Tuesdays 8:00 PM on FOX
American-idol

American Idol Results: The Fabulous 4

by at . Comments

Another Thursday night, another American Idol elimination.

These are getting harder and harder to introduce because it's getting harder and harder to predict who will stay and who will go. At this point, it seems like any of these contestants could win. Except, you know, only one of them can.

Carrie Underwood and Coldplay are in the theater tonight to give the contestants a master class in live performance. Jimmy's also here to give us his feedback on last night's performances.
The American Idol Five
Instead of leading with a cheesy group sing or the Ford commercial, Ryan takes us straight to the results.

Joshua Ledet will learn his fate first. Jimmy called Joshua's first song "fantastic" and said his performance of "To Love Somebody" was the best performance he's ever heard on Idol. Last night, I finally "got" Joshua. Ryan asked him what kind of album he'd make and he answered music that speaks to people and not necessarily what you'd hear on the radio.

It's no surprise that he's safe.

Coldplay performs their current hit "Paradise." This band is on my list concerts to attend before I die. They're fantastic. I only wish Colton were still around to see them because this is the kind of music I could see him making.

Hollie Cavanagh and Phillip Phillips are up next. Jimmy thought Hollie did a great job on "River Deep, Mountain High" because she didn't go into the performance thinking she would out-do Tina Turner. He thought her second performance was confident, but not fantastic. Jimmy called Phillip's songs from last night "bland" and thinks he should be in tonight's bottom two. I think Jimmy hit on the difference between Hollie and Jessica last night. Both of them did Tina Turner songs for Round One. Only one of them got overconfident, and it wasn't Hollie. As for Phillip, his songs last night weren't my favorites, but I didn't think they were as bad as Jimmy did.

Hollie's in the bottom two, which isn't surprising given her series of bad weeks leading up to this one. Phillip is safe.

It's been seven years since Carrie Underwood took home the Idol crown. She's back tonight and, as usual, she looks great. She sounds great, too. She's performing "Blown Away," the title track from her upcoming album of the same name. It's country in that it tells a story, but it's surprisingly un-country in sound.

Skylar Laine and Jessica Sanchez are up last. Jimmy calls Skylar a fighter and says she was exciting even if she didn't seem to really understand the lyrics to "Fortunate One." He also disagreed with Jennifer about Skylar's interpretation of "You Don't Have to Say You Love Me." While Jennifer thought it could win the competition, Jimmy thought it was confused. He loved every part of Jessica's "You Are So Beautiful" and called "Proud Mary" a "travesty." He said her dress was too mature for a 16 year old. High-five to Jimmy for making that comment. She's 16 and that dress was too tight and too short! But about the singing, I agree with him that last night wasn't Skylar's best. Not by a long shot. I wasn't as impressed with Jessica's second number as he was.

Jessica's safe. Skylar's in the bottom two with Hollie.

Before we can find out which girl will be leaving us, Coldplay is back with "Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall." First, it's another flawless performance. Second, I would NOT want to be on the clean-up crew inside that theater after all the confetti they just dumped all over the place.

Randy's reaction to the bottom two of Hollie and Skylar is to compliment everyone and say they both sang their faces off last night. J.Lo said it's hard to lose anybody. Steven's final thoughts are that we're "experiencing and feeling" these contestants. Mark, in for Keiran, has dimmed the lights.

After nearly 60 million votes, Skylar Laine is going home. She does a reprisal of "Gunpowder and Lead" as her closing number and reminds us who she wants to be as an artist. I have no doubt we'll see her back on this stage in the future.

Were you shocked that Skylar was eliminated tonight? Of the remaining four contestants, who do you want to see win?

 

Review

Editor Rating: 3.5 / 5.0
  • 3.5 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Miranda Wicker is a Staff Writer for TV Fanatic. Follow her on Twitter.

Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more American Idol?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic

Searching-for-eleanor

The Bridge Review: Butterflies

On tonight's The Bridge, the search for Eleanor continues. Will she kill again before she's found?
Telling-john

Extant Review: More Believable Than The Truth

On Extant, Molly reveals her pregnancy to John. However, Sparks' story isn't exactly a plausible explanation.
Paige-is-undercover

Graceland Review: Angels and Demons

On Graceland, Mike, Briggs and the team pull out all the stops to get Paige back. Read our review of "The Unlucky One" to find out if they were successful.
Isolation

Suits Review: Another You Problem

On Suits, Rachel and Jessica's life choices seep their way into the business of the men in their lives, some of which only cause more problems. Read out review of "Litt the Hell Up."

Avatar

Dee.....you are in the HUGE minority if you think that Jessica is awful. You must know more than all the recording artists that want to record duets with Jessica, or the studio pros that desparately want to signed her, or the millions of fans around the world (she has more fans in Asia than in America), or the millions of YouTube fans that have pumped up the viewing lists into the millions, when some of the other "much better" contestants are only in the tens or hundreds of thousands. Yes......you are the true expert. What were we all thinking?

Avatar

All Joshua(Mantasia) has proved is that he can scream and wail as good as Fantasia. Waiting to hear him sing Collar Greens and Cornbread lol. And Jessica don't even know who she is, what a Beyonce wanna be lol. We all know she ain't no Tina Turner that's for sure.

Avatar

Phillip should have been eliminated. He's maxed out on what he can do and now it's boring to listen to him. The 12 year old girls are keeping him in. Go figure! Jessica and Joshua should be in the finale with Jessica as the winner. I hope those that understand talent will get those votes out for Jessica and Joshua.

Avatar

I think Jessica should have went home and that it was a terrible decision to send Skyler home. It just makes me sick. Jessica is awful

Avatar

Phillip may be original but he just cannot sing a note.

Avatar

Sorry Skylar fans. Somebody had to go and I think that Skylar was a little "too country" (like 24/7 hardcore country). A couple of non-twangy songs here and there would have propelled her to the top. Phillip fans need to take their TVs off of "mute". Are you kidding me? We lost Colton, Elise AND Skylar to Phillip?????? That is a travesty.

Avatar

Philip is the best!!most original and talented artist on stage and will sell most records or bring in crowds to concerts.keep voting philip fans we almost there at the finish line.Lounge singer jessica 2 go next- keep hollie in!

Terrie

I was disappointed that Skylar was eliminated.... @Connie.......If you watched the XFACTOR then you remember that Melanie Amaro was brought back because Simon thought he'd made a mistake(As was done this year on Idol with Jermaine-and look what happened there).......AND she was brought back before the competition really started...... I really can't comment on this weeks performances because I missed Wed. night..... I will say Hollie has improved SOME..........but still not enough to win this competition.......I still say she's getting by on sympathy votes.
Jessica is over confident and that may end up costing her depending on her song choices in the coming weeks......
Joshua screams too much.........
I like Phillip! Will 2 be going home next week since the save was used?????

Avatar

Up until now I rated Joshua & Jessica as pretty much equal but now feel Jessica is most probably number one, after listening to her singing "You are so beautiful" her sensational ability to toy with the notes, low middle & high....you name it she can do it effortlessly....Oh my god can you just imagine what she might be in years to come?

Avatar

Jessica deserves to win because the judges know best when they saved her . Like Randy says even some singers with 50 years of experience can't do what she did. To win she really needs to pick the right songs .