffrey Dean Morgan. No other guest has had a greater impact on the show. But some top contenders would be Ben Shenkman and Eric Stoltz. Their stories were definitely the most creative and affecting.
As for the Drama entries- I really like both. they both featured some of mark and lexie's more humorous and tender moments. either won w
June 5th, 2009 11:35 AM
Patrick Dempsey as a supporting actor??? He seems to have already surrendered if he doesn't consider himself as the lead actor, I bet he gets a lead actors salary. Yes for Ellen, but I think the odds are she will be continually overlooked. The others, why?
June 5th, 2009 10:24 AM
I realllllly hope Katherine Heigl gets the emmy this year, she's an amazing acctress & she totally deserves it!
June 5th, 2009 10:05 AM
I agree leader actress ELLEN POMPEL 'll win,she is great actress.Her acting's very well.
For supporting actress Sandra Ho'll be the one nom. I agree PD'll be the leader actor for nom.