Thursdays 9:00 PM on ABC

Tournament of TV Fanatic: Ellen Pompeo vs. Robert Carlyle!

by at . Comments

Welcome back to the 1st annual Tournament of TV Fanatic: ABC edition!

It's time for you, TV Fanatics, to choose your favorite ABC star! We have chosen 16 fan favorites for this showdown. The concept is easy: Pick your favorite of the two pairs in each poll. That's it!

Patrick Dempsey and Missy Peregrym started us off, followed by Kerry Washington and Sofia Vergara, Stana Katic and Ty Burrell, Kate Walsh and Gabriel Mann, and Emily VanCamp and Adam Pally.

Today: Grey's Anatomy's Ellen Pompeo vs. Once Upon a Time's Robert Carlyle! Vote!

And the Winner is?

Ellen Pompeo vs. Robert Carlyle: Which ABC star do you love more? Vote now in this first round matchup of the Tournament of TV Fanatic: ABC Edition! View Poll »

Poll is now closed! Here are the results:

Ellen Pompeo

Robert Carlyle

Total Votes: 5508

We will post polls of these respective ABC matchups daily, and then after each round, update the bracket as some stars advance, while others are eliminated, until the winner is crowned. Make sense?

It's easy, fun and all decided by YOU! Here's the Tournament of TVF ABC field:

ABC bracket 

First-round matchups to come: #7 Ginnifer Goodwin vs. #10 Taye Diggs; #2 Nathan Fillion vs. #15 Dana Delany.

NBC, Fox and miscellaneous (HBO, USA, etc.) brackets are also still to come! Happy voting ...

Steve Marsi is the Managing Editor of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Google+ or email him here.

Tags: , , , ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more Grey's Anatomy?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic


Once Upon a Time Season 4 Adds New Frozen Character

Now who's coming to Once Upon a Time Season 4? Prepare to welcome another Frozen character, fans!

Once Upon a Time Creators Preview Frozen Arc

Which Frozen character will NOT be coming to Once Upon a Time Season 4? Find out now!

Grey's Anatomy Season 11: All About Meredith!

Grey's Anatomy Season 11 will be all about Meredith. Read on for some Shonda Rhimes-based scoop!

ABC President Teases Frozen-Themed Once Upon a Time Spinoff

Might another Once Upon a Time spinoff be coming? Don't count out the possibility.


Robert Carlyle is the Best, I dont know why Ellen is here, her show is so boring now.


Robert Carlyle, of course!! best actor in the world ever! and lovely person :) hugs from Argentina. Stella


Robert, duh. Like, duh!


Those of you who voted for Ellen must be living under a rock, Robert is an amazing, well-rounded actor and is on the best show on television right now. If you're not watching Once Upon a Time on ABC you don't know what you're missing.


Robert Carlyle


Anna - I'm with you on this one. Robert Carlyle is a freakin' amazing actor, compelling, charming, forceful. Pompeo doesn't come close.


Even though i like him a lot as well, I go for Ellen !


Ellen of course!


The votes for Ellen have vastly outnumbered the votes for Robert Carlyle? I don't think I want to live on this planet anymore...


@Carissa Palvica Do you like in a cave or something?? You must if you do not what ABC show Robert is in. He's on Once Upon A Time. Wow and you're a staff member? I guess they'll hire anyone these days.