Nurse Jackie Review: Getting Trashed

at . Comments

I'm really enjoying season four of Nurse Jackie.

Everything feels fresh, every character feels like he or she is on a new path, except for Zoe and Coop, I suppose, but would we ever want to see a new path for this pair? Sweet and naive, and clueless and douchey, are perfect for each. They are two who should never change.

Jackie and Grace

But everyone else? Gloria is a nurse on the floor; O'Hara is pregnant (will we ever learn the father?); Kevin is all business, both with Eddie (I want to understand!) and, as I'm sure we'll see a lot more over the coming episode, with Jackie and the kids.

Can't exactly blame him for wanting to take them away, can you?

Even Grace has evolved, though now she's just a regular teenager girl. Good luck with that, Jackie! She's giving her mom a hard time, she's moody, she's good at using the Internet and she's ready to date... although not if her mom can help it.

We even were treated to a pretty big shock involving Dr. Cruz. Not sure how I feel about him as Charlie's father, not sure if we needed to increase the role of someone who is prevalent enough at the hospital these days and the concept of these two being dad/son feels a bit contrived (Jackie just happened to befriend someone at rehab who just happens to be her new boss' kid?) but let's see where this goes before we judge.

Then there's the title character herself, of course. "Slow Growing Monsters" featured Jackie in a number of fun/interesting/revealing scenes.

I laughed out loud when Gloria and O'Hara reacted with a cheer to her attending an AA meeting, only for her to shush the celebration; I was proud of her inviting Charlie and genuinely trying to help him (and the old, fallen man); and I enjoyed every second of her interaction with Jules, played by the great Rosie Perez.

Often, a character on his/her death bed can come across like a writing crutch, like an easy way for the main character to realize various epiphanies about her life. But I never got that impression here. Chalk it up to Perez, who is just so entertaining as a curse-laden sass (and also pretty good at Jeopardy, I've heard) and the storyline in general: it teetered on the edge of maudlin, but never really went there.

Instead, it just reminded me of one too many nights in Jagermeister-based nights in college.

And the episode ended by successfully having it both ways: Jackie isn't totally over her pill addiction, nor should we expect her to be. But she isn't running straight home and popping this new batch, either. She's legitimately torn, and now legitimately smelly, caught between the past life she really wants to leave behind and a future one that isn't entirely comforting. But what will happen when she learns of Kevin's plans for full custody?

Will she head back to that dumpster and look harder? Or, like season four itself, is this really a new and improved version of Jackie Peyton?


Editor Rating: 4.4 / 5.0
  • 4.4 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.6 / 5.0 (12 Votes)

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.


Alex: you're probably used to reading reviews for movies you have yet to see. These are reviews for TV shows that we've already seen - and as such they function as retrospectives more than reviews really. I for one appreciate them - the reviewers' opinions gives me something to bite into, whether my choice is to agree with them or to argue about a point they've made. It's what makes this site live.


Ben, I think the series has shown that Eddie isn't the sharpest knife in the drawer. I can see Kevin guilting him into providing that info - along with the deceptive comment "I want to understand". He obviously didn't see it coming, because he had to ask "why do you want to know this?". Kevin's got a mean streak in him, provoked by the deceptions and betrayals both Eddie and Jackie put him through. That's truly realistic - I can buy that. He won't back down until Jackie is in obvious pain - but even that won't satisfy. If they kiss and make up? Now *that* would challenge my suspension of disbelief. Oddly though - I don't see that happening.


Why oh why did Eddie tell Kevin which drugs which was supplying to Jackie? It seems that Kevin will use that information against her in legal proceedings to gain custody of their two girls, and such information could lead to Eddie not only losing his job, but his license and even facing prison time. Unless the writers are willing to take the story in that direction, then this type of sloppy writing will only derail the show. And it is already beginning to show signs of problems with storylines. The obvious thing would have been for Eddie to deny anything to try to protect himself. He should know better, and our society is much more harsh on the dealer than it is with the user. But it is a comedy/drama and if one is willing or able to overlook these kinds of things, it is still an enjoyable show with great acting from Edie Falco.


The reviews on this site are really written poorly. Grammatical mistakes and typos aside, why does each reviewer insist on giving me so much opinion? "I liked this" and "I liked that" does not constitute a review. Tell us what happened and maybe talk about something that requires a bit more brain power such as themes, character development, dialogue, and plot. Yes, there will require some opinion in those things too, but damn I don't care if you liked the episode or the moment. Give us something a bit more in depth.

Tags: ,