Private Practice Review: "Something Old, Something New" Comments (Page 2)
21 Comments
Spindae Rank: Regular Character
May 6th, 2011 11:43 AM
I forgot to mention Amelia! I think she is sick so she can't take alcohol with medicine!
So dereck can stop by and some crossover action at the start of season 5!
And I think this kicking Addison out of the group will mix things up! She will probably dissappear for some time and come back!
Fifi
May 6th, 2011 11:17 AM
Amelia is pregnant,and you know who's kid it will turn out to be? Sam's. Come on, how perfect/ironic would that be? He and Addison broke up over her desire to have a baby and he get's someone else pregnant. He and Amelia had a moment an episode or so ago, where she said things didn't have to be strange between them just because of him and Addison. That made me stop and go,hmmm. It would turn out to be more of a shocker since they never should them actually hooking up.
Does anybody else share this opinion?
Jarrod Mitchell Rank: Leading Character
May 6th, 2011 10:38 AM
I loved this episode more than the Grey's Anatomy one.
I thought the wedding was perfect for these two. Even the choice of venue they decided to go to last minute.
Charlotte and Cooper are fair by the best two characters on the show and I'm glad the wedding happened. I thought something was going to happen towards the end because by the time the wedding came up, there was only 8 minutes left. Far from enough time for everything to play out right. Either way, love the development of the characters and who've they become. :)
Addison, where do I begin? Honestly, I love this girl, but as Naomi said (in regards about her relationship with Sam) "I just hope it was worth it". Those words were much more harsh than the reviewers rating for this episode in my opinion. Honestly, I get why Naomi is disgusting by the fact Addison got with Sam, but what pissed me off more was how Sam himself turned on Addison. I actually wanted to strangle him. I'm glad Addison told him off the way she did. I h
Howie
May 6th, 2011 10:36 AM
I love Private practice, and Addison was my favourite character in Grey's , but I feel like I'm starting to look for reasons to love Addison now. They gave her TOO many flaws without having her redeem herself a little bit more. She needs a good storyline to prove that she still has the magic that made everyone pick her to be the boss back in season 1.
Also, is it just me, or has Private Practice gone so much darker this season? Hell, it's even waayy heavier and more depressing that Grey's Anatomy. I find myself feeling sad and unsatisfied upon watching the last few episodes. I miss the thrill of the fun group interactions they used to have. I hope Shonda knows where she's going with this investigation storyline. It's a very interesting plot, for sure, but I hope in the end everyone does something to show that their practice best because of this system they have in place.
that being said, I loved how cooper and charlotte got married. they are my favourite couple, and to me they
confused
May 6th, 2011 10:34 AM
hi just wondering if anyone can explain the why all of a sudden Amelia can't drink. I know she had a pill problem like Charlotte but also like Charlotte she still drunk alcohol (she was drinking with Cooper the night Charlotte was attacked, doing shots i beleive ) and I'm pretty sure she drinks other times too, unless I'm mistaken then please correct me. Just a little confused to if she has been drinking before why now she asks for ginger ale then spits out the champagne.
tom
May 6th, 2011 10:21 AM
Amelia spitting out her drink could be foregrounding a storyline for her - relapse perhaps?
Spindae Rank: Regular Character
May 6th, 2011 10:19 AM
It was a pretty solid episode!
Don't know what U were watching?! Joke! Everyone can have his opinion!
I love the realistic approach! The writers have done a really good Job!
the Cooper and Charoltte Parent talks were like I was hearing my relatives talking about are family in love!
The naomi, sheldon and five talk were giving some other perspective from Five showing again that he has a heart!
The Addi&Sam realtionship is just how it happens in real live!
The Violet story could've been done better! But I think they are giving some intros for season 4!
I would give them 4 stars at least!
PPFan
May 6th, 2011 9:12 AM
Amelia is so not pregnant. That's about her sobriety
Christiesia
May 6th, 2011 9:03 AM
Amelia is sooooooo pregnant!!! When she spat out her 'champagne' thats a big give away!!!!
renee
May 6th, 2011 8:42 AM
I love Charlotte and Cooper. I was hoping for a big wedding, but these 2 are far from traditional, so I think the getaway wedding was perfect for their characters. She looked amazing!
I am so over Addie and Violet's characters. Addie always acts so righteous yet she goes after her best friend's ex husband and now is miffed that the best friend is angry with her. She is high and mighty except for her own actions. Same holds true for Violet. I have never cared for her character so if she loses her license, that isn't a big deal to me.
Caitlyn Rank: Regular Character
May 6th, 2011 7:30 AM
I think your rating is a little too harsh. The episode wasn't as good as I expected but it wasn't in the range of a 2.5 rating.
I thought the case involving Naomi, Fife, and Sheldon was an unnecessary use of airtime. The only outcome it really had was to show Naomi that Fife was a "good man".
The case of Violet was actually a good beginning to what the finale seems to be about. I know it has something to do with the future of the practice staying together or each one going their own way. I think Violet's situation is what leads to that because the way these people practice medicine isn't as conventional as other places.
As for Charlotte and Cooper's wedding, I'm the first to say that I have been waiting for this to happen since Cooper gave his speech about how he wants her beaming down that aisle. I've always wanted to see their "big white wedding" with an entire entourage and Charlotte walking down an aisle. I was disappointed that they didn't have that nor did they have a l
Addison: Then slowly, over time, everything changes. And you're no longer this young thing, and you don't believe in fairytales and "perfect" isn't in your v...
Rank: Regular Character
May 6th, 2011 11:43 AM
I forgot to mention Amelia! I think she is sick so she can't take alcohol with medicine!
So dereck can stop by and some crossover action at the start of season 5!
And I think this kicking Addison out of the group will mix things up! She will probably dissappear for some time and come back!
May 6th, 2011 11:17 AM
Amelia is pregnant,and you know who's kid it will turn out to be? Sam's. Come on, how perfect/ironic would that be? He and Addison broke up over her desire to have a baby and he get's someone else pregnant. He and Amelia had a moment an episode or so ago, where she said things didn't have to be strange between them just because of him and Addison. That made me stop and go,hmmm. It would turn out to be more of a shocker since they never should them actually hooking up.
Does anybody else share this opinion?
Rank: Leading Character
May 6th, 2011 10:38 AM
I loved this episode more than the Grey's Anatomy one.
I thought the wedding was perfect for these two. Even the choice of venue they decided to go to last minute.
Charlotte and Cooper are fair by the best two characters on the show and I'm glad the wedding happened. I thought something was going to happen towards the end because by the time the wedding came up, there was only 8 minutes left. Far from enough time for everything to play out right. Either way, love the development of the characters and who've they become. :)
Addison, where do I begin? Honestly, I love this girl, but as Naomi said (in regards about her relationship with Sam) "I just hope it was worth it". Those words were much more harsh than the reviewers rating for this episode in my opinion. Honestly, I get why Naomi is disgusting by the fact Addison got with Sam, but what pissed me off more was how Sam himself turned on Addison. I actually wanted to strangle him. I'm glad Addison told him off the way she did. I h
May 6th, 2011 10:36 AM
I love Private practice, and Addison was my favourite character in Grey's , but I feel like I'm starting to look for reasons to love Addison now. They gave her TOO many flaws without having her redeem herself a little bit more. She needs a good storyline to prove that she still has the magic that made everyone pick her to be the boss back in season 1.
Also, is it just me, or has Private Practice gone so much darker this season? Hell, it's even waayy heavier and more depressing that Grey's Anatomy. I find myself feeling sad and unsatisfied upon watching the last few episodes. I miss the thrill of the fun group interactions they used to have. I hope Shonda knows where she's going with this investigation storyline. It's a very interesting plot, for sure, but I hope in the end everyone does something to show that their practice best because of this system they have in place.
that being said, I loved how cooper and charlotte got married. they are my favourite couple, and to me they
May 6th, 2011 10:34 AM
hi just wondering if anyone can explain the why all of a sudden Amelia can't drink. I know she had a pill problem like Charlotte but also like Charlotte she still drunk alcohol (she was drinking with Cooper the night Charlotte was attacked, doing shots i beleive ) and I'm pretty sure she drinks other times too, unless I'm mistaken then please correct me. Just a little confused to if she has been drinking before why now she asks for ginger ale then spits out the champagne.
May 6th, 2011 10:21 AM
Amelia spitting out her drink could be foregrounding a storyline for her - relapse perhaps?
Rank: Regular Character
May 6th, 2011 10:19 AM
It was a pretty solid episode!
Don't know what U were watching?! Joke! Everyone can have his opinion!
I love the realistic approach! The writers have done a really good Job!
the Cooper and Charoltte Parent talks were like I was hearing my relatives talking about are family in love!
The naomi, sheldon and five talk were giving some other perspective from Five showing again that he has a heart!
The Addi&Sam realtionship is just how it happens in real live!
The Violet story could've been done better! But I think they are giving some intros for season 4!
I would give them 4 stars at least!
May 6th, 2011 9:12 AM
Amelia is so not pregnant. That's about her sobriety
May 6th, 2011 9:03 AM
Amelia is sooooooo pregnant!!! When she spat out her 'champagne' thats a big give away!!!!
May 6th, 2011 8:42 AM
I love Charlotte and Cooper. I was hoping for a big wedding, but these 2 are far from traditional, so I think the getaway wedding was perfect for their characters. She looked amazing!
I am so over Addie and Violet's characters. Addie always acts so righteous yet she goes after her best friend's ex husband and now is miffed that the best friend is angry with her. She is high and mighty except for her own actions. Same holds true for Violet. I have never cared for her character so if she loses her license, that isn't a big deal to me.
Rank: Regular Character
May 6th, 2011 7:30 AM
I think your rating is a little too harsh. The episode wasn't as good as I expected but it wasn't in the range of a 2.5 rating.
I thought the case involving Naomi, Fife, and Sheldon was an unnecessary use of airtime. The only outcome it really had was to show Naomi that Fife was a "good man".
The case of Violet was actually a good beginning to what the finale seems to be about. I know it has something to do with the future of the practice staying together or each one going their own way. I think Violet's situation is what leads to that because the way these people practice medicine isn't as conventional as other places.
As for Charlotte and Cooper's wedding, I'm the first to say that I have been waiting for this to happen since Cooper gave his speech about how he wants her beaming down that aisle. I've always wanted to see their "big white wedding" with an entire entourage and Charlotte walking down an aisle. I was disappointed that they didn't have that nor did they have a l