Special Grey's Anatomy Episode to Ask: What If... Comments (Page 3)
85 Comments
steven
December 5th, 2011 12:32 AM
@smileyglen
actually, a quarter of Lexie's class is still at SGMW. Go back to 6x03. This show isn't about their interns. If it was, then the show would have to also introduce the other residents and attendings in the hospital which would totally destroy the show cause this show isn't really about doctors. It's about a group of interns that competed against one another, went through difficult trials together, and how they developed relationships and grew up because of it. And if you focus too much on the details, you'll go crazy because there are a lot of inconsistencies in the show. Just accept and enjoy the ride. And intern Steve, now a resident, was in episode 707.
I really don't know how this episode is going to work if Izzie and George aren't there. Because my biggest "what if" questions are: What if Alex and Izzie were still married? What if George and Callie were still married? and What if Denny didn't pass away? aaahhhhhh endless possilities!!
Sam
December 4th, 2011 8:45 PM
the only season regular that is coming back is addison and one mercy wester it is also set in meredith's point of view
check www.greysgabble for more info
anonymous
December 4th, 2011 8:44 PM
dr. hahn was an awful woman. please do not bring her back
guest
December 4th, 2011 8:21 PM
Bring back Dr. Hahn! She brought a lot of good tension to SGH - maybe she ended up with Mark (instead of Callie)! Brooke Smith is such a great actress. Kate Walsh of course, maybe Meredith with Finn, Richard with Ellis.
Burke was a jerk, but maybe it would be good to see how he and Christina would have turned out.
LoveMeSomeMcSteamy
December 4th, 2011 5:37 PM
I think this will be awsome..I loved the music episode aswell, and I think a what if episode will bring alot of fun to the show. I love Greys and I think these imputs are brilliant, so I'm looking forward to it!
Karen Harmsen Rank: Extra
December 4th, 2011 1:12 PM
If all those stuff didn't happen this is what would happen:
Mark wouldn't be there, Lexie wouldn't date mark, and she wouldn't date Jackson because they dated after mark.. Derek wouldn't have an alzheimers trial, meredith wouldn't ruin it, there never would be a baby (zola).. Alex and Izzie would never get married, Callie wouldn't have a kid with Mark, because he wouldn't be there.. Meredith would die,kill herself or be with doctor animal finn, Teddy would never be there because owen wouldn't be there because Mark wasn't there and we saw owen at first with mark walking around screaming about a pen in a dude's neck, george would never go to the army, he wouldn't get hit by a bus.. Christina wouldn't get married and a lot of more stuff.. So i'm happy all of it happend! I hope it doesn't suck like the musical episode did..
Onebzycookie
December 4th, 2011 10:58 AM
Play your "What If" game/episode....then get back to reality.
patriziasalatrelli
December 4th, 2011 3:25 AM
al fine narrativo non capisco questa decisione è alquanto pretestuosa.se la vicenda è accentrata su meredith,bene,altrimenti non ha senso.A nessuno penso interessi sapere cosa poteva essere e non è stato,giusto una passerella per alcuni personaggi.
patriziasalatrelli
December 4th, 2011 3:25 AM
al fine narrativo non capisco questa decisione è alquanto pretestuosa.se la vicenda è accentrata su meredith,bene,altrimenti non ha senso.A nessuno penso interessi sapere cosa poteva essere e non è stato,giusto una passerella per alcuni personaggi.
Caitlyn Rank: Regular Character
December 4th, 2011 3:05 AM
I think this is gonna be a lot of fun to watch! I'm excited for it :)
smileyglen Rank: Regular Character
December 4th, 2011 1:16 AM
I know this hasn't got anything to do with what if's.
My question is out of 19 interns Lexie is the only one left. She may be Meredith's sister but she wasn't the only intern, why is she the only 2 year resident then introducing us to more interns. The rest don't need lines just walk on walk off in the background, maybe give them a scene with an attending or there resident now and again. (I know it's not about these interns but Meredith, Cristina, Izzie, Alex and George, I would just like to see consistency right across.
I understand some of them got fired in the merger but where are the rest of them, our four interns all got 4 interns each in Season 4 Premiere.
Cristina's Interns
1.Intern Steve Mostow, 2.Intern Dani, 3.Intern Lexie Grey, 4. ??, and 4.2 Intern Ryan Spalding
Meredith's Interns
Intern George O'Malley (repeating his intern year), Intern Megan Nowland (got fired during the merger and was married to Steve Mostow, she was rehired by Shepherd & never see
Nikki
December 3rd, 2011 11:08 PM
I don't know there could be major changes, because didn't Mer actually come back mostly because Ellis had Alzheimer's?
Mel
December 3rd, 2011 10:44 PM
I prefer what if George O'Malley never get hit by a bus and what if Izzie stevens never leave Alex Karev....
Wapiti
December 3rd, 2011 7:05 PM
I hope that includes finally finding out what happened to Mary. Because they never actually told us...
MrsDrMcDreamy Rank: Extra
December 3rd, 2011 3:59 PM
Elizabeth Reaser as Ava/Rebecca anyone?
Sue
December 3rd, 2011 3:07 PM
Might be interesting, still anything is better than last season especially the musical eppisode, which sucked ass entirely. Still think the show has run its course.
leenokinnee Rank: Guest Star
December 3rd, 2011 3:05 PM
This could be a great episode, and I'd really like to see it.
Renee
December 3rd, 2011 2:42 PM
The What Ifs I'd like to see:
What if Burke stayed at Seattle Grace after the broken wedding with Cristina?
What if Ellis was still alive and pursuing Richard?
What if Izzie stayed and tried to make her marriage work?
What if Derek & Addie worked out their problems and Finn & Meredith stayed together.
What if George did not sleep with Izzie and Callie & George were still married?
What if Denny did not die and Denny & Izzie were happily married?
I would die to have Burke, Izzie, Finn and George to return (highly unlikely) but I am sure SR could easily round up alums such as Denny, Ellis, Addie, Charles, Reed, Tucker or Lucy for this show. Although the latter choices could be entertaining, if SR could round up Burke, Finn, Izzie and George, the ratings would definitely skyrocket!
Linda
December 3rd, 2011 1:54 PM
I would like to see Izzy come back to GA. No cancer, no Denny, just Izzy and Alex with three or four children coping with all the hospital drama surronding them and their friends. This would be great. I wonder what life would be like for Izzy and Alex if KH hadn't left GA?
Natalie 22
December 3rd, 2011 1:20 PM
This can be fun to watch. There'll be probably be some golden comedy in it. And a little bit drama, of course. Looking forward to see Callie in this, will she be still married to George and have kids or what? I hope they show her with Arizona as well. A little bit of a romance for them or smth!
I actually liked McDreamy and Addison together, so I will definitely enjoy watching this.
bookwizard Rank: Extra
December 3rd, 2011 12:01 PM
Well.... would any of these changes truely change Cristina falling for Burke?
Wouldnt Ellis still die from heart problems even if she didnt have alzheimers?
The only big changes i see happening are the relationship with Mer and Der and then Mer and Cristina. So unless Der chooses Addison after he sleeps with Mer then he won't even be there. There are so many possiblities and fitting it all in to a one hour episode should be interesting. I am very much looking forward to this episode, and of course the return of Grey's because it feels like forever until Jan 5th.
kay
December 3rd, 2011 7:58 AM
i kind of don't get the point of this. obviously nothing in this episode will affect the rest. it's a complete liftout. genre eps work on shows like community, but i feel like the greys ones always come off as a bit off
uklass
December 3rd, 2011 6:32 AM
The merger would have have to have happened, and if the shooting was acknowledged as happening then would Der still be the CoS? Will Webber still have problems with alcohol, and would Alex have married Izzie cos they wouldn't have a someone elses wedding to use?
smileyglen Rank: Regular Character
December 3rd, 2011 6:10 AM
What about the What if? Richard left Adele and married Ellis, he would be Meredith's Stepfather.
What if? George didn't die?
What if? There was no merger?
What if? Derek never came to Seattle? Which would mean Mark would not have come to Seattle either.
What if? Susan didn't die. Lexie would have gone to another hospital.
There are a lot of What if's.
Can't wait think it would make a great episode.
uklass
December 3rd, 2011 6:08 AM
I hope Ellis appears, would she still be invovlved with Webber? I really would like to see Ellis being mean to all the docs, not just Mer who knows how to cope with it.
I don't think Cris and Mer would be so close. Mer wouldn't need to give a home to Lexie or any MWer interlopers. I can see Derad still living in the trailer, but just cos they're still married doesn't mean that everythings great between them (I hope).
Bring back Finn for Mer, although i'm not really expecting that to happen.
Meredith: People change, but they don't change.
December 5th, 2011 12:32 AM
@smileyglen
actually, a quarter of Lexie's class is still at SGMW. Go back to 6x03. This show isn't about their interns. If it was, then the show would have to also introduce the other residents and attendings in the hospital which would totally destroy the show cause this show isn't really about doctors. It's about a group of interns that competed against one another, went through difficult trials together, and how they developed relationships and grew up because of it. And if you focus too much on the details, you'll go crazy because there are a lot of inconsistencies in the show. Just accept and enjoy the ride. And intern Steve, now a resident, was in episode 707.
I really don't know how this episode is going to work if Izzie and George aren't there. Because my biggest "what if" questions are: What if Alex and Izzie were still married? What if George and Callie were still married? and What if Denny didn't pass away? aaahhhhhh endless possilities!!
December 4th, 2011 8:45 PM
the only season regular that is coming back is addison and one mercy wester it is also set in meredith's point of view
check www.greysgabble for more info
December 4th, 2011 8:44 PM
dr. hahn was an awful woman. please do not bring her back
December 4th, 2011 8:21 PM
Bring back Dr. Hahn! She brought a lot of good tension to SGH - maybe she ended up with Mark (instead of Callie)! Brooke Smith is such a great actress. Kate Walsh of course, maybe Meredith with Finn, Richard with Ellis.
Burke was a jerk, but maybe it would be good to see how he and Christina would have turned out.
December 4th, 2011 5:37 PM
I think this will be awsome..I loved the music episode aswell, and I think a what if episode will bring alot of fun to the show. I love Greys and I think these imputs are brilliant, so I'm looking forward to it!
Rank: Extra
December 4th, 2011 1:12 PM
If all those stuff didn't happen this is what would happen:
Mark wouldn't be there, Lexie wouldn't date mark, and she wouldn't date Jackson because they dated after mark.. Derek wouldn't have an alzheimers trial, meredith wouldn't ruin it, there never would be a baby (zola).. Alex and Izzie would never get married, Callie wouldn't have a kid with Mark, because he wouldn't be there.. Meredith would die,kill herself or be with doctor animal finn, Teddy would never be there because owen wouldn't be there because Mark wasn't there and we saw owen at first with mark walking around screaming about a pen in a dude's neck, george would never go to the army, he wouldn't get hit by a bus.. Christina wouldn't get married and a lot of more stuff.. So i'm happy all of it happend! I hope it doesn't suck like the musical episode did..
December 4th, 2011 10:58 AM
Play your "What If" game/episode....then get back to reality.
December 4th, 2011 3:25 AM
al fine narrativo non capisco questa decisione è alquanto pretestuosa.se la vicenda è accentrata su meredith,bene,altrimenti non ha senso.A nessuno penso interessi sapere cosa poteva essere e non è stato,giusto una passerella per alcuni personaggi.
December 4th, 2011 3:25 AM
al fine narrativo non capisco questa decisione è alquanto pretestuosa.se la vicenda è accentrata su meredith,bene,altrimenti non ha senso.A nessuno penso interessi sapere cosa poteva essere e non è stato,giusto una passerella per alcuni personaggi.
Rank: Regular Character
December 4th, 2011 3:05 AM
I think this is gonna be a lot of fun to watch! I'm excited for it :)
Rank: Regular Character
December 4th, 2011 1:16 AM
I know this hasn't got anything to do with what if's.
My question is out of 19 interns Lexie is the only one left. She may be Meredith's sister but she wasn't the only intern, why is she the only 2 year resident then introducing us to more interns. The rest don't need lines just walk on walk off in the background, maybe give them a scene with an attending or there resident now and again. (I know it's not about these interns but Meredith, Cristina, Izzie, Alex and George, I would just like to see consistency right across.
I understand some of them got fired in the merger but where are the rest of them, our four interns all got 4 interns each in Season 4 Premiere.
Cristina's Interns
1.Intern Steve Mostow, 2.Intern Dani, 3.Intern Lexie Grey, 4. ??, and 4.2 Intern Ryan Spalding
Meredith's Interns
Intern George O'Malley (repeating his intern year), Intern Megan Nowland (got fired during the merger and was married to Steve Mostow, she was rehired by Shepherd & never see
December 3rd, 2011 11:08 PM
I don't know there could be major changes, because didn't Mer actually come back mostly because Ellis had Alzheimer's?
December 3rd, 2011 10:44 PM
I prefer what if George O'Malley never get hit by a bus and what if Izzie stevens never leave Alex Karev....
December 3rd, 2011 7:05 PM
I hope that includes finally finding out what happened to Mary. Because they never actually told us...
Rank: Extra
December 3rd, 2011 3:59 PM
Elizabeth Reaser as Ava/Rebecca anyone?
December 3rd, 2011 3:07 PM
Might be interesting, still anything is better than last season especially the musical eppisode, which sucked ass entirely. Still think the show has run its course.
Rank: Guest Star
December 3rd, 2011 3:05 PM
This could be a great episode, and I'd really like to see it.
December 3rd, 2011 2:42 PM
The What Ifs I'd like to see:
What if Burke stayed at Seattle Grace after the broken wedding with Cristina?
What if Ellis was still alive and pursuing Richard?
What if Izzie stayed and tried to make her marriage work?
What if Derek & Addie worked out their problems and Finn & Meredith stayed together.
What if George did not sleep with Izzie and Callie & George were still married?
What if Denny did not die and Denny & Izzie were happily married?
I would die to have Burke, Izzie, Finn and George to return (highly unlikely) but I am sure SR could easily round up alums such as Denny, Ellis, Addie, Charles, Reed, Tucker or Lucy for this show. Although the latter choices could be entertaining, if SR could round up Burke, Finn, Izzie and George, the ratings would definitely skyrocket!
December 3rd, 2011 1:54 PM
I would like to see Izzy come back to GA. No cancer, no Denny, just Izzy and Alex with three or four children coping with all the hospital drama surronding them and their friends. This would be great. I wonder what life would be like for Izzy and Alex if KH hadn't left GA?
December 3rd, 2011 1:20 PM
This can be fun to watch. There'll be probably be some golden comedy in it. And a little bit drama, of course. Looking forward to see Callie in this, will she be still married to George and have kids or what? I hope they show her with Arizona as well. A little bit of a romance for them or smth!
I actually liked McDreamy and Addison together, so I will definitely enjoy watching this.
Rank: Extra
December 3rd, 2011 12:01 PM
Well.... would any of these changes truely change Cristina falling for Burke?
Wouldnt Ellis still die from heart problems even if she didnt have alzheimers?
The only big changes i see happening are the relationship with Mer and Der and then Mer and Cristina. So unless Der chooses Addison after he sleeps with Mer then he won't even be there. There are so many possiblities and fitting it all in to a one hour episode should be interesting. I am very much looking forward to this episode, and of course the return of Grey's because it feels like forever until Jan 5th.
December 3rd, 2011 7:58 AM
i kind of don't get the point of this. obviously nothing in this episode will affect the rest. it's a complete liftout. genre eps work on shows like community, but i feel like the greys ones always come off as a bit off
December 3rd, 2011 6:32 AM
The merger would have have to have happened, and if the shooting was acknowledged as happening then would Der still be the CoS? Will Webber still have problems with alcohol, and would Alex have married Izzie cos they wouldn't have a someone elses wedding to use?
Rank: Regular Character
December 3rd, 2011 6:10 AM
What about the What if? Richard left Adele and married Ellis, he would be Meredith's Stepfather.
What if? George didn't die?
What if? There was no merger?
What if? Derek never came to Seattle? Which would mean Mark would not have come to Seattle either.
What if? Susan didn't die. Lexie would have gone to another hospital.
There are a lot of What if's.
Can't wait think it would make a great episode.
December 3rd, 2011 6:08 AM
I hope Ellis appears, would she still be invovlved with Webber? I really would like to see Ellis being mean to all the docs, not just Mer who knows how to cope with it.
I don't think Cris and Mer would be so close. Mer wouldn't need to give a home to Lexie or any MWer interlopers. I can see Derad still living in the trailer, but just cos they're still married doesn't mean that everythings great between them (I hope).
Bring back Finn for Mer, although i'm not really expecting that to happen.