Tournament of TV Fanatic ABC Championship: Stana Katic vs. Nathan Fillion!

at . Comments

Welcome back to the 1st annual Tournament of TV Fanatic: ABC edition!

It's time for you, TV Fanatics, to choose your favorite ABC star! We have chosen 16 fan favorites for this showdown. The concept is easy: Pick your favorite of the two pairs in each poll. That's it!

Castle fans have spoken. After tough semifinal wins against Grey's Anatomy's core duo, Stana Katic and Nathan Fillion will square off for the ABC title! After tens of thousands of votes cast (and last night's Castle season premiere), they've earned it. So who's it going to be in our all-Castle final? VOTE below!

And the Winner is?

Nathan Fillion vs. Stana Katic: Which ABC star do you love the most? Vote now in the championship round matchup of the Tournament of TV Fanatic: ABC Edition! View Poll »

Poll is now closed! Here are the results:

Stana Katic

Nathan Fillion

Total Votes: 5307

The winner will be announced Friday! Here's the updated ABC field:


Steve Marsi is the Managing Editor of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Google+ or email him here.


Yes you are not fanatics and fans! You offer to make a draw, and the result is that a beautiful couple on screen, will also become the best couple on ABC. But no, the hard-nosed sheep only of his thinking.




Oh My gosh how can one choose.


Stana is a better actor, even Andrew Marlowe know that, he gives he much more challenging rolls. Stana is a better person, ask any Castle fan and they will tell she understands us like nobody else. Stana even looks much better on this 2 photos. Its like the Universe know what's up. You don't want to let the universe down, do you?


Franicine- this tournament is between Stana Katic as Kate Beckett and Nathan Fillion as Richard Castle. Nowhere does it say Firefly! Get over it- the show ended like a decade ago. Move on!


Yes, there is all the fans gone mad. You can easily make it a draw and they both win. Will be in the Castle, the best pair of channel ABC. We love them both, and are proud of them. So it is time to stop crying and start to vote, so that was a fifty-fifty.


Woohoo!!! I'm so proud to be a Castle fanatic and so proud that both of these fabulous actors made it into the final round!!! I really don't care who wins, considering it's a win-win for me (and should be for everyone else on here who call themselves Castle fans). I chose Nathan ONLY because I've been such a massive fan of his since Firefly back in '02 and my loyalty will always be to my Captain, but Stana is incredible, too, and I love her to death! I'm still on a high from last night's season premiere!!! To the in-fighters - Why fight? BOTH our leads made it into the finals, it's just silly to be anything other than THRILLED and happy, so please drop the senseless vitriol! Peace out, Casketteers!


Seriously people; regardless of how this poll turns out this is a win for Castle. Why does everything have to be turned into a slagging match? Stana & Nathan are both fantastic actors & clearly have the fan support to get them this far. Sure we all have our favourites, but ultimately why does it matter who wins? Both are winners for getting this far. Castle is a winner for having two cast members in the finals. And everyone else is a winner for the hard work they do day in & day out on their shows. Why can't we all just be civil? Is this really how you want to represent the show & the cast by turning it into a hatefest. Stana & Nathan have feelings you know & they deserve better than this from people who call themselves fans. Show some respect.


I'm not voting. I can't. I love them equally as much. They're both epic actors, and I'm disappointed with how badly the Castle fandom is representing themselves. We should be cheering them BOTH on!


I can't believe some of the comments! I love Stana, but I love Nathan too! They are both so crucial to why "Castle" is so awesome. Why are we fighting over this?! Shouldn't we be cheering on both of them???

Tags: , , ,

Castle Quotes

Sometimes the hardest things in life are the things most worth doing.


Castle: The fact that you even think that breaks my heart. I would walk into a tornado for you, Kate.
Beckett: And I would die if I lost you.