CSI: NY Review: "Scared Stiff"

at . Comments

An axiom from Sherlock Holmes suits this week’s episode, "Scared Stiff," well.

Sherlock once stated that, “when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth.” And, so, a divine balance was played out between ghost stories and the truth found only in the evidence on CSI: NY.

This episode was a delight, and I’m a little disappointed that it didn’t get to air a little closer to Halloween when it could have really spooked and excited. Then again, I think the paranormal undertones worked well regardless of the season.

John Laroquette on CSI: NY

The CSIs traded fantastic ghost stories during the first half of the episode and set the tone for creepiness in the rest of the show as the team investigated the death of a woman who was suffocated with no outward signs of an attack.

It was also nice to hear a black widow spider myth debunked by Danny that set Flack straight.

The secondary story of Chief Carver’s sister’s body being discovered was a fair distraction and an obvious set up for next week’s episode. I was as engrossed in the mystery surrounding the chief’s sister as I was in the main story. In point of fact, I was disappointed when the episode ended and I realized I was going to have to wait a whole week for the answer to that sub-plot.

John Larroquette has done a stellar job as Chief Carter, and his character’s relationship with Mac Taylor is an odd mix of respect and annoyance.

The character of Jo Danville (Sela Ward) seemed to have found her stride now that a handful of episodes had elapsed. The character seemed more comfortable in the team dynamic, but there remained a nagging sense of over perfection that has been with the character from the beginning.

She seemed a bit too good for the New York team at the start, but I have begun to see the tiny flaws that kept the character from being a complete saint.

I’ve been very pleased with this season of CSI: New York. There have been some mediocre episodes, but for the most part the show has been strong. This was a relief since the exit of one main character for another held the possibility for disaster.

Happily, CSI: New York has avoided that, and hopefully it shall continue to.

Review

Editor Rating: 4.6 / 5.0
  • 4.6 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.6 / 5.0 (9 Votes)
Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more CSI: NY?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

From Around the Web

    More From TV Fanatic

    Past-transgressions

    Graceland Review: Unintended Consequences?

    The road to healing and closure is a long one. Some of our agents are on it, others are struggling. Check out our Graceland review of "Magic Number" now.
    Safety-concerns

    The Bridge Review: Finger, Hand, Ear?

    On tonight's The Bridge, Sonya and Marco deal with the aftermath of saving Eva. With their lives in danger, how will they protect her?
    Fighting-the-sec

    Suits Review: Always a Choice

    Jeff and Jessica try to fight off the SEC, while Mike struggles to make good on an investment, causing more rifts as he does it. Can Pearson Specter survive the onslaught? Read our Suits review of "Leveraged" now.
    A-distrubing-encounter

    Extant Review: Welcome Home

    On the Extant series premiere, astronaut Molly returns from a 13-month trip to space with a condition that seems impossible. Read the review for details!

    Nicky79

    thnks 4 the review! i relly enjoy this show and this episode was awesome... love it!

    Avatar

    John Larroquette had 0:17 at the most in the episode. I'm baffled as to the people who say he did a good job. He's been doing these odd split-second guest appearances for a while now.

    Avatar

    Great review! It was a really good episode and this show doesn't get the credit it deserves... One of my favorite.

    Avatar

    wow that was quite a surprise this morning when i opened ur site and saw a review of one of my favorite shows. thank u