41 Comments

36. anuflas
    Rank: Regular Character
    December 8th, 2009 4:38 PM
    

    It could've been great if Lexie or Molly didn't exist. But she has already another half family she's trying to bond with and it'd be too much.
    
    Also quite illogical. He should be younger than Meredith, how could she not notice Ellis' pregnancy? Or Thatcher for that matter?
    
    I hope he isn't. At the pace we're going, half the hospital is going to be related to Meredith.

37. breakmeout93
    Rank: Extra
    December 8th, 2009 4:26 PM
    

    I think this storyline would be exceptionally cool. Too bad, then, that Shonda Rhimes personally tweeted that it wasn't true. Oh, well.

38. Alexia
    Rank: Extra
    December 8th, 2009 4:22 PM
    

    I wouldn't mind if Jackson got a bigger role in the show, but this twist sounds like a brasilian soap opera. And Meredith, who thought she's an only child until she was 29, not only found out she has two sisters, but now also a brother? A little bit too much of secret relatives for her...
    
    But if the writers can make it good, we'll see.

39. Phobo
    December 8th, 2009 4:20 PM
    

    umm how would people not notice Ellis getting pregnant??? I think the idea od a secret love child for a couple is completely ridiculous. Yes, men can have kids they kept secret but no matter how good she is, women can not hide a pregnancy that well at the same time as being a brilliant surgeon. And we've already had this secret sibling story, like debra says, so this would be an extremely unplausible plotline

40. Amanda
    December 8th, 2009 4:20 PM
    

    I think it would be great!

41. debra
    December 8th, 2009 4:16 PM
    

    How many 1/2 siblings for Meredith can possibly come out of the woodwork without fans feelings like "enough is enough"!!!