Grey's Anatomy > The Grey's Anatomy Musical Event: What Did You Think? > Comments Page 6
Alex he rocks!!!!!
it was a little awkward at first but "how to save a life" and onwards just flowed and i thought it was a pretty genius idea. cmon, no other show would have the guts to experiment like this!
The open was strong. Sara Ramirez's (Calli) voice was beautiful and sympathetic to the storyline and perhaps she should've been the only one singing. As a viewer, I was able to hear more of her story through her songs.I felt like she was taking me on a journey. I was touched by it- until I heard another voice.
Once the other actors started picking up lines, it became very awkward and almost comical. It definitely interfered with the seriousness of the plot. Combining drama and song isn't easy but the producers nailed it beautifully in the very beginning and at the very end with the lovely Callie.
Story was great, the musical, not much?! It would have been perfect!!!
Alice you sound like a twerp telling people how they should feel. Give it up darling.
DISTRACTING!!! Ruined what would have been a top episode. Is this show trying to compeat with GLEE...well don't. Each show stands on it's own for a reason. Distracting!
This episode was perfect! I absolutely loved it. For the ppl that are giving this ep bad reviews, fyi it was not random singing. Callie was in a state and this was all in her head. You should have expected this, if you didnt like the episode theres a thing called a remote that allows you to change the channel. This was a thank you to the fans from Shonda. Glee is random, Glee is a musical, this wasnt because these songs actually fit with the storyline. So get over it and be happy, geez.
Anyway, happy that mark apologized in his own way to Arizona.
Excited that Callie said yes.
Loved "universe & U" with Callie and Arizona
Loved the emotion in this episode, it was all very well acted/performed. Well done.
mclover101 if you're going to scream, at least learn how to spell!!!
I think yhe show and the music was terrific! Will there be a CD of all the music to purchase?
Awful. Completely and totally awful. The actors did an admirable job, but I think greys anatomy officially jumped the shark tonight.
OMFG THIS WAS BY FAR IN MY TOP FIVE EPISODES!!!!!!!! FIRST CHYLER IS A-MAZING!!!! A FEW COMMENTS
1.IM SUPRISED THEY DIDNT DING " SONG BENEATH THE SONG " MARIA TAYLOR.
2. I HAVE TO AGREE I WAS MOST EXCITED TO HEAR ELLEN SING SHE'S NOT A-AMZING BUT SHE CAN SING WELL ENOUGH TO GET TWO SOLOS.
3. IM VERY MAD THAT PATRICK DIDNT SING, HE SHOULD HAVE SANG WITH ELLEN.
4. MY FAV SONG IS CHASSING CARS AND RUNN'N ON SUNSHINE.
5. I LOVED THE SEEN WITH TEDDY AND HENERY TO CUTE AND HILORIUS!!!
6. I WAS SHOCKED AS TO HOW SHE JUST MADE DEREK STAND THERE AND JUST LISTEN, I WAS SO MAD.
7. IM ALSO VERY EXCITED ABOUT THE PROMO WITH MER STEALING.......
I agree that after the first 15 minutes, the singing was distracting. Some of them cant sing, but that Callie chick could really belt it out. Christina needs a miracle bra.
I did not like it at all. I am a huge greys fan too. but the whole thing was just completely AWKWARD. Good drama.. terrible idea.
can anyone tell me where i could watch this episode online?
This SUCKED!!!!!!!!!!! I hated the music......the episode was very had to follow. Please never do that again.
I thought it was okay, I didn't really expect much. I would've rather there wasn't any singing. A lot of them had pretty good voices. Chandra, for example. I've always loved her voice, and it's cute to see her sing, because she's sort of the mother of everyone on the show, and it's sweet that she would sing to Callie. I also liked Kevin McKidd's voice. Not in How To Save a Life, but in How We Operate, he was pretty amazing, I think. I absolutely adored Eric Dane's voice, and I'm sad that he didn't get to sing more. Finally, Justin Chambers. Whoa. Loved it. His voice was very impressive too.
Anyway, I think the singing was too distracting, I would've rather had the music in the background like usual, than to see the characters walking around and singing to each other like that. The on screen singing was just stiff, I thought. It's not a music video, I take Grey's very seriously, and this episode was just awkward for me, personally. Also, what was up with the scene where everyone was
wow...i liked Mark and Alex sing
Loved the singing. Loved the plot. Not together. It didn't quite match putting the songs and intense drama together.
SUCKED the fuck i look like watching bitches dance and sing no this is a drama ppl not fuckin glee IM PISSED
I totally dug this episode, but wanted more of Arizona singing...she did a whole duet with Callie that they barely showed. Oh well, I thought it was great.
LOVED IT!!! thought the songs were placed exactly right with the scenes...b/c I have a crap memory what season was Breathe used in and do you remember what scene? Thanks
This episode was absolutely amazing...loved every minute of it. Shonda Rhimes and her cast and crew are absolute geniuses. I totally expected it to end like that. All smiles here!!!!!!!
@MarkDW, at the end of the episode Callie woke up and as far as we know the baby was still hanging on. The previews for next week show a fully awake Callie, although the baby needs surgery.
I thought it was awful. I had a hard time following wht was happening because of all the singing. I didn't remember most of the songs. It just came across as corny. I was okay with the first 15 minutes, and then it just got old.
You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.
Remember My Info