TV Fanatic Mid-Season Report Card: Glee 12/23/2010

at . Comments

With our favorite prime time shows on hiatus, TV Fanatic is taking a look back at some buzzed-about programs and grading their performance this fall, with a look toward 2011.

Earlier, we examined House. Up now: Glee.

Best episode: "The Substitute." Gwyneth Paltrow simply radiated excitement and energy throughout this hour. The one drawback? It made me wish Holly Holiday was the leader of New Directions instead of Will. But it also showcased Glee at its best: great songs, funny lines and sheer fun.

Sectionals Song

Worst episode: "Britney/Brittany." This wasn't a showcase for storylines or characters. It just served as an excuse to feature a few Britney Spears songs. It came across like a shallow, paid advertisement for the pop star.

Best character: Brittany. She's done the impossible, out Sue Sylvestering Sue Sylvester in terms of the best
one-liners from the season. Aside from cracking us up with her belief that "adultery" means acting like "a dolt," though, Brittany also caused us to tear up with her adorable sensitivity, as best evidenced in the Christmas episode.

Worst character: Will Schuester. It's hard to see where they're really going with Will. He creeped us out with his quasi stalking of Emma and he spends every episode lecturing the students. But can you blame them for not always listening to someone whose own life is such a mess?

Best performance: It's too difficult to choose between so many incredibly-sung renditions ("Teenage Dream" and "Le Jazz" would likely top that list), so gonna go with "Valerie" from Sectionals here. Seriously, I could watch Brittany and Asia Mike dance around on stage for hours.

Best cast addition: Sam and Blaine (tie). Sorry, can't choose between these stud muffins. All I can say is that their presence makes me hopeful that all will be okay when various characters graduate in 2012.

Hopes for 2011: Fewer societal messages, more focus on relationship developments. When Glee tackles an issue such as religion or homosexuality within the context of well-written, planned-out storylines, it can have an affect like no show on television.

But when it tries too hard to hammer certain points home (e.g. bullying), it comes across like a PSA that doesn't ever treat characters as human beings, but just as message-delivering props.

Overall grade: B.

Agree or disagree with our assessment? Sound off now in our Glee forum!

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.


Sorry -- forgot to offer that I liked "Duets" as the best episode of the second season.


I'm not sure Brittany's the best character because I liked how they used her last year as comic relief (so many great quotes!). I suppose how good she was last year earned the actress more screen time. Anyhow, do mean to agree Will is the worst character -- you definitely have that right, and can't imagine what they mean to do with him. All I can think is that classic musical comedy uses a lot of stock characterizations on the periphery (probably because so much of the story time is taken up by musical numbers) and that Will has become some kind of caricature (but not sure of what). And what I would like to see is more story lines that involve Rachel -- and not as the dumpee for everyone else!


I'm actually glad Finn and Rachel broke up! For some reason, I cannot stand them right now. They do need a break from each other. This season they've just been rather annoying. Other than that, I love this season so far!


I agree with the Bgrade for season 2 of Glee so far, but I would have to give a big F to Ryan Murphy and co-authors of the show for breaking up FINNCHEL. Seriously, That's THE COUPLE of the show. Can't they see that its ruinning the show, and they whill lose fans!!!

Tags: ,

Glee Quotes

[to Finn] You know, I don't really know what's going to happen between us, but I know that you used to be the guy that would make me feel like the most special girl in the whole world, and it doesn't feel that way anymore. Now it just feels sad and confusing. And the worst part is that it doesn't even feel that bad anymore.


I'm engorged with venom, and triumph.