Glee > Glee Review: Messy Love, Storytelling > Comments Page 4
Can we please have a Glee reviewer who is actually a fan of the show? This guy is ridiculous every single week. Learn how to judge Glee as Glee, and not a regular show.
I still think of myself as a gleek, but it's getting harder and harder with this kind of episodes. I get it, whatever makes sense in the Gleeverse, doesn't make sense in ours, but it's getting really bad, cramming all those storylines that seem random, at best, didn't give me a sense of "woo-hoo" lots of variety! It gave me a headache and the urgent need to scream "why am I even watching?"
he never proposed to Quinn...
I loved that episode. I finally found that the storylines were build. I'm sorry but it was obvious that Will would propose to Emma (the show is aiming at that since season 1).
I don't thnik it's random that Finn ask Rachel to marry him. After all, it's his way to react to bad new (he proposed to Quinn in Season 1 after learning she was pregnant...).
For me, it was one of the best episodes ever (very sentimental and the songs were well inserted in the storylines)
Now I know why reviewers review: It's the only way a talentless hack can be heard. Though I agree that the Christmas episode was weak, tonight's episode was FANTASTIC! The interwoven story lines and incredible vocals/arrangments were all amazing.
The first mistake was to cover Grease. You just don't take that shit on. There's no way to top it! I wanted to jump ship then. But I stuck it through until Moves Like Jagger came on. This was a waste of an episode and I totally agree with you.
Well that was the best show of the season... so far! I really liked it and for those that don't well sucks to be you. The start of season three was slow but it's starting to pick up. This season is about them winning the main prize and how the graduating class moves on past high school. Guess what guys the cast is so big and it's only an hour time slot and with something like 5 songs an episode the character development takes a hit. Overall I'm pretty happy with the direction the show has gone so far. I kinda of cringed at the end of yes/no episode because I knew Fin was proposing but it makes for an interesting plot. Can't wait for the next episode and I gotta stop reading the comments because 60 percent of them are so negative. Just enjoy the ride and as the song goes 'don't worry be happy!'
Uncle Jackass is right, glee is an amazing show, if you watch it like you have a brain like Finn's only seeing the obvious, not getting too emotionally invested because nothing happens(except rachel beng bullied by her so called family)
Keep the good work up Matt. I am a hundred percent with you on this.
dare i say, if you don't like it don't watch it
@AmyGirl: I totally agreed with you. What makes Glee unique is the huge, huge cast. And somehow that huge cast become the strength and weakness of the show. Like Heroes, or Lost, there's just no enough time to come up with storylines and character-building for everyone. And I just hope the reviewer can see through that and stop reviewing Glee like it's a 'normal' show with 5-6 main leads.
I stopped watching after the first time episode... glad I did.
DUDE I COMPLETE AGREE WITH YOUR REVIEW. I LOVE GLEE BUT LATELY THESE STORY LINES HAVE BEEN SO RANDOM. I MEAN HOW HARD IS IT TO WRITE ABOUT TEENAGE CHARACTERS? THE SHOW IS BEGINNING TO SUCK, AM ONLY HOLDING OUT FOR SOME MORE BRITTANA.
ha ha to turn off your brain and enjoy...thatswhat you have to do with most programs any way.
BTW FYI... It is Down Syndrome not Down's syndrome. Easier to write that way and is correct name of physician that first studied the collection of features common to people with trisomy 21.
The SamCedes is almost as unbelievable as Finchel they thought that pushing them down our throats would make us like them,let me see Mercedes is a bitch for a few episodes so she gets a boyfriend,wait I forgot this is Glee, meaning if you are a bitch to Rachel lots of good things hapen to you
Rachel's song was perfect and I think it demonstrated Miss Pillbury perfectly she needs him, and Santana nice as always(Wait didnt Rachel literally gave up a number per competition to Santana, and let her back in Glee club after she insulted her multiple times?)made another snark comment, and the FAMILY'S only response was snickers and a weakresponse from mr schue.
I have nothing special in my life, after that, is there actually still a finchel shipper out there.
Finn you do know she wants to go to New York, college, and i dot know BROADWAY before settling dowsn, did you ignore the last two years when you proposed to her??
God I miss Real Rachel, and developments in characters!!
ok so we begin this episode with a rendition that butchered my whole childhood of an epic song(If you think this is a good cover loo for spring awakening doing it, Lea Michele an Jonathan Groff can sing this song, those two on he show....I was looking for a knife).
There was a little build up for the Wemma, but what i loved about it was Will saying Finn teached so much to him,(cheated on his girldfriend, lusted over another girl when he thought Quinn was pregnant with his baby, lied about his virginity, MADE Quinn cheat on Sam, then broke up with her, disrespected Rachel's wishes of being alone during Nationals, then kissed her on the stage so they lost the competion, outed Santana, and many, MANY more)
@Matt: "WHY WOULD WE HAVE ANY CLUE YOU TWO WERE HEADED IN THAT DIRECTION?!?" Pretty sure you meant there's no build-up whatsoever when there is clearly one!
And you want Beiste's storyline? Aren't you the one that bash at "Asian F" for having too much storylines crammed into one episode? What exactly do you mean? Everyone should get storylines?
I'm really not that "Glee" fan that freak out when Glee got attacked, but I just want you to be more objective, and clearly not subjective.
Surgeon Warning: Just turn off your brain and enjoy the episode. Made my day a happier day :-)
Glee has too many characters; they can't handle it.
It's not like a show with perhaps 6 core cast members that get an adequate amount of screen time each week. There are at LEAST 20 characters; there's simply no time to give them proper story lines that build up per episode.
I am on cloud nine after reading your review because I feel like someone FINALLY agrees with me! I stopped watching Glee midway through season 2 because I could not understand how Ryan Murphy and Co could argue that they are making a such a social movement by representing those that aren't represented when they don't invest anything in their characters? It has become all about the songs and oneliners, which can be fun, but do not a committed gleek make. I hope the creators and show runners take in your criticisms and make a change for those who still watch
@Aquariuz (=liarsunited): Asian F aired on October 4. Pretty sure you just proved my point.
I didn't say the show has literally never depicted Will and Emma. I said it goes WEEKS at a time without doing so and then tries to stage this heartfelt proposal, which is spurred on by Beiste apparently getting married, which couldn't have been more out of nowhere. Why not give her an actual storyline? It's tonal, storyline whiplash that is written on set, five minutes prior to filming.
I don't understand why I watch anymore. I completely agree with the recapper. Nothing here made any sense. In one episode Will is defending Emma to her parents but here he lets him sway him? He asks Finn to be his best man and goes ring shopping with him? What? THe only realistic scene was when the kids were eating, talking about how they didn't realize their futures would happen so quickly. So, the answer is a sham marriage? What? And yes, I liked the proposal scene- very cute- until Will comes out in a white suit and top hat and walks on water? Are you kidding me? What the heck? I do not undersatnd this show at all and I think that Ryna Murphy needs all the critism he can get so he can whine and bitch like a narcisstic asshole when he gets the slightest criticism. again and this can be canceled. ood lord.
The whole episode was ridiculous. I think there needs to be less trying to cram a lot of stories all in one episode. It just gets hectic. There needs to be a change and for the love can we get episodes that are one week after another. Seriously with the 2 week break, 3 week break and the small breaks in between how are you supposed to hold an audience!
THIS EPISODE WAS MY FAVORITE EPISODE EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I CAN'T WAIT TILL THE NEXT ONE! GLEE IS THE BEST SHOW EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!
This show is just so DUMB, I used to watch it but now it is just pathetic and sick..
You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.
Remember My Info