Fans will have a few months to ponder these questions and debate all the possibilities with friends because the ABC Family drama doesn't return with new episodes until January.
With the exception of October 23, that is. For the second consecutive year, Pretty Little Liars will air a special standalone Halloween installment, this one taking place on a train and featuring guest star Adam Lambert.
Watch the official preview now and continue to sound off: Toby? Reall?!?!?
Want more Pretty Little Liars?
Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!