Grey's Anatomy Season Premiere Review: "With You I'm Born Again" Comments (Page 3)
48 Comments
StevenTong
September 24th, 2010 11:06 AM
I love this episode, but I don't like April being around. She's annoying, just the same as last season finale.
spanishfan
September 24th, 2010 10:45 AM
Do you think that being cruel deserves a high 5? Then all of you (the ones who think that) deserves nothing good in life, because being cruel is not right, NEVER. ALEX HAS BEEN THROUGH A LOT, AND HE IS JUST TRYING TO PROTECT HIMSELF. Since now, I think I am going to hate Lexie, who does she thinks she is? Poor Alex, he deserves a lot more than what Shonda is giving him.
I am so dissappointed with some people in here...who do you think you are to say that being cruel is what Alex deserved? NO ONE should be treated like that.
Brittany
September 24th, 2010 10:38 AM
Okay Loved it all but i feel like i gotta defend Alex. I have a wierd soft spot for him. Let's keep in mind his enormous trauma befor the shooting. His mother was crazy, Rebecca/Ava was crazy, and for all intents and purposes, Izzie was crazy too. And thats only what Shonda let us know. He reall would probably snap himself if he had another crazy Chick and even though he didnt handle it well its pretty obvious to me that Lex is not all the way okay. Plus I was never a die hard fan of their relationship. It was really just an overly forced rebound that you wanted to work cuz you wanted them to have some happiness.
colin
September 24th, 2010 10:35 AM
i agree that chyler is a good actress but i think alex is suffering a lot more than her, and saying that he has gone back to his 'old' self isnt the right
term, he has reverted to putting his guard up. alex is a better character
than her anyday, he has more depth and has been a favourite from the start. he has had a lot more happen to
him in s6 than lexie has had happen to ger in the duration of time she has been on the show. so i say go alex, give him a good storyline i have missed justina great acting. ps loving the new season x
deliane
September 24th, 2010 10:08 AM
.. wish Bailey hadn't bailed on the gas man-- tenderness is what heals, Bailey (imho)
and yes, cheers for Chief Webber's moves-
and, as usual, Sandra Oh's acting chops
Slash
September 24th, 2010 9:43 AM
Chyler was awesome!!But I'm a little disappointed.It's not the best Grey's SP that I've seen.It was good but,I don't know,1 hour is too short,ABC made a mistake on that point.
MsWinston
September 24th, 2010 9:30 AM
Mark and Lexie are my favorite couple and hope the writer brings them back together this season. That whole grandchild storyline last season was a real turnoff -- there was no valid reason for the couple to break up. And I say this as a grandparent who dotes on her grandchildren -- you can love more than one person at a time.
llAsHLeYll
September 24th, 2010 9:20 AM
OK, I was blown away for the entire episode. I was so pissed at Derek Shephard. And that my friends, is HUGE! I never get mad at him. He's FREAKIN McDreamy!!! I'm so worried he is just going to plummit and hit rock bottom, bc even tho some people may think he's already there, he's no where near there. But, in a way I feel like this is something that is inevitable to his character. We have seen Mer hit that point, (drowning), so I think this is going to be a very important piece to the MerDer puzzle.
At first, I was with Meredith, on the whole Dr. Perkins is crazy giving Lexie and Derek the clear to operate, but I thought about it a little more. I think I understand his reasoning. Derek and Lexie have began to deal with there issue.....allbeit they may be scary as hell right now (especially Derek), but Meredith isn't dealing. She refuses to talk about the miscarriage is a HUGE thing. The way I see it, is Alex and Derek they have those scares that will always be visible, but Mer she h
McBaby! Rank: Guest Star
September 24th, 2010 9:02 AM
I was glad that it showed April apologizing to Derek. She realized that she shouldn't have left the office. I think April is going to be ok.
IT was sooooo sad when Derek said Let's make a baby! The look on Mer's face! :(
Me
September 24th, 2010 8:45 AM
All I gotta say is that this "Think less, just do" Derek better damn well not cheat on Mer. Poor girl has been through so much in her life, she deservers her man to not be an idiot. And I still don't like April...
Julie
September 24th, 2010 8:23 AM
I think it's pretty damn sad that you're applauding Lexie being cruel to Alex. Yes, he was a being a jerk but he wasn't being outright cruel. Throwing the fact that when he delirious and dying he called for his wife - the only woman he's ever loved - who walked out on him after everything he did for her, is just plain CRUEL. Alex needed to be called out for being a jerk but Lexie shouldn't have gone there (mentioning Izzie). Plus, Alex got divorced, shot and nearly died in a short amount of time. He's got reasons to have his walls up again and try to protect himself from getting even more hurt. At least Izzie understood why Alex would react this way when he got hurt and knew how to deal with it (early season 5). Meredith gets Alex too. But Lexie... she needs to go drink her juicebox and shut the hell up.
Lina
September 24th, 2010 7:59 AM
Lexie saying that to Alex was badass! And I just LOVED the Calzona scenes! HILARIOUS when Callie brought up "Blow dryer" in the movin in-invitation hahaha! Can't wait to see them living together for real and see how this relationship developes! (To bad we'll miss a lot since J.Cap is goin on maternity leave soon)
I LOVED this episode and I think this season is going to be one of the best. Season 5 and 6 is my favorite seasons so far, it's going to be fun to see if this one is going to top them? And I agree, Now i'm TOTALLY over Alex and Lexie!!
btw, the Lexie-breakdown, Good job Chyler!! Great scene! It's going to fun to see how especially Lexie and Baylie will chnage during this season. Cos' I think that's those two who will change the most. And also, I still don't like April. But I'm over hating her, I think she will be this slitly ittatating character that will grow for each episode and who you will come to love in the end of the series!
RaXXX Rank: Guest Star
September 24th, 2010 7:52 AM
Well said! Lexie truly deserves a High 5! I was feeling the same way! I feel Lexie is gonna be one of the characters to watch out for in S7.. other than the Fab 5 ( or as they are now Tremendous 3 as the two we miss very much have moved on :( )
Meredith: Get this baby out of me safely and you can have whatever you want.
September 24th, 2010 11:06 AM
I love this episode, but I don't like April being around. She's annoying, just the same as last season finale.
September 24th, 2010 10:45 AM
Do you think that being cruel deserves a high 5? Then all of you (the ones who think that) deserves nothing good in life, because being cruel is not right, NEVER. ALEX HAS BEEN THROUGH A LOT, AND HE IS JUST TRYING TO PROTECT HIMSELF. Since now, I think I am going to hate Lexie, who does she thinks she is? Poor Alex, he deserves a lot more than what Shonda is giving him.
I am so dissappointed with some people in here...who do you think you are to say that being cruel is what Alex deserved? NO ONE should be treated like that.
September 24th, 2010 10:38 AM
Okay Loved it all but i feel like i gotta defend Alex. I have a wierd soft spot for him. Let's keep in mind his enormous trauma befor the shooting. His mother was crazy, Rebecca/Ava was crazy, and for all intents and purposes, Izzie was crazy too. And thats only what Shonda let us know. He reall would probably snap himself if he had another crazy Chick and even though he didnt handle it well its pretty obvious to me that Lex is not all the way okay. Plus I was never a die hard fan of their relationship. It was really just an overly forced rebound that you wanted to work cuz you wanted them to have some happiness.
September 24th, 2010 10:35 AM
i agree that chyler is a good actress but i think alex is suffering a lot more than her, and saying that he has gone back to his 'old' self isnt the right
term, he has reverted to putting his guard up. alex is a better character
than her anyday, he has more depth and has been a favourite from the start. he has had a lot more happen to
him in s6 than lexie has had happen to ger in the duration of time she has been on the show. so i say go alex, give him a good storyline i have missed justina great acting. ps loving the new season x
September 24th, 2010 10:08 AM
.. wish Bailey hadn't bailed on the gas man-- tenderness is what heals, Bailey (imho)
and yes, cheers for Chief Webber's moves-
and, as usual, Sandra Oh's acting chops
September 24th, 2010 9:43 AM
Chyler was awesome!!But I'm a little disappointed.It's not the best Grey's SP that I've seen.It was good but,I don't know,1 hour is too short,ABC made a mistake on that point.
September 24th, 2010 9:30 AM
Mark and Lexie are my favorite couple and hope the writer brings them back together this season. That whole grandchild storyline last season was a real turnoff -- there was no valid reason for the couple to break up. And I say this as a grandparent who dotes on her grandchildren -- you can love more than one person at a time.
September 24th, 2010 9:20 AM
OK, I was blown away for the entire episode. I was so pissed at Derek Shephard. And that my friends, is HUGE! I never get mad at him. He's FREAKIN McDreamy!!! I'm so worried he is just going to plummit and hit rock bottom, bc even tho some people may think he's already there, he's no where near there. But, in a way I feel like this is something that is inevitable to his character. We have seen Mer hit that point, (drowning), so I think this is going to be a very important piece to the MerDer puzzle.
At first, I was with Meredith, on the whole Dr. Perkins is crazy giving Lexie and Derek the clear to operate, but I thought about it a little more. I think I understand his reasoning. Derek and Lexie have began to deal with there issue.....allbeit they may be scary as hell right now (especially Derek), but Meredith isn't dealing. She refuses to talk about the miscarriage is a HUGE thing. The way I see it, is Alex and Derek they have those scares that will always be visible, but Mer she h
Rank: Guest Star
September 24th, 2010 9:02 AM
I was glad that it showed April apologizing to Derek. She realized that she shouldn't have left the office. I think April is going to be ok.
IT was sooooo sad when Derek said Let's make a baby! The look on Mer's face! :(
September 24th, 2010 8:45 AM
All I gotta say is that this "Think less, just do" Derek better damn well not cheat on Mer. Poor girl has been through so much in her life, she deservers her man to not be an idiot. And I still don't like April...
September 24th, 2010 8:23 AM
I think it's pretty damn sad that you're applauding Lexie being cruel to Alex. Yes, he was a being a jerk but he wasn't being outright cruel. Throwing the fact that when he delirious and dying he called for his wife - the only woman he's ever loved - who walked out on him after everything he did for her, is just plain CRUEL. Alex needed to be called out for being a jerk but Lexie shouldn't have gone there (mentioning Izzie). Plus, Alex got divorced, shot and nearly died in a short amount of time. He's got reasons to have his walls up again and try to protect himself from getting even more hurt. At least Izzie understood why Alex would react this way when he got hurt and knew how to deal with it (early season 5). Meredith gets Alex too. But Lexie... she needs to go drink her juicebox and shut the hell up.
September 24th, 2010 7:59 AM
Lexie saying that to Alex was badass! And I just LOVED the Calzona scenes! HILARIOUS when Callie brought up "Blow dryer" in the movin in-invitation hahaha! Can't wait to see them living together for real and see how this relationship developes! (To bad we'll miss a lot since J.Cap is goin on maternity leave soon)
I LOVED this episode and I think this season is going to be one of the best. Season 5 and 6 is my favorite seasons so far, it's going to be fun to see if this one is going to top them? And I agree, Now i'm TOTALLY over Alex and Lexie!!
btw, the Lexie-breakdown, Good job Chyler!! Great scene! It's going to fun to see how especially Lexie and Baylie will chnage during this season. Cos' I think that's those two who will change the most. And also, I still don't like April. But I'm over hating her, I think she will be this slitly ittatating character that will grow for each episode and who you will come to love in the end of the series!
Rank: Guest Star
September 24th, 2010 7:52 AM
Well said! Lexie truly deserves a High 5! I was feeling the same way! I feel Lexie is gonna be one of the characters to watch out for in S7.. other than the Fab 5 ( or as they are now Tremendous 3 as the two we miss very much have moved on :( )