The Tuesday Gossip Girl +/- Index

by at . Comments

It's time once again for the Gossip Girl +/- index from New York Magazine, an entertaining perspective on the show we love from New Yorkers and Gossip Girl 'shipers.

Some highlights from their take on "The Sixteen Year Old Virgin" ...

  • They used actual pics of Taylor Momsen for the Jenny photos in the Brooklyn apartment. In them, she looks normal, innocent, even happy. Plus 2, because we imagine Jenny's downward trajectory is perfectly matched with her real-life counterpart.
  • Okay, Nate and Serena are definitely not "sex all the way under the covers so that not even your head is sticking out" people. They are more like "gross sex on shared surfaces where your roommates also prepare food" people. Minus 10.
  • Chuck and Blair sat for a posed portrait together? It'd be more real if it was a painting, but that's probably still in the commission phase, so Plus 2.
The Beautiful Serena
  • What, again, is Serena doing with her life? Just hanging around Nate's place? And repeatedly and ill-advisedly endeavoring to use her brain? Plus 2.
  • Elizabeth does not look like a lady who plays squash. Minus 4.
  • Even for TV, Damien is wearing a ton of makeup. Plus 1.
  • Serena's dress at the Historical Society only has pretend cleavage? Come on. Minus 4.
  • Serena's maroon dress is almost (almost!) safe and demure. And yet her boobs literally ripped it open to make it outright dangerous-looking. Plus 2.
  • Not to give Damien too much credit here, because his whole plot line was leading up to this, but he did sort of really seem to like Jenny for a while. He's a player, sure, but he wouldn't have just bolted like that. Minus 6.
  • Jenny: "I'm a virgin. I just wanted you to know, in case … I just wanted you to know." This made us cringe so, so hard. Partially because it was so real, and partially because we definitely had no such sweet, nervous hesitations in our own lives. Plus 4.

Steve Marsi is the Managing Editor of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Google+ or email him here.

Like Us On Facebook

Want more Gossip Girl?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

From Around the Web

    More From TV Fanatic


    Gossip Girl Rewatch: There Might Be Blood

    Join us for the rewatch of Gossip Girl Season 2 Episode 9 "There Might Be Blood." What did you think of this episode?

    Gossip Girl Rewatch: Pret-a-Poor-J

    Jenny's career ambitions go to a new level in Gossip Girl Season 2 Episode 8 Read on for our review.

    Gossip Girl Rewatch: Chuck In Real Life

    Revisit Gossip Girl Season 2 Episode 7 in this review rewind. Remember this classic installment of The CW series?

    Gossip Girl Rewatch: New Haven Can Wait

    Join us for the rewatch of Gossip Girl Season 2 Episode 6! This was a fun one.


    HOW can you not include Jenny not knowing about Dirty Dancing!? I have a nephew that's close in age (15) that has never heard of the movie!!!


    Just for the record: I simply loved "The Sixteen Year Old Virgin"! It was really exciting, especialy the shady Elizabeth/uncle Jack plot...can´t wait to see what happens next!!! :D and of course...amn always delightfull and sexy Serenate sight, though I dislike they fighting all the time. I want them to be sexy, fun and careless!!!


    i'd have to minus 20 for the line about chuck's hotel being boycotted by conservative christian groups. they really don't care... it would be the liberal feminist groups like code pink boycotting him and calling him a sexist pig or something. but the writers probably had a political agenda. *just incase anyone wonders...i am a libertarian


    seriously...serena should start going to college man
    and i agree with @rel


    It's really cute for Chair to have photos of each other and all, but could they PLEASE stop using promo pictures for them? Christ, even Twilight had a candid!


    WHERE THE HELL IS ERIC? Pretty sure he would have been a huge part off this storyline considering it was jenny moving out and all.. minus 500


    Where was the posed portrait from Chair?
    I want to see it :D