17 Comments

11. George
    October 18th, 2011 11:27 AM
    

    i didnt particularly like this episode.
    i for one think Kal has like 0 chemistry with robin and the group. Ill admit he's a funny guy but he just doesnt fit in the group. Pretty much every other guest, cameo, and girlfriend fit in like 10x better than he does
    i didnt like the whole "therapist analyzing the group" bit, thought it was a cheap forced bit.
    pretty much the only thing i found entertaining was the barney/robin bit
    
    overall 3/5
    
    Also something that just dawned on me[something ive been subtly noticing but just wanted to finally acknowledge it] is that Ted "presumably" the protagonist for the show has definitely become one of the least entertaining, least significant characters. [although admittedly this probably has more to do with Marshall and Barney stealing the show than anything].

12. Goffy
    October 18th, 2011 9:51 AM
    

    The other issue with the spitting gag is that it has been done many times before on this show.
    
    The ending to the date was a fizzer, but other than that a good solid episode. Kevin is a bit of a stop gap, you know there is more to Barney/robin story and that Kevin is a fling. Takes the fun out, but I think he was hilarious.....

13. ShaunieB
    Rank: Guest Star
    October 18th, 2011 8:19 AM
    

    I thought that this was a greta ep and the best one of the season so far (I certainly laughed more with this one)
    I like the whole researching Ted's dates and seeing him freak out at the potential secrets his date was hiding was a lot of fun. Also, it's always nice to see Robin and Barney together and the chemistry between the two characters really shone brightly. Also, I think that Kal Penn is getter better and better with each episode and I really enjoyed his parts...also whilst his blow up is similar to that of Roger in friends, they are two completely different charactars as Kevin isn;t as big an ass and tried to make up for his outburst straight away.
    Overall a great ep!

14. Michael
    October 18th, 2011 8:14 AM
    

    funny how people said Robin had No chemistry and her acting feels forceful now look at her

15. maddie
    October 18th, 2011 7:46 AM
    

    i thought this was quite funny actually. i love barney and robin playing off each other. and it was ashley from greek!

16. chaela
    October 18th, 2011 3:52 AM
    

    I hate hate HATE robins bf. Doesn't fit in with them at all. No chemistry and his acting feels forceful!!
    i love this show but i will end up skipping episodes with him in it when i re-watch them

17. Uncle Jackass
    Rank: Regular Character
    October 18th, 2011 12:17 AM
    

    I was more thinking about how this episode relates to a University of California study about the "Spoiler Paradox" with the theory of minds. Do you like or dis-like spoilers in advance?
    
    The larger of majority of people prefer spoilers as it only makes it more engaging and anticipating.