Prime Suspect Review: "Carnivorous Sheep"

at . Comments

While Prime Suspect had told us to expect a serious toning down of the sexism, beginning with "Carnivorous Sheep," I wasn’t expecting most of Jane's best qualities to be tamed, too.

Yes, the elements of what made Jane such a fantastic character are still there, but along with a reduction in sexism came a reduction in Jane’s bite and it was jarring to watch that in the second episode of the series because there was nothing gradual about it.

Jane on the Streets

Still, I’m willing to give it a little bit of a pass because of the nature of any second episode; you’re no longer a pilot, which means time and budget are now limited. Moreover, the installment is also responsible for setting up a sustainable direction for the series. In the long term, the path Prime Suspect is taking now looks a lot better because that amount of sexism seen on the premiere just wouldn’t fly in 2011.

But I’ve rambled enough about this. We have an episode to discuss!

It appears that once again Jane is the only decent detective on her squad because Duffy and the beef trust are laser focused and convinced that Chris Hughes, a former child molester, is the one who killed a mother and kidnapped her little girl. But Jane has questions.

Hughes was played wonderfully by David Meunier, who you might have recognized from the most recent season of Justified. Jane’s almost instant realization that he wasn’t responsible for the kidnapping, her willingness to go to bat for him, and her attempt to protect him from doing something stupid after the beef trust unnecessarily ruined his clean reputation after prison helped to further set apart Jane and Prime Suspect.

I can’t remember a procedural protagonist that was ever truly sympathetic to a suspect, especially a child molester. Instead of automatically assuming he was guilty and working to build a case around him, Jane was once again more interested in following her gut and checking out all of the angles before assigning blame.

All of that real detective work led Jane to Glenn, who could not be anymore stereotypically guilty unless “I totally did it” was tattooed to his face. Glenn was carrying a grocery bag with cereal, he lived in a creepy apartment with cement for a floor and walls, and his hallway was made of metal and locks. I’m all for pointing out the obvious but I don’t mind a little subtly either.

Aside from the downplay in sexism, this was the other jarring moment for me: the lack of suspense and danger for Jane compared to the pilot. I’m not expecting Jane to take a punch to the face every week, but at least get my heart racing. Instead Glenn ran, Jane caught him in about six seconds, and rescued the little girl.

Overall, Prime Suspect is still a fantastic procedural and Maria Bello is still wonderful to watch. Hopefully, its rough edges will be smoothed out a little more gracefully from here on out.

Other thoughts:

  • Matt’s ex certainly wasn’t toned down. She’s still annoying and might truly be insane. But Jane can still hilariously play her with ease.
  • The title card reminds me of a hastily done PowerPoint slide.
  • Yes, Jane is addicted to coffee and Nicorette, no need to tell us every act.


Editor Rating: 4.0 / 5.0
  • 4.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.2 / 5.0 (24 Votes)

Good show, but what's with the fedora?
Is it supposed to make her quirky? If so, it's not working. It is just a distraction and paired with the ridiculous scarf she constantly wears, it is making the character into a caricature.
Plus the sexism angle is a little tired. It was original when Angie Dickinson faced it on Police Woman, but any show made in the past 10 years is just reaching for a plot.


Great show. Maria Bello normally an extremely beautiful sexy actress transforms Jane T. into a beautiful, tough, smart detective. Hail to the the days of Angie Dickinson's Police Woman. I love the show and the cast. Great work.


I'm pretty sure I disagreed with most of this review. I'm sick of predictability and action for sake of action. This show, I feel, depicts realism with authentic characters and refreshingly honest dialog. It strips out all of the special effects and fluff to create something genuine and gritty. I want to thank NBC for producing a "cop drama" that's actually good for a change. I hope it's on the air for a long time to come...


Totally agree with you Virg. I thought the action it did have was tense enough and was a good episode.


I thought this finally might be one we agree on. Nope. This one captures the true action of police work. Not every day is a fight but the chase makes up most of it. I hope this show unlike Charlies Angels makes it.

Tags: ,

Prime Suspect Season 1 Episode 2 Quotes

Duffy: How ya doin'?
Jane: I could be drunker.
Duffy: Well, maybe I wanna say I'm sorry.
Jane: And maybe I wanna say suck it!

But I'll always still know that you were wrong.