TV Fanatic Works Better with Prime Instant Video
40,000 other titles are available to watch now.

Lost Review: "The Candidate"

by at . Comments

You've heard of a blood bath, right?

This week, Lost - shockingly, dramatically, poignantly - introduced us to a sub bath.

Lapidus is dead. Sayid is dead. Sun is dead. Jin is dead. And, after months of debate, let there be no doubt: the Man in Black is not anyone's friend.

We've been aware that not all characters would make it to the series finale, but we never expected so many deaths to take place in one episode.

When asked why "The Candidate" was filled with such sorrow, producer Carlton Cuse told EW.com it was to prove that the "show is willing and capable of killing anyone." Also, to send a message about the man masquerading as Locke:

“There is no ambiguity. He is evil and he has to be stopped."

Explosive Photo

Because there was little mythology this week (the show is saving that for next week's monumental episode, which focuses entirely on the history of Smokey and Jacob), let's mourn those whose island lives have come to and end...

Lapidus: Always good for a wise crack to lighten the mood, we'll miss this pilot, about whom we must wonder: why was he on the island? We never got a real flashback, his presence never served much of a point. Will we ever learn more about this character? Or was he simply around so we would believe the castaways might leave via the plane because a pilot was among them?

Sayid: In the end, he proved to be good. Following his actions in the war, this was a man that believed he was eternally damned. Even when he fell in love (Nadia, Shannon), he was around when those women died. These tragedies allowed Sayid to wallow in his own form of self-pity, which manifested itself in violent, dark ways.

But he never fully lost his humanity, and when forced to make a split-section decision, he made the ultimate sacrifice for his friends. The question, of course, remains: what the heck happened to him? What "darkness" was Dogen referring to and how did the Temple make him into such a zombie? We assume these answers are to come.

Sun & Jin: Their reunion lasted a week, but their death will be remembered for a lot longer than that. I was afraid for their lives as soon as viewers were made privy to the conversation about daughter Ji Yeon staying with Sun's mother. Dropping that nugget on us didn't bode well for the girl's parents.

One complaint about this death scene: no mention of Ji Yeon? Really?!? As admirable as it was for Jin to remain with his wife, I was distracted by the thought that Sun should be pleading with Jin to leave, for the sake of their daughter.

The tears Lost fans will shed over this couple's passing speaks as much to the show's brilliance as it does to the pair's love. It's impossible not to think back to the first season, where Sun and Jin weren't close, where the former had recently contemplated leaving the latter, and where the latter didn't even speak English.

Fast forward a few years and they became one of the most iconic couples in TV history. It's a testament to Lost that - while throwing jaw-dropping twists, turns and storylines at us - it could also develop such layered, interesting characters. It's their journey that truly carries this show.

Of course, Sun and Jin's demise also makes us think: they were drowned. So was Charlie. The island is submerged in the Sideways World. Is there any significance to these watery deaths?

Among other notes, observations and questions from the episode:

  • Fake Locke clearly planted the explosives on the plane and had a plan all along. But he also grabbed the watch off that dead guy, making it seem a bit impromptu. Earlier in the hour, Widmore told his group to speed up its plans for the fence because "he's coming."
  • It may mean nothing and it may be nit picky, but there have been multiple instances such as these where things didn't go exactly according to plan (another example: Widmore had yelled at his team previously for picking up Jin earlier than discussed). Might Jacob be pulling some strings, putting little dents into these machinations, all with some grander goal in mind?
  • They didn't throw in that shot of Jin, alive, in the Sideways World randomly. I continue to believe this is the universe in which the characters will all end up.
  • Bernard!!!
  • Locke's Sideways life raises numerous questions: He may have the love of Helen, but he's in the wheelchair, wrecked with the guilt of essentially killing his father, with whom he shared a close, loving relationship. Almost every other character's Sideways world has been free from such burdens. These individuals may be realizing that they're missing something in their lives, but only Locke is faced with such an overriding hardship. Why? What makes him different?
  • Push the button. I wish you believed me. Chilling moments, chilling words from an unconscious Locke and sentimental reminders of important instances on the island. Also, triggers to a connection with the Island world? Jack's reiteration of the second line stopped Locke in his tracks.

What did you think of the episode? Can you believe so many characters were killed at once? Is there anything more heartbreaking than Hurley crying? Sound off now about the most memorable developments from "The Candidate."

Review

Editor Rating: 4.8 / 5.0
  • 4.8 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.8 / 5.0 (83 Votes)

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.

Tags: ,
Avatar

I WAS SHOCKED WHEN JIN AND SUN DIED WHEN I FINALLY THOUGHT HE COULD REALLY SEE HIS DAUGHTER AND BE A HAPPY FAMILY ALL OVER AGAIN
IT WAS A BIG LOST FOR ALL OF US LOSTS FANS ESPECIALLY WHEN HERLY FOUND OUT THAT ANOTHER GOOD FRIEND IS DEAD THAT MOMENT BROKE MY HEART THE ONE THING IM THANKFUL FOR IS THAT SAWYER IS ALIVE THANK GOD FOR A MINUTE I THOUGH THEY COULD DO IT AND KILL HIM BUT LUCKILY HE SURVIVED

Avatar

A NOTE ON LOST'S LAST EPISODE It was fantastic! it was a beatiful way of unifying some afterlife concepts together. . . and for those who didn't like waking up at 5am on monday and didn't like the episode... Well WHAT WERE U EXPECTING A 3D MIRACLE COMING OUT OF YOUR TV! Joking! People are rating it as crap because there were a few lifes (characters such as Harly/Desmon) that weren't explained how or when they died, but didn't you hear the part where Jacks Dad said "THERE IS NOT NOW, HERE" and "YOU ALL BUILT THIS PLACE" and "EVERYONE DYES SOMETIME". . . Really in my view and surely other people agree, this episode was very spiritual and brilliantly clever how the producers manage to reunited the concepts of "Reencarnation"," Time Travel", "A place where you finally meet with everyone you love" from which some people re-encarnate and other finally move on to a bright light. And YES! we all wish there was more lost, but wasn't that the feeling it always left you with, at the end of each episode? It was and is the BEST 6 SERIES THAT I'VE EVER WATCHED" & "I'LL DO IT AGAIN IF COULD ERAISE MY MEMORY"

Avatar

I do not think Jin is dead. In beginning of the show they made a huge deal about Jin's father being a fisherman so I have to wonder if he a good enough swimmer to get out of sub or if he finds a air tank. We never saw Jin die, just his hand let go.

Avatar

When I saw the episode and saw Bernard I asked my self where are Bernard and Rose on the island are they still alive???
It was a really great episode I loved it!!

Avatar

Great episode .. this show finally coming down to a final confrontation between Jack and Locke, we all knew this would be the case since S1. Jack is finally starting to figure Smokey out and Im sure by the finale will know how to either stop him or destroy him and assume his role as the new Jacob. Interesting news that the finale will be 2hrs 30 min now.. must have lots of goodies to answer and more teasers to love us wondering for the rest of time lol.

Avatar

I doubt that Frankenlocke planted the explosives on the plane. More likely it was Ben and Richard. Why is Locke so tortured in Un-Crash Land? Because in the other reality he is doing the torturing. Karma. And there are more deaths to come. Be afraid. Be very afraid.

Avatar

obviously Sun & Jin's death was devastating, my biggest questions after last night:
1. Is Frank really dead? We saw all three other characters die, but Frank just got hit in the head with the door...maybe there's hope? I think he has some purpose we still haven't learned yet.
2. Where the HELL is Benjamin Linus (and Richard and Miles)??? They've been MIA for 2 episodes now? my guess is that we don't see them again til the end of the finale, and Ben will save the day or something. and statement:
Jack is the new man of faith,
Sawyer is the new man of science.

Mr probst

What a phenomenal episode last night. One of my favorites.

Avatar

oh man, i can't stop crying. this sucks. this really sucks. in one episode, they kill off sun,jin, sayid and lapidus. if they kill off hurley, i am not going to be one happy camper!(

Avatar

If I'm not mistaken, Frank was originally supposed to be the pilot of Oceanic 815. So I'm guessing that he keeps ending up there because it was his "destiny". This was an amazing episode, way better than 2 weeks ago, but not as good as Ab Aetermo. I'm hoping next week keeps it going. The writers can't let us down now!