17 Comments New Comment Subscribe

Misskitten

@Aries93 Actually Violet's description of her rape (in 2x07 when she confides in Dell) was "I was twenty, in college and a man broke into my dorm... and it was awful... and violent... and... awful"

So this new list of details actually doesn't break canon. She never said there was a door or that she heard banging. For someone to break in it doesn't mean they have to actually break whatever it is they use as their portal to get in. It's still very much a break-in.

Avatar

@geo b: You might wanna watch some more episodes before passing judgement on the way Charlotte is dealing with this, you simply don't know her. KaDee'w work has been truly amazing on this.

Avatar

yet you care enough to post about it! :)

Avatar

last night was only the 3rd episode i've ever watched. yes, charlotte is hurting, yes, she needs help. but i find myself strangely unsympathetic to someone who basically used people to get what she needed-the urgent care- even though one of them risks her career by helping her,instead of being grateful charlotte is scornful, mean and uncaring. [her voice-to add to my irritation- is nails on a chalk board]. personally i really don't care how this is resolved.

Avatar

This storyline and the acting of KaDee is really heartbreaking! It's hard to watch, but until know this season of PP is really the best one.

Aries93

Other then that, does anyone else agree that Private Practice switched the details of Violets rape? In season 2 I believe it was, "I heard banging on the door and a man broke in". Now it's "I left my window open on a hot summer night". Hate when shows cannot stick to a simple detail like that.

Aries93

I really liked this episode. But right now I think other cases are not as fascinating as the storyline on Charlotte. Is it just me or does EVERYONE else feel the same?




You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Sign In or Register