Pretty Little Liars Season Two Premiere Review: Romance & Mystery

at . Comments

"It's Alive."

The title of this episode was likely a reference to Ian's body, but it could very well have been talking about the ongoing drama, mystery and romance of Pretty Little Liars - because this episode made it clear: all are alive and well on season two!

Therapy Visit

Let's start with the love that remained in the air. Both Ezra and Caleb dropped the L word on Aria and Hanna, respectively. What was your reaction to each admission?

I don't doubt both men meant it, but I'm over the icky relationship between teacher and student. There were plenty of reasons all along while these two shouldn't be together, but the arrival of Jackie really should seal their demise. Best to end it now before one of them really gets in trouble.

I'm down with the rekindling of the Haleb flame, however. Haven't we all been tasked with gathering intel on a frenemy of our blind pal, only to eventually take that individual's virginity inside a tent and develop actual feelings for her? I can sympathize with Caleb. I see a future here.

Moving on to the mystery, we were introduced to a therapist, a new "thing" and a bevy of questions. Foremost among them:

Is Ian still alive? No way... right? There was a hooded stranger in that bell tower on the season one finale and I've gotta assume he/she simply moved Ian's body and created the tale that he left town. How would this account for the episode-concluding text of Ian and Melissa's proper baby name?

I have no clue. But there's plenty of information "A" seems to somehow know, all of which will be a challenge for writers to explain when the stalker's identity is finally revealed.

What role will Anne Sullivan play? A key one, creator Marlene King has said. I was certain the girls would tell her about "A" and then we'd learn that Anne has some connection to the mysterious character. But the show took a different turn instead.

Unless that scene with her racing to her car while being seemingly followed was just a red herring. Two more questions: Would four friends ever be permitted to attend grief counseling sessions together? I doubt it. Is there a reason PLL named the therapist after Helen Keller's famous mentor?

Noel is back... and dating Mona? I didn't see that one coming.

What is the Jason thing? I don't know. But it will come up again this season, and Aria will get involved with the man behind the "thing" to which Jenna referred.

How good of a carpenter in Toby? The guy can slice off a section of wall and instantly make it appear as if nothing ever happened? Wow.

Will Emily really move to Texas? Of course not. But the more appropriate question is: how will she avoid it? Seems like a keen opportunity for "A" to swoop in, help out and then demand something in return, sort of like she did with Hanna last season when she helped out with the bank money problem.

Overall, a solid start to season two, wouldn't you say? Granted, the episode somehow didn't show us any of the clothes Hanna purchased during her shopping spree (come on!), but it delivered the sort of intrigue that will force us to tune in on Tuesday nights all summer and ask: What's next?!?


Editor Rating: 4.5 / 5.0
  • 4.5 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.7 / 5.0 (76 Votes)

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.


I loved this episode!!!!!


also you have to remember -A was deleting emily's hard drive


Definitely disagree about Aria and Ezra. I think they are really good together, but to each their own. Surprised there's no mention of Mona and Noel dating or A deleting everything (including the pervy video Ian took) off Emily's comp. Both seem kinda important to me...
And now just a little rant....
How is it that all these girls can sneak out of their houses so easily? And I'm not just talking about this show; it happens in everything. All of their houses have windows or doors that easily and silently open without their parents noticing? Yeah, right!


Are you nuts, Aria and Ezra are the whole reason I watch the show. If they break up, I don't know if I'd continue. I hope they don't break them up. I also like Hannah with Caleb.
The A storyline feels dragged out. I know we can't find out who A is until the show ends but I feel like more questions keep coming up and don't get resolved.


mediocre??? are you kidding me! This was such a solid premiere with a lot of plot to advance it into season 2. I've missed this show :D


over the break i read the whole series and i have to admit it is causing me to be left underwhelmed by the show. i love where the books took things...i knew both A's going into reading it and i still was left very intrigued by what would happen...i just am really worried about how the show will play out....and i am left pining for alot of the relationships in the books!


overall it was an ok episode but im glad caleb is back and im really perplexed as to the whole ian thing!


No answers and even more questions. That's all I got out of this mediocre premiere.

Tags: ,