The Vampire Diaries Round Table: Pre-Finale Edition!

at . Comments

Welcome to a special edition of The Vampire Diaries Round Table!

With the season three finale just days away, TV Fanatic has teamed with a number of other websites and TVD fans to preview "The Departed." Who will live? Who might die? What choice will Elena make?

Joining in the discussion below are: Yours truly; Jim Halterman of; Tiffany Vogt of; Sabrina Forrester; Sharie of Paul Wesley Fans; and Jayne from TV After Dark.


Who will Elena choose?
Matt: Stefan would be a case of having been there and done that. But Stefan leaving town, if Elena selects Sexy D, would be the same. I say she plays it safe, chooses Stefan and we spend a lot of time with Damon away from Mystic Falls on Season 4.

Jim: She has to choose Damon, right? The show always paints the Elena/Stefan relationship as so sacred but you know what else it is? Boring! With Damon, there's fire and passion and you get more out of Damon as a character. Having her choose Stefan would be going backwards to the first season and I respect the show for always being smart enough to move forward even when looking to the past. The only other choice (and this would be a jump-the-shark moment) would be if she says "I choose myself." UGH!

Tiffany: Elena may be a risk taker in protecting others, but she is more cautious with her heart. So she'll go with the safe choice and choose Stefan. He is her ideal hero and he makes her feel safe. Above anything, she craves safety and stability. Damon is just too much of a risk.

Sabrina: Stefan.

Sharie: Matt, she's already admitted to stringing men along, maybe this is her longest one. Could be a Guinness world record or maybe a best seller.

Jayne: Neither of the boys. Elena recognized in "Before Sunset" how much it's worrying her what choosing between them will do to their relationship. I don't think she'll be able to break them apart like that.

Vampire Diaries RT - depreciated -

Rank in order of most likely to die: 'Ric, Sheriff Forbes, Jeremy, Bon-Bon, and Matty.
Matt: Sorry, Sheriff. But you'll need to die in order to protect your now-outed daughter. Alaric is the next obvious choice, and I'll tie up the final trip in last place. Elena has gone through too much to kill off Jeremy, the team needs a witch on its side in Bonnie, and The Grill would shut down forever without Matt.

Jim: RIC: Not only could Matt Davis' pilot get picked up, but now that Ric is pure evil, they've done pretty much everything they can. And, if you follow my tweets, you know that I've been wanting this lackluster character dead since season one. 
BON-BON: After Ric, she's the one we care about the most so it make sense to kill her off. Plus, nobody is every REALLY dead on The Vampire Diaries, right? (And Kat Graham REALLY just wants to sing and dance her little pop songs!)
MATTY: Would be sad but the show needs to either do something new with him (vampire, werewolf or some new creation) or put him out to pasture.
JEREMY: The funny thing is this - when Steven McQueen was gone for a handful of episodes earlier in the season, did anyone REALLY miss him? I didn't. But he's also Elena's last family member alive and the girl has been through enough so I'd be surprised if he was really killed off.
SHERIFF FORBES : Would anyone REALLY care other than Caroline? Nah....

Tiffany: Unfortunately, now that Ric has gone to the dark-side, his days are numbered and it is unlikely he is going to survive to see another season.

Sabrina: 'Ric, Matty, Sheriff Forbes, Jeremy, Bon-Bon.

Sharie: Bonnie will go first because she always gets the bad end of the friendship stick. Jeremy, Matty, Ric and Sheriff Forbes. I put those two at the end because Forbes no one would really be upset about, and Ric has died so many times we have no tears left for him.

Jayne: Sheriff Forbes, Ric, Matty, Bon-Bon, Jeremy.

More likely to appear: Katherine, Klaus or Rose?
Matt: I don't wish to spoil it, so I'll just say this Vampire Diaries clip gives away my answer.

Jim: Executive Producer Julie Plec said recently that there's no way Katherine will reappear as long as Klaus is around, so after last week's happenings, it would totally make sense for her to make another one of those shocking, 'didn't see it coming' appearances.

Tiffany: More likely to reappear is Klaus. There is no way that he is going to go gently into the night and no mere witch's spell will keep him for very long.

Sabrina: Katherine and Klaus.

Sharie: Katherine. Let's face it, when you need a full proof plan, she is the only one that delivers.

Jayne: Klaus, I think! Katherine's still boogeying outta town and I think Rose is pretty content on the Other Side. Plus, I want Joseph Morgan back. That's all I want.

Who has been the season three MVP?
Matt: Rebekah. And not just because Claire Holt looks like Claire Holt and speaks with an accent. She's also helped bring about the humanity in Klaus, expanded the Originals storyline and... okay, she looks like Claire Holt!

Jim: Klaus. While originally brought in as pure evil and the bad guy to bring down, the writers managed to give him dimension, as evidenced by his vulnerability (Mommy issues!), and they even give him a crush in Caroline that didn't come off as too mushy. Plus, Joseph Morgan surprised me with his ability to spew classic Klaus lines while also showing that - for a character who is technically dead - there's a lot of human emotion still going on with him. We'll see him again in Season 4... at least I hope we will!

Tiffany: The Season 3 MVP would have to be Joseph Morgan. Love him or hate him, he certainly spiced up the season and made it riveting to watch. Every show needs a good villain and he ROCKED as the villain we loved to hate.

Sabrina: Klaus all the way.

Sharie: Spells, Stakes and Daggers, oh my!!!

Jayne: I gotta say Caroline. She's been this fresh balance between the crazy and the mundane; keeping everyone's minds focused and still staying true to herself. Yep, she's my MVP.

Make one bold prediction regarding the finale.
Matt: Esther will actually be killed. For good. Forever. To truly never be seen again.

Jim: Ric will die (PLEASE!!!) but he'll take someone with him and I wouldn't be surprised if it was Tyler, whose death I do think would feel like a substantial loss to the show.

Tiffany: My prediction is that brother Elijah is going to make an appearance and hopefully he will help everyone with Dark Alaric. Klaus and Rebekah may have wanted to run from that harbinger of death, but Elijah is more likely to want to confront and vanquish the dark one from Mystic Falls. 

Sabrina: Elena will turn into a vampire so Alaric can die. And Katherine will show up... probably.

Sharie: Elena will finally make her choice, but her choice sacrifices everything and dies. I also think the forest animals are planning an attack because Stefan is off the humans.

Jayne: Ric won't be the one to die - it'll be either the death of another Original or one of the founding moms (i.e. Liz or Carol) who will find themselves face-down in the dirt. Let's face it, to create a villain like psycho-vamp-killer Ric and simply kill him off after two episodes would be downright boring. Wouldn't it?

Matt Richenthal is the Editor in Chief of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Twitter and on Google+.

Allison berry barbieri

@Shizzy, well if Klaus comes back to life and Elena is a vampire, she would need to be protected because he's want to kill her like he wanted to kill Katherine...but we've already seen the protect Elena from Klaus storyline so I hope not..

Allison berry barbieri

@Spindae...I thought there was a chance that Caroline might die as well...I wouldn't like it but it would be upsetting and shocking!

Kitanishi h mcdonald

Who has been the season three MVP?
Inconsistencies and utter chaos in terms of writing. And that benny hill show tune that makes visit to my room every time I watch an episode. Make one bold prediction regarding the finale.
Elena turns int he way she did in the books(meh), thus Rick appears to be died but TWIST(!) is most likely not.

Kitanishi h mcdonald

Who will Elena choose?
herself or jeremy. not that the choice will matter anyway since its quite obvious on what will happen then.
Rank in order of most likely to die: 'Ric, Sheriff Forbes, Jeremy, Bon-Bon, and Matty.
Rick, matt, mommy forbes, jeremy, bonnie. That is "die" not "stay dead". I can see rick dying due to elena dying, only to be revealed to not have died. More likely to appear: Katherine, Klaus or Rose?
while all three now are equally boring plot devies, I guess Klaus and Katherine.


2.Sheriff Forbes,Ric,Matt,Jeremy,Bonnie.
3.Klaus and Katherine
5.Elena or Jeremy will turn into a vampire.


Who will Elena choose?
Hopefully she decides to stay alone so the Salvatores can move on to cooler girls and their awesome bromance :-) Rank in order of most likely to die: 'Ric, Sheriff Forbes, Jeremy, Bon-Bon, and Matty.
What I wish: Bonnie, Jeremy, Alaric, Forbes, Matt.
What I think is realistic: Alaric, Forbes, Matt, Jeremy, Bonnie. More likely to appear: Katherine, Klaus or Rose?
Klaus. Because Rebekah and Elijah come to the rescue.
At least I hope so. TVD without any Original (as Elijah and Rebekah don't want to stay in Mystic Falls) seems rather dull to me. Who has been the season three MVP?
Klaus. Make one bold prediction regarding the finale.
Rebekah wants to save Klaus, but gets killed by Badlaric.


She'll so choose Damon. I'm not even worring about that


There is no way that she chooses one of them. The heart of the show is the triangle. At what makes this triangle so painful to watch is that everyone loves everyone in either direction. No one would watch this show any longer if she chooses Stefan and Damon leaves town. Stefan and Elena couldn`t carry the show alone just by watching them. Think about it. So i assume that Elena will choose her humanity and her life as a normal teenager. But at the end something pretty horrible will happen and because Ian told in one of his lates interviews that the way Damon will act in the last ep will surprise everyone and will show how much he cares about Elena. I think Damon will sacrifice himself for Elena somehow.


Why can't she have both brothers? I say the writers are keeping it too traditional...;) If I was her, I'd tell them "You really love me? Then you won't mind sharing a little."


How is everybody so sure that Elena will turn into a vampire at the end of the season? Yes, that's what happened in the books, but c'mon, the writers are not relying on the book for storytelling cliffhangers. Elena will eventually turn into a vampire, maybe bext season. Now is too soon. Everybody episode features the brothers going to harsh lenghts to protect Elena's life, that's what the series is primarily about. If they turn her into a vampire, then all that protecting and saving will end and there is no plot crutch to fall back on.

Tags: ,

Vampire Diaries Quotes

You want a love that consumes you. You want passion and adventure, and even a little danger... I want you to get everything you're looking for. But for right now, I want you to forget that this happened. Can't have people knowing I'm in town yet. Goodnight, Elena.


When 9 Russians tell you you're drunk, you lie down.

Enzo [to Bonnie]