Gossip Girl Review: Who is the Father?! Comments (Page 5)
154 Comments
Kookakicha
October 11th, 2011 2:08 AM
I'm very disappointed with the writers. Keeping us guessing about the identity of the father only to, well keep us guessing again. To me that was unnecessary really. I was happy it wasn't Chuck's but it might be his so I'm going to be unhappy whenever they decide it's fit to tell us.
I'm a big Dair fan but I admit the Chair scene was good. Part of me though thinks it's a little too much like the previous similar scenes they shared before so I wasn't all engaged in it.
I actually consider Dan and Blair's little fight as the best scene of that episode. It was so funny and adorable.
Apart from that, the way Noah tricked Dan was so great. I am so happy he got published!
The Charlie/Ivy thing has potential if we ever get the real Charlie coming around. If it stays that way it may turn out boring. Nate's storyline is blahh as usual. Get him back with Serena or just make sure this Diana/Gossip Girl thing actually gives us a glimpse of Gossip Girl herself.
G
October 11th, 2011 1:44 AM
It's amazing what a Chair scene can do to me. I found 5x01 and 5x02 SO BORING. And until the last 10 minutes I was thinking the same of 5x03. But then come up the chair scene. And you can just feel the tension, love, confusion bettween them. Ed and Leighton, as usually, just nailed it. Now I feel like s5 has finally started.
Jarrod Mitchell Rank: Leading Character
October 11th, 2011 1:40 AM
ABORT THAT BABY AND GET WITH DAN!
LuckyBastarda Rank: Recurring Character
October 11th, 2011 1:32 AM
Oh! And I know I must be steping on TvF's toes right about now, BUT for those who didn't watch next week's promo here it is, directly from YT:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5WYIDwGnu6E
Enjoy!
LuckyBastarda Rank: Recurring Character
October 11th, 2011 1:29 AM
I really, REALLY (and I mean REALLY) hope Chuck IS NOT the father.
Chair blows, it was good for a while, but it's over. Epic my -PEEP-! I -PEEP- EPICNESS!
Just let the characters be. If I wanted to watch a soap opera, I would change the channel.
It's my opinion tough, Chair fans are more than welcome to have theirs.
I'm still hoping for DAIR to happen and to be the "endgame" (another word I hate)
PS: Loved B's dress on the fashion show too... and Leighton rocks the character, kudos to her!
lucy
October 11th, 2011 1:27 AM
I don't think Blair was lying, but perhaps the test was wrong. She looked so brokenhearted that the baby isn't Chuck's. Maybe there was some kind of mix-up at the lab or whatever and Chuck is actually the father. Whatever happens, I'm like 99.5% certain that baby is really Chuck's. Or hey, maybe the prince will die and Chuck will raise the baby with her. You never know.
RODRIGO
October 11th, 2011 1:21 AM
omfg best episode of the season so far 10/10
gossip crazy
October 11th, 2011 1:20 AM
Wow. That Chuck and Blair scene. So much tension you could cut it with a knife. Heartwrenching and beautiful.
But did anyone else find that scene a bit eeriee? The music, the close-ups of the faces, the facial expressions themselves...especially Chuck's. And that scene was packed to the rafters with subtext. I mean, come on. The confusion over Chuck keeping the dog? The seemingly misplaced comment about the Chuck Bass lifestyle? Blair's furrowed eyebrows when Chuck said she must have felt relief? But who knows. GG is notorious for completely changing the direction of their story just to win viewers. Anything is possible at this point. In the end, the Chuck/Blair scene, plus Chuck crying at the end were amazing. So much raw emotion. Absolutely the best I've seen on GG thus far.
On a lighter note, based on the preview, next week's episode looks like great fun. Already counting down the days.
Jeca Rank: Recurring Character
October 11th, 2011 1:19 AM
Let's be honest loui will be the best choice always for the baby and Blair, sure chuck will grow but he will always carry some issues that would come out without noticing, like this can't feel thing, he looked so adorable with monkey!, and I like this girl that plays ivy, shed good , but her arc seem long and very non important , I want to think that is starting but I'm not been pull by it, I missed the mistery from last year with Juliet and Serena, wich seem an inanimate beautiful statue with so little to do,say and give to gg.
LinaRose Rank: New User
October 11th, 2011 1:05 AM
Come on where is the Chair scenes. Pretty much everyone else on this show is boring. Ed and Leighton have this awesome chemistry from the very beginning. Their characters are so complex and the angst. When the characters can make you feel the emotions of the scene, you know its gold. If the other characters are lucky to have a scene with either Ed or Leighton thank the writers. Any scenes with them is upped a notch. Love Chuck's last scene, wonderful actor.
peaceloveandchair!
October 11th, 2011 12:59 AM
Ed Westwick is one hell of an actor, even with just a few scenes, he made the episode... he's really been carrying the show this whole season. He and Leighton have such chemistry on screen, their one scene together gave me butterflies. That child is so his, and he and Blair are so obviously still in love. They need to get them back together already, the show lacks so much sparkle and intrigue without their interaction.
blairchick11492 Rank: Guest Star
October 11th, 2011 12:52 AM
Okay, so. About Blair. I seriously think that she lied to Chuck. Not only did that scene with her hiding the envelope give it away (although she could have hid it so that Louie wouldn't think she had cheated on him, so she HAD to know who the father was. Although she could have shown it to him and said she had it done so that noone else, like the press, could question paternity. I go with the latter as the better choice.) But the reason I think she lied: She didn't want to complicate things. She let Chuck go. Chuck let her go. If she told him it was really his....what were they supposed to do? And telling Louie...that would be the scariest thing in the world to her. Step in her shoes and think about it.
Now, as for the whole book thing....I think it's kindof boring. Along with the Nate plus sex-crazed-social-destroyer-crazy-ass woman storyline. It's just boring, and you already know what's going to happen. You can predict it. I'm not looking forward to next weeks episode if it's onl
BrookeHolmes
October 11th, 2011 12:45 AM
Correct me if I'm wrong......we didn't see Blair tell Louis she was pregnant did we? Didn't the scene start mid convo? So the recap is we see blair tell non father chuck that she is pregnant but we don't see how she tells the supposed actual father?! Sure.......
Ninasmileface Rank: Guest Star
October 11th, 2011 12:44 AM
This episode was fantastic! I actually think it was the best episode of the season so far. Everyone was somewhat interesting, even Charlie. I think that know that Nate has her phone his and her story lines just became more interesting. I can't wait to see what happens when Dan's story hits the shelves. I'm happy he finally got the guts to let it be published. I think that the father is Chuck or Dan. The way she looked at the envelope immediately insinuated that it wasn't his. Well, as long as it gets Louis out of the way I'll be happy. Overall it was suspenseful and interesting from beginning to end: 9.5/10!
Uncle Jackass Rank: Regular Character
October 11th, 2011 12:23 AM
Title: "Who's your Daddy??? Louis: "I AM YOUR FATHER!!!" Nooooooo, That's not True, That's Impossible....Search your feelings you know it to be true Or it could just be that other guy. What's he's name? Ohh yes... Chuck"
Intro:
First things first, I loved how the TVD and Gossip Girl steal each other's CW playlist. Great music and great intro...
A.) Baby Blue Blair:
Is this show all about Blair's baby blue problems? Ans: Yes and it seems the larger focus of the show for this arc is the emotional journey for Chuck and Blair. In that respects it does seem like that of a sandwich of "BDC" (Blair-Dan-Chuck, not a BLT) roll-coaster. And yes a Leighton and Ed show.
Blair's advice to Ivy/Charlie in this episode was "It's your life, do whatever you want with it" seems more like the denial in the title than girl power. But the words were profound with her actions in this episode with telling that Chuck was not the father and letting Louis ligh
Chiquita94 Rank: Guest Star
October 11th, 2011 12:23 AM
•lovestruck
October 10th, 2011 11:45 PM
God I miss Chuck and Blair,together their magic!It's amazing how they can light the screen up and give it life!I just want them to be together soon!!
It's so obvious that Louis isn't the father. like no way. there goes your story. clearly it's chuck's (or dan's :P)so louis will find out and dump her. that gets him out of the way...
i loved this episode. it was great: 8/10
Crista
October 11th, 2011 12:09 AM
The first answer is never the right one, so the baby is Chuck's. For one thing, if it's Louis's , most boring thing ever. Poor kid has no chance. There's no dram if it's the prince's and Chuck and Blair are obviously meant to be. It's Chuck's.
Still Love Chuck Rank: Leading Character
October 11th, 2011 12:06 AM
Saw the episode again and for me, it's because of what Blair told Charlee/Ivy @ the fashion show, something along the lines of "I'm beginning to realize mother's hold the darkest secrets of all." Makes me think she isn't being honest about anything when it comes to the pregnancy. Like Blair is falling back on what is the easiest thing to do. Her "complicated" comment also was troubling too. Oh my... too much to think about; I'm still thinking about the last scene with Blair & Chuck and Chuck & Monkey mutt. Incredible.
Carla Calles Rank: Extra
October 10th, 2011 11:57 PM
i dont know why you put Dan in the daddy question! as far as i know blair and dan never had sex. it can only be Chuck or Louis i belive is Chuck but that will be too obvious for the show to go on that direction
She's lying. Her tone of voice and her uncertainty with the envelope. And keeping it. It can't be this simple. I think she was hoping Louis would leave her so she wouldn't have to leave him. And next week, Dan's gonna be in deeeep shit hahaha. Sucker.
Bonnie
October 10th, 2011 11:51 PM
Kimmi, don't stress! I think Blair isn't being honest with anyone, including Chuck. It was pretty obvious to me that she was not being honest with Chuck because of her reactions as they were speaking to each other and the envelope at the end. She was hiding it from him. Why would she do that. I do think the Chuck scene was crazy good. Can't get over how great Ed and Leighton are together!
Kimmie
October 10th, 2011 11:48 PM
This episode was a miss in more ways than one. And we all know the one major way it misses was revealing that Chuck is NOT the father. NOOOOO!!!!!!
Okay we have Lily and Rufrus, not so interesting. I’m just glad we are done with the whole house arrest story because it was pointless.
So is Ivy really a good or bad person? She’s manipulating Carroll because she wants a real family? This girl is confusing and boring. Her and Serena are like dumb and dummier and are just a waste of time together.
And did everyone else notice that Serena totally did not reappear for like the last 20 minutes of the episode? What’s up with that?
Dan is so weird. He doesn’t want the book to be published but then takes the glory for himself. Make up your mind. I hope all the people who actually thought Dan could be the father can actually see how ridiculous it sounds. It’s somewhat pathetic that the only for Dan and Blair to be more is through his imagination and his alone.
Nate you are so den
Carrie
October 10th, 2011 11:46 PM
Blair is lying, that is something I have no doubt about. Look at her body language in that apartment scene- it's so clear! Chuck and Blair are just meant to be and I can't wait to see them together with their baby!
Serena: Congratulations, you've officially joined the dark side.
October 11th, 2011 2:08 AM
I'm very disappointed with the writers. Keeping us guessing about the identity of the father only to, well keep us guessing again. To me that was unnecessary really. I was happy it wasn't Chuck's but it might be his so I'm going to be unhappy whenever they decide it's fit to tell us.
I'm a big Dair fan but I admit the Chair scene was good. Part of me though thinks it's a little too much like the previous similar scenes they shared before so I wasn't all engaged in it.
I actually consider Dan and Blair's little fight as the best scene of that episode. It was so funny and adorable.
Apart from that, the way Noah tricked Dan was so great. I am so happy he got published!
The Charlie/Ivy thing has potential if we ever get the real Charlie coming around. If it stays that way it may turn out boring. Nate's storyline is blahh as usual. Get him back with Serena or just make sure this Diana/Gossip Girl thing actually gives us a glimpse of Gossip Girl herself.
October 11th, 2011 1:44 AM
It's amazing what a Chair scene can do to me. I found 5x01 and 5x02 SO BORING. And until the last 10 minutes I was thinking the same of 5x03. But then come up the chair scene. And you can just feel the tension, love, confusion bettween them. Ed and Leighton, as usually, just nailed it. Now I feel like s5 has finally started.
Rank: Leading Character
October 11th, 2011 1:40 AM
ABORT THAT BABY AND GET WITH DAN!
Rank: Recurring Character
October 11th, 2011 1:32 AM
Oh! And I know I must be steping on TvF's toes right about now, BUT for those who didn't watch next week's promo here it is, directly from YT:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5WYIDwGnu6E
Enjoy!
Rank: Recurring Character
October 11th, 2011 1:29 AM
I really, REALLY (and I mean REALLY) hope Chuck IS NOT the father.
Chair blows, it was good for a while, but it's over. Epic my -PEEP-! I -PEEP- EPICNESS!
Just let the characters be. If I wanted to watch a soap opera, I would change the channel.
It's my opinion tough, Chair fans are more than welcome to have theirs.
I'm still hoping for DAIR to happen and to be the "endgame" (another word I hate)
PS: Loved B's dress on the fashion show too... and Leighton rocks the character, kudos to her!
October 11th, 2011 1:27 AM
I don't think Blair was lying, but perhaps the test was wrong. She looked so brokenhearted that the baby isn't Chuck's. Maybe there was some kind of mix-up at the lab or whatever and Chuck is actually the father. Whatever happens, I'm like 99.5% certain that baby is really Chuck's. Or hey, maybe the prince will die and Chuck will raise the baby with her. You never know.
October 11th, 2011 1:21 AM
omfg best episode of the season so far 10/10
October 11th, 2011 1:20 AM
Wow. That Chuck and Blair scene. So much tension you could cut it with a knife. Heartwrenching and beautiful.
But did anyone else find that scene a bit eeriee? The music, the close-ups of the faces, the facial expressions themselves...especially Chuck's. And that scene was packed to the rafters with subtext. I mean, come on. The confusion over Chuck keeping the dog? The seemingly misplaced comment about the Chuck Bass lifestyle? Blair's furrowed eyebrows when Chuck said she must have felt relief? But who knows. GG is notorious for completely changing the direction of their story just to win viewers. Anything is possible at this point. In the end, the Chuck/Blair scene, plus Chuck crying at the end were amazing. So much raw emotion. Absolutely the best I've seen on GG thus far.
On a lighter note, based on the preview, next week's episode looks like great fun. Already counting down the days.
Rank: Recurring Character
October 11th, 2011 1:19 AM
Let's be honest loui will be the best choice always for the baby and Blair, sure chuck will grow but he will always carry some issues that would come out without noticing, like this can't feel thing, he looked so adorable with monkey!, and I like this girl that plays ivy, shed good , but her arc seem long and very non important , I want to think that is starting but I'm not been pull by it, I missed the mistery from last year with Juliet and Serena, wich seem an inanimate beautiful statue with so little to do,say and give to gg.
Rank: New User
October 11th, 2011 1:05 AM
Come on where is the Chair scenes. Pretty much everyone else on this show is boring. Ed and Leighton have this awesome chemistry from the very beginning. Their characters are so complex and the angst. When the characters can make you feel the emotions of the scene, you know its gold. If the other characters are lucky to have a scene with either Ed or Leighton thank the writers. Any scenes with them is upped a notch. Love Chuck's last scene, wonderful actor.
October 11th, 2011 12:59 AM
Ed Westwick is one hell of an actor, even with just a few scenes, he made the episode... he's really been carrying the show this whole season. He and Leighton have such chemistry on screen, their one scene together gave me butterflies. That child is so his, and he and Blair are so obviously still in love. They need to get them back together already, the show lacks so much sparkle and intrigue without their interaction.
Rank: Guest Star
October 11th, 2011 12:52 AM
Okay, so. About Blair. I seriously think that she lied to Chuck. Not only did that scene with her hiding the envelope give it away (although she could have hid it so that Louie wouldn't think she had cheated on him, so she HAD to know who the father was. Although she could have shown it to him and said she had it done so that noone else, like the press, could question paternity. I go with the latter as the better choice.) But the reason I think she lied: She didn't want to complicate things. She let Chuck go. Chuck let her go. If she told him it was really his....what were they supposed to do? And telling Louie...that would be the scariest thing in the world to her. Step in her shoes and think about it.
Now, as for the whole book thing....I think it's kindof boring. Along with the Nate plus sex-crazed-social-destroyer-crazy-ass woman storyline. It's just boring, and you already know what's going to happen. You can predict it. I'm not looking forward to next weeks episode if it's onl
October 11th, 2011 12:45 AM
Correct me if I'm wrong......we didn't see Blair tell Louis she was pregnant did we? Didn't the scene start mid convo? So the recap is we see blair tell non father chuck that she is pregnant but we don't see how she tells the supposed actual father?! Sure.......
Rank: Guest Star
October 11th, 2011 12:44 AM
This episode was fantastic! I actually think it was the best episode of the season so far. Everyone was somewhat interesting, even Charlie. I think that know that Nate has her phone his and her story lines just became more interesting. I can't wait to see what happens when Dan's story hits the shelves. I'm happy he finally got the guts to let it be published. I think that the father is Chuck or Dan. The way she looked at the envelope immediately insinuated that it wasn't his. Well, as long as it gets Louis out of the way I'll be happy. Overall it was suspenseful and interesting from beginning to end: 9.5/10!
Rank: Regular Character
October 11th, 2011 12:23 AM
Title: "Who's your Daddy??? Louis: "I AM YOUR FATHER!!!" Nooooooo, That's not True, That's Impossible....Search your feelings you know it to be true Or it could just be that other guy. What's he's name? Ohh yes... Chuck"
Intro:
First things first, I loved how the TVD and Gossip Girl steal each other's CW playlist. Great music and great intro...
A.) Baby Blue Blair:
Is this show all about Blair's baby blue problems? Ans: Yes and it seems the larger focus of the show for this arc is the emotional journey for Chuck and Blair. In that respects it does seem like that of a sandwich of "BDC" (Blair-Dan-Chuck, not a BLT) roll-coaster. And yes a Leighton and Ed show.
Blair's advice to Ivy/Charlie in this episode was "It's your life, do whatever you want with it" seems more like the denial in the title than girl power. But the words were profound with her actions in this episode with telling that Chuck was not the father and letting Louis ligh
Rank: Guest Star
October 11th, 2011 12:23 AM
•lovestruck
October 10th, 2011 11:45 PM
God I miss Chuck and Blair,together their magic!It's amazing how they can light the screen up and give it life!I just want them to be together soon!!
agreed with you!!!
Rank: Extra
October 11th, 2011 12:23 AM
It's so obvious that Louis isn't the father. like no way. there goes your story. clearly it's chuck's (or dan's :P)so louis will find out and dump her. that gets him out of the way...
i loved this episode. it was great: 8/10
October 11th, 2011 12:09 AM
The first answer is never the right one, so the baby is Chuck's. For one thing, if it's Louis's , most boring thing ever. Poor kid has no chance. There's no dram if it's the prince's and Chuck and Blair are obviously meant to be. It's Chuck's.
Rank: Leading Character
October 11th, 2011 12:06 AM
Saw the episode again and for me, it's because of what Blair told Charlee/Ivy @ the fashion show, something along the lines of "I'm beginning to realize mother's hold the darkest secrets of all." Makes me think she isn't being honest about anything when it comes to the pregnancy. Like Blair is falling back on what is the easiest thing to do. Her "complicated" comment also was troubling too. Oh my... too much to think about; I'm still thinking about the last scene with Blair & Chuck and Chuck & Monkey mutt. Incredible.
Rank: Extra
October 10th, 2011 11:57 PM
i dont know why you put Dan in the daddy question! as far as i know blair and dan never had sex. it can only be Chuck or Louis i belive is Chuck but that will be too obvious for the show to go on that direction
Rank: Guest Star
October 10th, 2011 11:55 PM
Also: Ed and Leighton: such fricking great on-screen chemistry!! Loved loved loved the CB scene :D
Rank: Guest Star
October 10th, 2011 11:53 PM
She's lying. Her tone of voice and her uncertainty with the envelope. And keeping it. It can't be this simple. I think she was hoping Louis would leave her so she wouldn't have to leave him. And next week, Dan's gonna be in deeeep shit hahaha. Sucker.
October 10th, 2011 11:51 PM
Kimmi, don't stress! I think Blair isn't being honest with anyone, including Chuck. It was pretty obvious to me that she was not being honest with Chuck because of her reactions as they were speaking to each other and the envelope at the end. She was hiding it from him. Why would she do that. I do think the Chuck scene was crazy good. Can't get over how great Ed and Leighton are together!
October 10th, 2011 11:48 PM
This episode was a miss in more ways than one. And we all know the one major way it misses was revealing that Chuck is NOT the father. NOOOOO!!!!!!
Okay we have Lily and Rufrus, not so interesting. I’m just glad we are done with the whole house arrest story because it was pointless.
So is Ivy really a good or bad person? She’s manipulating Carroll because she wants a real family? This girl is confusing and boring. Her and Serena are like dumb and dummier and are just a waste of time together.
And did everyone else notice that Serena totally did not reappear for like the last 20 minutes of the episode? What’s up with that?
Dan is so weird. He doesn’t want the book to be published but then takes the glory for himself. Make up your mind. I hope all the people who actually thought Dan could be the father can actually see how ridiculous it sounds. It’s somewhat pathetic that the only for Dan and Blair to be more is through his imagination and his alone.
Nate you are so den
October 10th, 2011 11:46 PM
Blair is lying, that is something I have no doubt about. Look at her body language in that apartment scene- it's so clear! Chuck and Blair are just meant to be and I can't wait to see them together with their baby!