Thursdays 10:00 PM on FX

It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia Review: Brotherly Love Ends In Bloodshed

by at . Comments

What is it about 'It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia' Halloween episodes that make them so awesome? The Gang always seems to bring the full comedic force on this holiday.

In what some would consider to be a continuation from last week’s ode to recycling, The Gang tells this story, "The Maureen Ponderosa Wedding Massacre," through flashback just as they had with the costume party at Paddy’s the previous year.

But this version had every horror movie plot device and nod to popular horror classics of the past (Blair Witch, zombies, vampires), yet it didn’t come off as cliche.

It's Always Sunny Halloween

This is the season where all The Gang’s past actions, interactions and transgressions come back to bite them. I’ve noted their half-self aware/subconscious desire to change, and we’re seeing why: the holes they’ve dug are only getting deeper. The consequences collide in a one giant, hilarious clusterf*ck with this, the unholiest of unions.

Mac couldn’t have said it any better when he discovers Liam is the groom at Maureen’s wedding - "‘A McPoyle-Ponderosa wedding... Jesus." It’s like the previous seven seasons have been one long setup for this season alone. One hundred-plus stories spent neatly establishing and meticulously developing characters, arcs, relationships, dynamics and family trees to have them culminate in frantic and frenzied fireworks with each episode, but especially this one.

And yet, they show restraint. They don’t go overboard shoe-horning more characters in. Just enough mayhem to move the narrative along to the next level. Is this hitting them stride? Seems hypocritical and flip-floppish considering my assessment last week, but I was completely opposed to the recycling approach.

Take, for example, Bill Ponderosa’s addiction to drugs and alcohol leading him to lace the milk (the McPoyle beverage of choice) with bath salts, the narcotic that caused people to eat each other’s faces like zombies. You couldn’t have written it any better. The writers’ grasp on the characters is as firm as it can get. The progressions - and conclusions - just feel natural.

What I’m probably most fond of is the trend of Charlie taking on dramatic speeches where he gets into character. When well-placed, it’s a game-changer and his slightly modified soliloquy from Jaws was top notch. While it’s something I’d like to see more of, I’m hoping The Gang doesn’t wedge it in - it's spontaneous, out of left field style is what makes them so great.

But the gold star goes to the moment when Dennis busts down the door with Frank it tow to catch what looks like Ryan McPoyle deep-throating his brother, Liam. Again, this is the payoff we’ve been so patiently waiting for since the disturbing duo’s debut. Of course, it turns out Ryan’s just begging for forgiveness but it was a rare, jaw-dropping moment.

Tying up the loose ends with Dennis’ narcissistic, self-absorbed quasi-homicidal psychosis is the bloody cherry on top of this expertly crafted sundae. Like Chinese takeout, it’s left me hungry for more - more recurring characters from the Gang’s past to come back and add to their own lore and the legendary status of the show.

Check out another batch of classic It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia quotes now!


Editor Rating: 4.0 / 5.0
  • 4.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.2 / 5.0 (31 Votes)
Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic


Tyrant Review: Turning Point

On Tyrant, Bassam attempts to find a peaceful resolution instead of a revolution. Will he succeed?

Covert Affairs Review: Honesty

On tonight's Covert Affairs, Annie and Auggie switch jobs and head to Paris. Will Auggie succeed in the field with Annie as his handler?

The Real Housewives of New York City Review: Leg-endary Finale

A leg went flying on The Real Housewives of New York City this week. You must read this review.

Perception Review: Gone Baby Gone

On Perception, Daniel and Kate try to track down a missing baby. Kate also must deal with Donnie's talks about their own future children.


As a true fan of this show for many years, this was honestly one of the funniest episodes ever. The fact that they can rehash old storylines like the McPoyles or Bill Ponderosa's drug addiction in new and innovative ways is a testament to how great the writing really is. I literally pissed my pants when Charlie crashed Dee's car or Mac and Charlie argue about Batman & the Academy awards. One of the funniest lines was Bill Ponderosa's "Dee's nuts!" I don't know how they continue to do it but this season is shaping up to be the best one since the fifth season, and that one was best.