Grey's Anatomy Review: The Musical Episode Comments (Page 4)
498 Comments
Penny
April 29th, 2011 12:21 PM
I loved it! Best episode so far this season!
asdfghjkl
April 28th, 2011 8:55 PM
This was the worst thing I have ever seen in my enitre life. I have watched every episode of Grey's but this just sucked. I hope they never do it ever again or I will stop watching. I couldn't even finish that crap. After the first 10 minutes I wanted to bunch my hand threw the TV!
Debra
April 28th, 2011 12:16 AM
I love this episode so much I watched it twice. Just because something is different it doesn’t make it bad. People are creatures of habit and comfort so step outside of your comfort zone long enough to enjoy something new. The comment that the baby looks like a quail is just ignorance rearing its ugly head. My son was born at 28 weeks and a friend’s son was born at 26 weeks, babies that premature do look very much like the one on this wonderful and powerful episode.
Lost in the 50's
April 26th, 2011 4:46 PM
Not my favorite episode. A little too "out there" for me. But I still enjoy Grey's.
Kelly
April 25th, 2011 8:03 PM
Just rewatched the ep and still LOVE IT!,!!!!! Can't wait to buy sound track.
Jane
April 25th, 2011 5:53 AM
I thought it was a great episode. I actually didn't like all of the singing - Sara and Chandra have great voices, but I didn't think the rest were too good. But it seemed to make so much sense, what songs were sung and when, and overall it was so effective that the qualities of the individual voices didn't matter. I wouldn't necessarily want Grey's to do this again, but as a once off it was really powerful and really interesting.
Guest
April 24th, 2011 5:01 PM
I have always loved Greys and
think it's absolutelty amazing,
and the music is part of that.
But to make this particular episode
a musical was horrible! I understand
the concept and where they were coming
from in trying this. However, this was
an amazing episode, and it was difficult
and disturbing to watch with all the
freakin singing!!!
part time viewer
April 17th, 2011 8:05 PM
I dont' watch Grey's that much. But it seemed odd that Yang was being stripped to her braw on the stove and singing while her co-worker was dying.
The music distracted from what should have been a very powerful episode.
plus their baby looked like a quail.
aysedog
April 16th, 2011 5:39 PM
I have always loved how Grey's Anatomy uses music and I've discovered so many artists that I now love thanks to Greys but I really did not like to hear the doctors singing. I've seen the Scrubs musical episode and the music made sense because there was a story around in. It just really didn't make sense for everyone to be singing in this episode, nor did it make sense for Callie to say "music" when taken out of the ambulance. A connection should have been made for them to be able to pull this off. Additionally many of the songs seemed completely irrelevant. When I heard they were making a soundtrack it kind of fell into place in my mind why they would include some songs though, to have variation in the album and thus sell more probably. Background music is what Greys does best, it increases the drama, passes across the emotion really well... This just made me laugh and feel embarrassed as well as disappointed. I wanted to feel the excitement and tension about what would happen to Calli
I loved it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Loved the music, loved the power, the surprise, thought the voices were great.... Truly amazing.
whatthedude
April 16th, 2011 8:04 AM
What the hell were they thinking going on with this ?
IT IS TERRIBLE, HORRIBLE!!!! It's just wrong in so many ways. Callie's the only one that's got a good voice, the rest=virus to my ears.
I don't like it. I hope they never do it again, or i will no longer watch this show, even though I'm a HUGE x1000 Fan!!!!
Mariana
April 16th, 2011 2:47 AM
L O V E I T!!! it was great!!! i cant understand why everybody is complanig so fuckig much!!!
Groffles love Rank: Regular Character
April 15th, 2011 8:28 AM
it was well and truly horrible.
angella
April 14th, 2011 5:05 PM
This was absolutely breath taking. I thouroughly enjoyed this epidose. I was in a trance throughout the entire episode. Every fiber of my being was electrified by every scene and every song.I love the ruggedly handsome Owen Hunt and to hear his melodic scotish voice bellowing those beautiful notes...soothed my soul.lol. I loved Callie and lexy..they were brilliant, phenomenal and miranda "little powershouse" bailey was very good. Great work Grey's Anatomy.
angella
Robin
April 14th, 2011 9:36 AM
The musical was horrible, horrible horrible. I hated it, just show the show.
anuflas Rank: Regular Character
April 14th, 2011 2:16 AM
All I can say is that my love for PD went through the roof. At least someone had the dignity and integrity to not be involved in this mess.
Terrible doesn't begin to cover how bad it was.
Lynn
April 13th, 2011 8:38 PM
i hated the musical. absolutely hated it.
Lauren
April 13th, 2011 1:39 PM
Well I really enjoyed the episode but I don't think they should make a habit out of it. The amount of drama and the way that the songs were integrated was wonderful!
However, it's very clear that some actors are not meant to sing. They seem a bit awkward and unsure of what to do. (Teddy and Owen (although his voice is good) and Meredith).
Overall, I think it was an amazing episode and they did it in a very classy way. Great song choices too!
DeeDee
April 12th, 2011 1:21 AM
the concept of music is new to the show, though the musical episode has been done a few times, if I recall correcly, in other shoes (That 70's Show and Scrubs, for example). I don't remember much dramas doing that though.
However, I'm getting a little sick of the out of bosy experience premise in Grey's. Meredith, Izzie and George have had it (though George didn't make it). Can't recall if Derek had one after he was shot. I understand that the writers needed an excuse for the musical episode, but after years of a similar premise, I expect a bit more. It made sense in the episode, but I hope it doesn't become a recurring theme any more than it already has.
steph
April 11th, 2011 9:41 PM
Unbelievably good! The actress playing Callie deserves an Emmy for her performance.
Lyndyleigh
April 11th, 2011 5:48 PM
Not real crazy about the musical. I prefer just the regular show, so hope the writers don't have this happen again. I watched it, but was bored with the singing.
Dekadent846
April 11th, 2011 4:29 AM
Lose the stupid singing. It Did Not work and was horribly annoying. Lose it or get off the air.
Grey's Anatomy has been a great show until that episode..... can we get back to the medicine, please...?!
At least Patrick Dempsey had the sense not to sing. The rest of the actors seemed forced..... It could be seen in their eyes.
Luca
April 11th, 2011 2:13 AM
This was an embarrassment to watch. Typically I Love this show but stick with what you know! It was a complete rip off of Scrubs My Musical, except was sooo horribly performed. You could see it in the actors eyes, it was so awkward even they weren't convinced they were doing a good job. Thank you Hulu for your easy fast forward function so I could get thru the horrible horrible musical performances.
Cassi
April 10th, 2011 8:36 PM
I absolutely Loved it this was one of the best ones
Chips
April 10th, 2011 8:12 PM
When I first heard that Grey's was doing a musical, I have to say that I wasn't looking forward to the episode at all. But from the moment that Sara sang Chasing Cars to Grace, Universe and U, then the story, I was blown away by her talent as a singer. It wasn't hard to see why Shonda wanted to do this musical with her Tony award winner. Sara has one of the most beautiful voices that I've heard in a while. I can't stop humming her songs in my head. For the most part I give the other cast members a lot of credit for going along with the musical. Hearing the songs on I tunes made it a lot better to listen to them. I thought at times that some of the songs were cheesy. The acting of JCap was outstanding. She was able to show us so much emotion though out the episode. Mark was his usual ass self. I love Alex's for being the only one to show Arizona support. Where are her friends? Mark telling her she was nothing, was like getting punched in the stomach for me. I know he has said some me
Meredith: Get this baby out of me safely and you can have whatever you want.
April 29th, 2011 12:21 PM
I loved it! Best episode so far this season!
April 28th, 2011 8:55 PM
This was the worst thing I have ever seen in my enitre life. I have watched every episode of Grey's but this just sucked. I hope they never do it ever again or I will stop watching. I couldn't even finish that crap. After the first 10 minutes I wanted to bunch my hand threw the TV!
April 28th, 2011 12:16 AM
I love this episode so much I watched it twice. Just because something is different it doesn’t make it bad. People are creatures of habit and comfort so step outside of your comfort zone long enough to enjoy something new. The comment that the baby looks like a quail is just ignorance rearing its ugly head. My son was born at 28 weeks and a friend’s son was born at 26 weeks, babies that premature do look very much like the one on this wonderful and powerful episode.
April 26th, 2011 4:46 PM
Not my favorite episode. A little too "out there" for me. But I still enjoy Grey's.
April 25th, 2011 8:03 PM
Just rewatched the ep and still LOVE IT!,!!!!! Can't wait to buy sound track.
April 25th, 2011 5:53 AM
I thought it was a great episode. I actually didn't like all of the singing - Sara and Chandra have great voices, but I didn't think the rest were too good. But it seemed to make so much sense, what songs were sung and when, and overall it was so effective that the qualities of the individual voices didn't matter. I wouldn't necessarily want Grey's to do this again, but as a once off it was really powerful and really interesting.
April 24th, 2011 5:01 PM
I have always loved Greys and
think it's absolutelty amazing,
and the music is part of that.
But to make this particular episode
a musical was horrible! I understand
the concept and where they were coming
from in trying this. However, this was
an amazing episode, and it was difficult
and disturbing to watch with all the
freakin singing!!!
April 17th, 2011 8:05 PM
I dont' watch Grey's that much. But it seemed odd that Yang was being stripped to her braw on the stove and singing while her co-worker was dying.
The music distracted from what should have been a very powerful episode.
plus their baby looked like a quail.
April 16th, 2011 5:39 PM
I have always loved how Grey's Anatomy uses music and I've discovered so many artists that I now love thanks to Greys but I really did not like to hear the doctors singing. I've seen the Scrubs musical episode and the music made sense because there was a story around in. It just really didn't make sense for everyone to be singing in this episode, nor did it make sense for Callie to say "music" when taken out of the ambulance. A connection should have been made for them to be able to pull this off. Additionally many of the songs seemed completely irrelevant. When I heard they were making a soundtrack it kind of fell into place in my mind why they would include some songs though, to have variation in the album and thus sell more probably. Background music is what Greys does best, it increases the drama, passes across the emotion really well... This just made me laugh and feel embarrassed as well as disappointed. I wanted to feel the excitement and tension about what would happen to Calli
Rank: New User
April 16th, 2011 2:12 PM
I loved it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Loved the music, loved the power, the surprise, thought the voices were great.... Truly amazing.
April 16th, 2011 8:04 AM
What the hell were they thinking going on with this ?
IT IS TERRIBLE, HORRIBLE!!!! It's just wrong in so many ways. Callie's the only one that's got a good voice, the rest=virus to my ears.
I don't like it. I hope they never do it again, or i will no longer watch this show, even though I'm a HUGE x1000 Fan!!!!
April 16th, 2011 2:47 AM
L O V E I T!!! it was great!!! i cant understand why everybody is complanig so fuckig much!!!
Rank: Regular Character
April 15th, 2011 8:28 AM
it was well and truly horrible.
April 14th, 2011 5:05 PM
This was absolutely breath taking. I thouroughly enjoyed this epidose. I was in a trance throughout the entire episode. Every fiber of my being was electrified by every scene and every song.I love the ruggedly handsome Owen Hunt and to hear his melodic scotish voice bellowing those beautiful notes...soothed my soul.lol. I loved Callie and lexy..they were brilliant, phenomenal and miranda "little powershouse" bailey was very good. Great work Grey's Anatomy.
angella
April 14th, 2011 9:36 AM
The musical was horrible, horrible horrible. I hated it, just show the show.
Rank: Regular Character
April 14th, 2011 2:16 AM
All I can say is that my love for PD went through the roof. At least someone had the dignity and integrity to not be involved in this mess.
Terrible doesn't begin to cover how bad it was.
April 13th, 2011 8:38 PM
i hated the musical. absolutely hated it.
April 13th, 2011 1:39 PM
Well I really enjoyed the episode but I don't think they should make a habit out of it. The amount of drama and the way that the songs were integrated was wonderful!
However, it's very clear that some actors are not meant to sing. They seem a bit awkward and unsure of what to do. (Teddy and Owen (although his voice is good) and Meredith).
Overall, I think it was an amazing episode and they did it in a very classy way. Great song choices too!
April 12th, 2011 1:21 AM
the concept of music is new to the show, though the musical episode has been done a few times, if I recall correcly, in other shoes (That 70's Show and Scrubs, for example). I don't remember much dramas doing that though.
However, I'm getting a little sick of the out of bosy experience premise in Grey's. Meredith, Izzie and George have had it (though George didn't make it). Can't recall if Derek had one after he was shot. I understand that the writers needed an excuse for the musical episode, but after years of a similar premise, I expect a bit more. It made sense in the episode, but I hope it doesn't become a recurring theme any more than it already has.
April 11th, 2011 9:41 PM
Unbelievably good! The actress playing Callie deserves an Emmy for her performance.
April 11th, 2011 5:48 PM
Not real crazy about the musical. I prefer just the regular show, so hope the writers don't have this happen again. I watched it, but was bored with the singing.
April 11th, 2011 4:29 AM
Lose the stupid singing. It Did Not work and was horribly annoying. Lose it or get off the air.
Grey's Anatomy has been a great show until that episode..... can we get back to the medicine, please...?!
At least Patrick Dempsey had the sense not to sing. The rest of the actors seemed forced..... It could be seen in their eyes.
April 11th, 2011 2:13 AM
This was an embarrassment to watch. Typically I Love this show but stick with what you know! It was a complete rip off of Scrubs My Musical, except was sooo horribly performed. You could see it in the actors eyes, it was so awkward even they weren't convinced they were doing a good job. Thank you Hulu for your easy fast forward function so I could get thru the horrible horrible musical performances.
April 10th, 2011 8:36 PM
I absolutely Loved it this was one of the best ones
April 10th, 2011 8:12 PM
When I first heard that Grey's was doing a musical, I have to say that I wasn't looking forward to the episode at all. But from the moment that Sara sang Chasing Cars to Grace, Universe and U, then the story, I was blown away by her talent as a singer. It wasn't hard to see why Shonda wanted to do this musical with her Tony award winner. Sara has one of the most beautiful voices that I've heard in a while. I can't stop humming her songs in my head. For the most part I give the other cast members a lot of credit for going along with the musical. Hearing the songs on I tunes made it a lot better to listen to them. I thought at times that some of the songs were cheesy. The acting of JCap was outstanding. She was able to show us so much emotion though out the episode. Mark was his usual ass self. I love Alex's for being the only one to show Arizona support. Where are her friends? Mark telling her she was nothing, was like getting punched in the stomach for me. I know he has said some me