I am just so happy that Skylar Laine went home. I don't know with you guys but, It's about time. :)
As a Senior Idol fan I am taken back to Elvis Presley. They said he could not sing, but was handsome, gave good hip action and we all know that through the years his stage presence grew. So while Philip may not be the best singer, America sees and hears something they like. The Judges may have anointed Joshua or perhaps Jessica, but what if it turns out Hollie and Philip are the last two standing...now that would be America with a thumbs down to the three judges. They seem who more biased this year than ever.
I have no idea who the majority voting are,but Skylar was not the one to be voted off tonight!!I will miss her spunk and the refreshment she brought to the show!
Based on last night's performance,if that is how people voted,Philip should have gone home!
I live in Canada and wish I could vote!I DO watch the show!!!!
I feel Jimmy has a more professional critique than any of the judges!
Miss Simon.s often misunderstood criticism,but he at least said what he felt was valid and didn't hold back and I feel that made the contestants try harder and push themselves to the limit!
Love all the judges,but they are too non critical,and don't push them to their max!
I am still curious about last nights comment that Joshua is the best artist(I believe it was Jennifer who said that)in the last 50 years!!That was an unbelievable comment!Who is the other person?
Very unhappy about tonight,s elimination!!
The weirdest season yet for judges guidance!!!Jimmy is like Simon!he calls it as he sees it!!
Joshua has the IDOL VOICE
w howard, you just shown ur racial discrimination. the travesty is that we voted and skylar was the least vote getter. she deserves to be booted out. ur the joke w howard....what a shame..
What a travesty....the wrong fin al 4! Should be Colton, Skylar, Josh and Phil! Thanks for screwing this one up Jennifer....what a joke you are!
Keep it going Jessica! The city of San Diego and Chula Vista are behind you!
You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please
© 2013 TV Fanatic