Gossip Girl Review: Who is the Father?! Comments (Page 6)
154 Comments
lovestruck
October 10th, 2011 11:45 PM
God I miss Chuck and Blair,together their magic!It's amazing how they can light the screen up and give it life!I just want them to be together soon!!
CrAZychicke
October 10th, 2011 11:41 PM
been waiting for this review for ages. haha loved this episode! very funny, moving and dramatic. i'm loving blair's storyline and i'd have to agree with the others - though she admited it was louis' the fact she hid the envelope after sort of says she's hiding something and it could be chuck's. i love Louis and Blair but it think something will get in the way of their fairytale - namely the truth which will prob be dug up by Louis' sister or Diana. Nate getting a sotryline is good and i hope they make it interesting. loved that chuck kept the dog - totally became the start of me actually liking his character again. that dog was gorgeous btw. starting to like ivy's character, still hate S. good to see lily and rufus and hope to see more of them in next episodes. All DAIR scenes were classic and lots of fun. the ending of chair for now was good i think. we need a break of the heartbreak but it came across good. big bombshells happening next week - the promo for invisible dan looks like o
Kelly Ann
October 10th, 2011 11:39 PM
Blair is sooo lying. No doubt in my mind. @angel01cales is right. The show is about total drama and there is no drama if Louis is the dad. Here is what I think is going to happen: When it turns out Louis is shooting blanks people are going to think Dan is the dad because he wrote a big sex scene in his book! Otherwise, who would care about that? If Dan and Blair had had sex it was before she was engaged to Louis, so big deal.
So yeah, Louis isn't the daddy so Chuck obviously is. I think we'll find out when Louis and Chuck have their confrontation. Chuck will find out the truth and fingers crossed start to fight for his real legacy: His child. (Just like how Lily told him that he was Bart's true legacy last season. Not Bass Industries.)
Loved the Chuck and Blair scene and the Chuck scene at the end. Both broke my heart. So intense and emotional. Loved seeing Nate being a good friend. But without those scenes and the addition of Monkey it would not have been a very in
canyoufeelthelove
October 10th, 2011 11:28 PM
I definitely think this is Chuck's baby. I knew the second she said it was Louis' that she was lying - maybe to protect Chuck, maybe to test his reaction. Either way, it was a lie. I think she did open the envelope, hence why she hid it. She hid it to keep Louis from finding out. Louis can't be the father because he's not a series regular. His time on GG will be up soon. And her face when Louis said "I'm so happy to be a father!" clearly indicated who the father really is - Chuck. That's my theory, and I'm sticking to it.
Shannon
October 10th, 2011 11:27 PM
I found the episode kind of dull until the Chuck and Blair scene and the final Chuck scene. THIS is what the show has been missing in the first two episodes. No one can make the tiniest scene absolutely epic like Ed and Leighton can. Then that last scene with Chuck finally FEELING again after Blair told him Louis was the father? I was bawling. Ed Westwick nailed it. Totally nailed it. I love that Chuck is trying to be mature and do the right thing with the dog. I absolutely think Chuck is the daddy by the way. There's no drama otherwise. Blair lied because she thinks she's doing the right thing for her baby.
Maribells Rank: Guest Star
October 10th, 2011 11:25 PM
The episode was really slow in the middle for me- it was just hard to get into Dan following Chuck and Blair all over the place and trying to make them do things (seriously? how far we've come from S1, indeed) and Nate's storyline dragged for awhile, but it kicked up at the end there with finding Ivy's cell phone. And Ivy, while I've previously found her boring and useless, was actually pretty interesting in her scenes with Blair and Carol, so I think there may be some hope for that storyline.
The initial Chuck/Dan scene with the dog was hilarious, Chuck making a joke about Dan needing kneepads for his visit to Noah was full of win. I also adored Blair teasing Dan about his hair- because let's be frank, it's getting completely ridiculous, he looks like a small rodent crawled on top of his head and died there.
I was glad to see Lily off house arrest and back to being awesome. And is it just me, or is Rufus actually aging in reverse? He's like Benjamin Button.
Anyway, the highl
Chris
October 10th, 2011 11:25 PM
The CB scene. Just wow. The acting was so good because I feel like the expressions are what really told the story. I really am so confident that it is Chuck's baby. She goes there and he's like 'why are you here? We're done'. And then she admits she's pregnant. Waits a bit then says its Louis. She says he's not the fathering type anyway. Oh Blair is so wrong in this. She thinks he couldnt be a good father and is making the choice for him because she doesn't trust him and I can see why.
But then when she sees he kept the dog and did the responsible thing, her face says it all, she's taken aback and it looks like she is rethinking things, but its too late. She made her bed and has to lie in it, and when she says that a part of her wishes it were his, her face right after is like, "why did I admit that" and its because she wanted it to be him, just like in 4.20 she wanted it to be him. But she cant trust him!!! He hasn't earned that yet Blair is so wrong to lie but I think it is totall
Step
October 10th, 2011 11:23 PM
They aren't going to stick Blair with that lame prince's baby. Are you kidding me. It's so Chuck's and I couldn't be more happy. Chuck and Blair forever!
angel101cales
October 10th, 2011 11:18 PM
I have been thinking about the whole baby thing and honestly if the show is about total drama and stuff, the baby has got to be Chuck's. They wouldn't have this major story line and have the baby not be Chuck's and be Louis's. Yes it will create some drama, but not total drama like the producers want. I think the baby really is Chuck's because when Blair was reading what the paternity test said it looked like she was in shock and scared or something of that sort. Also why would she go to Chuck first? I mean shouldn't she tell Louis, then the others? I don't know I feel like things didn't fully add up to be honest. I am sure the plot isn't ending right there and there will be some twist on it. I know it can't be Dan's baby. Anyways I am not saying whose right and whose wrong, just my opinion. :)
Dan
October 10th, 2011 11:18 PM
Ooooookay. So the baby is obviously (hopefully) really Chuck's. That's going to probably come into play soon. Either Chuck's gonna get tipped off that it's not Louis' or Blair is gonna crack and tell him & he'll be incredibly mad. I don't really like her as the pretty little princes, but Leighton is so talented; holy geez!
I cried when chuck cried, no lie.
But I swear, ed westwick is the only one who can pull off the name 'chuck'.
Love chuck
October 10th, 2011 11:16 PM
I loved this episode! No matter what happens btw them or who they end up with, CHUCK n BLAIR have major chemistry n I cried when chuck cried! Hes soooooooo beautiful! I love him!
Isa
October 10th, 2011 11:15 PM
I think Blair is lying. She first thinks that Chuck is not daddy material, got rid of the dog, but once she finds out that he didn't? It's too late. She already told him it was Louis. And the way she looked at the envelope was very telling. That Chair scene was great and Chuck's reaction was truly heart-breaking. Love them so much!
Chair scene broke my heart. Especially the last part with Chuck crying. Pty is right Chuck has barely EVER cried in any of the seasons.
Meg
October 10th, 2011 11:06 PM
Goodness me. I was nearly in tears when I saw Chuck crying with Monkey. He's so, so in love with Blair. And she's obviously still in love with him. The writers can't be THAT stupid; the baby has to be Chuck's. It would all just be so boring and aggravating if the baby was Louis'. Chair is endgame; Blair's fairytale is all going to come crashing down before too long.
Heddy
October 10th, 2011 11:01 PM
I know that scene with Chair seemed like it was over but there's still more to come between them according to the pictures. And they seemed pretty chill in the promo for next weeks episode so... don't lose hope is what I guess I'm trying to say.
I've read a lot of peoples interpretations of why Blair kept and hid her paternity test; Blair obviously doesn't want Louis to see even if it is his because it would give away that she was unfaithful, maybe Chuck IS the father but she didn't think Chuck would want responsibility because she thought he gave his dog away and therefor wouldn't want/shouldn't have a child.
She seemed pretty convincing to me that the baby is Louis' and that a little part of her DID wish it was Chucks, however I believe that Blair got scared when Chuck welcomed her coldly. I think more terrifying to Blair than Louis rejecting her is Chuck rejecting her.
pty
October 10th, 2011 10:57 PM
I'm going to try to keep to myself my opinion about the paternity of Blair's baby (between Chuck and Louis) because I feel that a storm is going to be brewing about this issue and that soon enough it will start pouring rain like a monsoon. That being said, I need to point at that: a) if she lied, which let's face it is a posibility, that lie better pop before she has the baby (no pun or double meaning intended) because otherwise, I don't know what I will do, and b) there is no way Dan is the father, I'm sorry TV Fanatic but I don't agree with your attitude of pretending with each episode that Dan has greater chances of being in the race for the child's paternity when all I see in my TV screen is the exact opposite, next week's promo clearly had Blair's voice saying "he made us have sex in the book? I'm going to kill him!", maybe I'm not been verbatim with each word but I'm sure it's almost the same words.
The episode started light and kinda fun, kinda like the writers had promised
whateva
October 10th, 2011 10:57 PM
People keep saying Chair didn't work out for a reason... maybe because they were young and both needed to seriously grow the hell up. I seen Chuck at least attempt but I have yet seen Blair attempt to make it own her own (you know the reason why she and Chuck didn't get back together in season 4 or the storyline dropped in favor of some fairytale bs).
I still don't like the idea of Dair as more than friends. as for reviewers keeping Dan in the poll lmao...that promo clearly proves sex did not go down after their awkward season 4 kiss.
whateva
October 10th, 2011 10:52 PM
@Dair fan
Dair was not being built since season 1. I respect Dair but let's get real. Neither one were remotely interested in each other in the first 4 seasons and barely interacted unless it had to do with Serena (with the exception of when Blair was trying to get Chuck to bone her w/o her admitting she love him in season 2). They didn't start building that until last year. If you want to talk about building something for four years and then tossing it go talk to Derena fans (and I am not one but they get shafted after season 2 except for those teases).
Alice Mayer
October 10th, 2011 10:51 PM
I am happy to see that the baby is Louis' baby. (I hope it is true.) Blair deserves someone better than Chuck. Chair was a great love, but Chuck and Blair are older now and should move on with their lives. It did not work out for a reason.
Dair Fan 2011
October 10th, 2011 10:48 PM
oh - and the comment about the writers building something up for 4 years and tossing it out the window--- welcome to feelings of a DAIR fan. The writers have been building and building the relationship up... it is becoming so strong.... they need to get together.
Jamey
October 10th, 2011 10:46 PM
I can't wait for Dan and Blair to get together. They are so perfect for each other! He supports her, encourages her and cares for her. I love them together and I can't wait to see them together again next week.
Julie
October 10th, 2011 10:43 PM
I used to be the biggest GG fan, but as of late, the plot is going down hill along with the ratings. The writers better start making sense soon unless they want to lose all of their viewers! I know j only mainly watch it now for the fashion- btw LOVED B's dress at the fashion show!
As for the plot- I definitely do not think the baby is Louis' nor do I think that Blair will ever end up having the baby. Something crazy will happen because there is no way that Blair will have a baby. Also, I think it's be a crazy, but also cool, spin if it was dan's baby. I love Chair!! I also love Dan and chuck as close friends- it's adorable. I HATE the Charlie plot. They just need to expose her and drop it! It's just like with juliet... The plot sucks and doesn't make Amy sense. I miss the old gossip girl.... Looks like the show will get cancelled soon.....
Juliette Rank: Regular Character
October 10th, 2011 10:40 PM
the review is full of mistake...Sorry...
Can chuck and Blair just be together already?!?!?
October 10th, 2011 10:38 PM
I didn't want a baby to be the reason Chuck and Blair found their way back to each other but this episode was so sad for Chuck. I am confused about the Blair hiding the envelope in her desk scene because it could mean either she didn't want Louis to know she even had to get a paternity test because she slept with someone else OR the baby is Chuck's and she wants to "hide" it. I feel like either way, if it was me I would burn that envelope if I truly didn't want anyone to see it. Dan and Blair friendship is good but I really just want it to remain completely platonic. They still do Nothing for me as compared to the scene between Blair and Chuck which totally had me holding my breath. I will be watching that interaction on YouTube a few times soon. Great episode overall!
Juliette Rank: Regular Character
October 10th, 2011 10:38 PM
Blair read the letter on the street.......Was I the only one who saw that scene with Dan where she opens it and reads it while Dan goes to face up for his book.
Serena: Congratulations, you've officially joined the dark side.
October 10th, 2011 11:45 PM
God I miss Chuck and Blair,together their magic!It's amazing how they can light the screen up and give it life!I just want them to be together soon!!
October 10th, 2011 11:41 PM
been waiting for this review for ages. haha loved this episode! very funny, moving and dramatic. i'm loving blair's storyline and i'd have to agree with the others - though she admited it was louis' the fact she hid the envelope after sort of says she's hiding something and it could be chuck's. i love Louis and Blair but it think something will get in the way of their fairytale - namely the truth which will prob be dug up by Louis' sister or Diana. Nate getting a sotryline is good and i hope they make it interesting. loved that chuck kept the dog - totally became the start of me actually liking his character again. that dog was gorgeous btw. starting to like ivy's character, still hate S. good to see lily and rufus and hope to see more of them in next episodes. All DAIR scenes were classic and lots of fun. the ending of chair for now was good i think. we need a break of the heartbreak but it came across good. big bombshells happening next week - the promo for invisible dan looks like o
October 10th, 2011 11:39 PM
Blair is sooo lying. No doubt in my mind. @angel01cales is right. The show is about total drama and there is no drama if Louis is the dad. Here is what I think is going to happen: When it turns out Louis is shooting blanks people are going to think Dan is the dad because he wrote a big sex scene in his book! Otherwise, who would care about that? If Dan and Blair had had sex it was before she was engaged to Louis, so big deal.
So yeah, Louis isn't the daddy so Chuck obviously is. I think we'll find out when Louis and Chuck have their confrontation. Chuck will find out the truth and fingers crossed start to fight for his real legacy: His child. (Just like how Lily told him that he was Bart's true legacy last season. Not Bass Industries.)
Loved the Chuck and Blair scene and the Chuck scene at the end. Both broke my heart. So intense and emotional. Loved seeing Nate being a good friend. But without those scenes and the addition of Monkey it would not have been a very in
October 10th, 2011 11:28 PM
I definitely think this is Chuck's baby. I knew the second she said it was Louis' that she was lying - maybe to protect Chuck, maybe to test his reaction. Either way, it was a lie. I think she did open the envelope, hence why she hid it. She hid it to keep Louis from finding out. Louis can't be the father because he's not a series regular. His time on GG will be up soon. And her face when Louis said "I'm so happy to be a father!" clearly indicated who the father really is - Chuck. That's my theory, and I'm sticking to it.
October 10th, 2011 11:27 PM
I found the episode kind of dull until the Chuck and Blair scene and the final Chuck scene. THIS is what the show has been missing in the first two episodes. No one can make the tiniest scene absolutely epic like Ed and Leighton can. Then that last scene with Chuck finally FEELING again after Blair told him Louis was the father? I was bawling. Ed Westwick nailed it. Totally nailed it. I love that Chuck is trying to be mature and do the right thing with the dog. I absolutely think Chuck is the daddy by the way. There's no drama otherwise. Blair lied because she thinks she's doing the right thing for her baby.
Rank: Guest Star
October 10th, 2011 11:25 PM
The episode was really slow in the middle for me- it was just hard to get into Dan following Chuck and Blair all over the place and trying to make them do things (seriously? how far we've come from S1, indeed) and Nate's storyline dragged for awhile, but it kicked up at the end there with finding Ivy's cell phone. And Ivy, while I've previously found her boring and useless, was actually pretty interesting in her scenes with Blair and Carol, so I think there may be some hope for that storyline.
The initial Chuck/Dan scene with the dog was hilarious, Chuck making a joke about Dan needing kneepads for his visit to Noah was full of win. I also adored Blair teasing Dan about his hair- because let's be frank, it's getting completely ridiculous, he looks like a small rodent crawled on top of his head and died there.
I was glad to see Lily off house arrest and back to being awesome. And is it just me, or is Rufus actually aging in reverse? He's like Benjamin Button.
Anyway, the highl
October 10th, 2011 11:25 PM
The CB scene. Just wow. The acting was so good because I feel like the expressions are what really told the story. I really am so confident that it is Chuck's baby. She goes there and he's like 'why are you here? We're done'. And then she admits she's pregnant. Waits a bit then says its Louis. She says he's not the fathering type anyway. Oh Blair is so wrong in this. She thinks he couldnt be a good father and is making the choice for him because she doesn't trust him and I can see why.
But then when she sees he kept the dog and did the responsible thing, her face says it all, she's taken aback and it looks like she is rethinking things, but its too late. She made her bed and has to lie in it, and when she says that a part of her wishes it were his, her face right after is like, "why did I admit that" and its because she wanted it to be him, just like in 4.20 she wanted it to be him. But she cant trust him!!! He hasn't earned that yet Blair is so wrong to lie but I think it is totall
October 10th, 2011 11:23 PM
They aren't going to stick Blair with that lame prince's baby. Are you kidding me. It's so Chuck's and I couldn't be more happy. Chuck and Blair forever!
October 10th, 2011 11:18 PM
I have been thinking about the whole baby thing and honestly if the show is about total drama and stuff, the baby has got to be Chuck's. They wouldn't have this major story line and have the baby not be Chuck's and be Louis's. Yes it will create some drama, but not total drama like the producers want. I think the baby really is Chuck's because when Blair was reading what the paternity test said it looked like she was in shock and scared or something of that sort. Also why would she go to Chuck first? I mean shouldn't she tell Louis, then the others? I don't know I feel like things didn't fully add up to be honest. I am sure the plot isn't ending right there and there will be some twist on it. I know it can't be Dan's baby. Anyways I am not saying whose right and whose wrong, just my opinion. :)
October 10th, 2011 11:18 PM
Ooooookay. So the baby is obviously (hopefully) really Chuck's. That's going to probably come into play soon. Either Chuck's gonna get tipped off that it's not Louis' or Blair is gonna crack and tell him & he'll be incredibly mad. I don't really like her as the pretty little princes, but Leighton is so talented; holy geez!
I cried when chuck cried, no lie.
But I swear, ed westwick is the only one who can pull off the name 'chuck'.
October 10th, 2011 11:16 PM
I loved this episode! No matter what happens btw them or who they end up with, CHUCK n BLAIR have major chemistry n I cried when chuck cried! Hes soooooooo beautiful! I love him!
October 10th, 2011 11:15 PM
I think Blair is lying. She first thinks that Chuck is not daddy material, got rid of the dog, but once she finds out that he didn't? It's too late. She already told him it was Louis. And the way she looked at the envelope was very telling. That Chair scene was great and Chuck's reaction was truly heart-breaking. Love them so much!
Rank: Extra
October 10th, 2011 11:07 PM
Chair scene broke my heart. Especially the last part with Chuck crying. Pty is right Chuck has barely EVER cried in any of the seasons.
October 10th, 2011 11:06 PM
Goodness me. I was nearly in tears when I saw Chuck crying with Monkey. He's so, so in love with Blair. And she's obviously still in love with him. The writers can't be THAT stupid; the baby has to be Chuck's. It would all just be so boring and aggravating if the baby was Louis'. Chair is endgame; Blair's fairytale is all going to come crashing down before too long.
October 10th, 2011 11:01 PM
I know that scene with Chair seemed like it was over but there's still more to come between them according to the pictures. And they seemed pretty chill in the promo for next weeks episode so... don't lose hope is what I guess I'm trying to say.
I've read a lot of peoples interpretations of why Blair kept and hid her paternity test; Blair obviously doesn't want Louis to see even if it is his because it would give away that she was unfaithful, maybe Chuck IS the father but she didn't think Chuck would want responsibility because she thought he gave his dog away and therefor wouldn't want/shouldn't have a child.
She seemed pretty convincing to me that the baby is Louis' and that a little part of her DID wish it was Chucks, however I believe that Blair got scared when Chuck welcomed her coldly. I think more terrifying to Blair than Louis rejecting her is Chuck rejecting her.
October 10th, 2011 10:57 PM
I'm going to try to keep to myself my opinion about the paternity of Blair's baby (between Chuck and Louis) because I feel that a storm is going to be brewing about this issue and that soon enough it will start pouring rain like a monsoon. That being said, I need to point at that: a) if she lied, which let's face it is a posibility, that lie better pop before she has the baby (no pun or double meaning intended) because otherwise, I don't know what I will do, and b) there is no way Dan is the father, I'm sorry TV Fanatic but I don't agree with your attitude of pretending with each episode that Dan has greater chances of being in the race for the child's paternity when all I see in my TV screen is the exact opposite, next week's promo clearly had Blair's voice saying "he made us have sex in the book? I'm going to kill him!", maybe I'm not been verbatim with each word but I'm sure it's almost the same words.
The episode started light and kinda fun, kinda like the writers had promised
October 10th, 2011 10:57 PM
People keep saying Chair didn't work out for a reason... maybe because they were young and both needed to seriously grow the hell up. I seen Chuck at least attempt but I have yet seen Blair attempt to make it own her own (you know the reason why she and Chuck didn't get back together in season 4 or the storyline dropped in favor of some fairytale bs).
I still don't like the idea of Dair as more than friends. as for reviewers keeping Dan in the poll lmao...that promo clearly proves sex did not go down after their awkward season 4 kiss.
October 10th, 2011 10:52 PM
@Dair fan
Dair was not being built since season 1. I respect Dair but let's get real. Neither one were remotely interested in each other in the first 4 seasons and barely interacted unless it had to do with Serena (with the exception of when Blair was trying to get Chuck to bone her w/o her admitting she love him in season 2). They didn't start building that until last year. If you want to talk about building something for four years and then tossing it go talk to Derena fans (and I am not one but they get shafted after season 2 except for those teases).
October 10th, 2011 10:51 PM
I am happy to see that the baby is Louis' baby. (I hope it is true.) Blair deserves someone better than Chuck. Chair was a great love, but Chuck and Blair are older now and should move on with their lives. It did not work out for a reason.
October 10th, 2011 10:48 PM
oh - and the comment about the writers building something up for 4 years and tossing it out the window--- welcome to feelings of a DAIR fan. The writers have been building and building the relationship up... it is becoming so strong.... they need to get together.
October 10th, 2011 10:46 PM
I can't wait for Dan and Blair to get together. They are so perfect for each other! He supports her, encourages her and cares for her. I love them together and I can't wait to see them together again next week.
October 10th, 2011 10:43 PM
I used to be the biggest GG fan, but as of late, the plot is going down hill along with the ratings. The writers better start making sense soon unless they want to lose all of their viewers! I know j only mainly watch it now for the fashion- btw LOVED B's dress at the fashion show!
As for the plot- I definitely do not think the baby is Louis' nor do I think that Blair will ever end up having the baby. Something crazy will happen because there is no way that Blair will have a baby. Also, I think it's be a crazy, but also cool, spin if it was dan's baby. I love Chair!! I also love Dan and chuck as close friends- it's adorable. I HATE the Charlie plot. They just need to expose her and drop it! It's just like with juliet... The plot sucks and doesn't make Amy sense. I miss the old gossip girl.... Looks like the show will get cancelled soon.....
Rank: Regular Character
October 10th, 2011 10:40 PM
the review is full of mistake...Sorry...
October 10th, 2011 10:38 PM
I didn't want a baby to be the reason Chuck and Blair found their way back to each other but this episode was so sad for Chuck. I am confused about the Blair hiding the envelope in her desk scene because it could mean either she didn't want Louis to know she even had to get a paternity test because she slept with someone else OR the baby is Chuck's and she wants to "hide" it. I feel like either way, if it was me I would burn that envelope if I truly didn't want anyone to see it. Dan and Blair friendship is good but I really just want it to remain completely platonic. They still do Nothing for me as compared to the scene between Blair and Chuck which totally had me holding my breath. I will be watching that interaction on YouTube a few times soon. Great episode overall!
Rank: Regular Character
October 10th, 2011 10:38 PM
Blair read the letter on the street.......Was I the only one who saw that scene with Dan where she opens it and reads it while Dan goes to face up for his book.