Revenge Review: Forgive and Never Forget

at . Comments

"Good for Revengey stuff. Sad for you." - Nolan.

The full, public introduction of Jennifer Jason Leigh as Kara Clarke tonight served as yet another Revenge game changer, altering the playing field and expectations, while raising even more questions than it answered.

Kara provides Madeleine Stowe's Victoria with a new type of adversary, a slightly unhinged one with skeletons and secrets galore, made even more delicious by the fact that her agenda isn't understood by anyone else.

Victoria Grayson, speechless, utterly baffled and legitimately unsure what to make of the situation? In that, Revenge has done the unthinkable. You half expected those pruning shears to end up in Kara's back.

The slow-motion hug. The empty expressions on both of their faces as they attempt to size up the other. The dueling motivations neither understands. Who says there isn't room for another sociopath on this show?

Kara and Victoria Hug

Safe to say this wasn't in Vicky's master plan. Under the impression that the white-haired man remains alive and that Kara is feeding him information, she and Conrad hatched a plan to remarry ... for legal reasons.

By tying the knot, they can't be forced to testify against each other if and when the Initiative (or the FBI) comes calling. After Conrad's romantic proposal, there couldn't have been a dry eye in the house. So touching.

The Wedding of the Century takes place on next week's episode, and with enemies both real and perceived trying to undermine the increasingly paranoid Graysons, it should be a memorable affair to say the least.

These Clarke girls really are a Thorne (sorry) in their side.

Kara also impacted Emily profoundly, but the wheels she set in motion with her daughter were emotional as well as tactical. When the memories came flooding back, our once-unflappable girl broke down in tears.

We learned a wealth of information about Kara tonight, through flashbacks and in the present day. She came back looking for WHM (her true love), but was forced to confront her past with David (her first love).

The mother who tried to drown her sought forgiveness in the lie she (and David) lived all of these years. These revelations would be difficult enough to stomach were it not for the FauxManda situation.

Imagine if your long-presumed-dead mother reappeared and you had to use the woman masquerading as you - who just had your own first love's baby, incidentally - to probe her for information? And then that information involved you dying, coming back to life, and fed a 20-year diet of lies? Then finding out mom is actually still alive?

Emily and Kara Photo

If all of those things combined don't register around Infinity times Infinity on the Freak-o-Meter, what does?! It's a lot to take in, and Emily VanCamp really sold her namesake's vulnerable, innocent side tonight.

The good news is that Emily came clean to Amanda about Carl and sought "Forgiveness" of her own. The question (which we'll address more in a second) is where the Emily-Amanda relationship goes next.

There were a bunch of additional, significant developments in what was another solid episode this week, each weaving into the plot separately and in conjunction with the overarching narrative of Season 2:

  1. Padma's request for information about David Clarke's contract. Deliberately or not, she tipped off Daniel to the fact that Grayson Global possibly OWNS HALF OF NOLCORP. Which ties in to ...
  2. Aiden teaming up with Emily to destabilize Grayson Global. Acting as Takeda's proxy, the smooth Mr. Mathis quickly won over Daniel (and Ashley) while keeping close tabs on the hedge fund. One still gets the feeling that there may be more to his connection with Ashley than meets the eye.
  3. That slime Mason Treadwell returning to sniff out the Kara story. No one has figured out the Emily-Amanda switcheroo yet, although Mason is hot on the trail after spotting her scar, or lack thereof.
  4. Kenny buying the Stowaway from Jack. It looks like his plan is coming together, and while it remains to be seen what his true motivation is, you can expect the consequences to be far-reaching.
  5. Nolan was the man. Pretty much goes without saying.

Which of these storylines do you find most significant, and how will they play out in the coming weeks? Before you weigh in with your predictions, theories and views, take a look at next week's promo:

What did you think of tonight's Revenge? Discuss in the comments below!


Editor Rating: 4.5 / 5.0
  • 4.5 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.8 / 5.0 (287 Votes)

Steve Marsi is the Managing Editor of TV Fanatic. Follow him on Google+ or email him here.


First off, I loved that they used Ferraby Lionheart's "Vermont Ave" during that scene when Jack comes back to the Stowaway after being in the hospital to find Declan finishing up...what a great song But anyway, this show is definitely starting to hit its stride - not that it was a poor show last season, but they're improving the pacing and the dialogue of this show so much that it's really starting to grab my interest. I also love some of the relationship development of this season, especially the friendship between Emily and Nolan.


I don't really get the nolcorp thing...I knew David supported Nolan, but how is it connected to Grayson global? How do they own half of nolcorp?


first of all just hate victoria,nw i hate kara too!!i wish to see both dis bitches catfight!!is goin to be crazy!!is it just me or daniel is getting hotter!!HOT!!!!ashley is a bitch!!!! wonder aiden and daniel kiss!!it would be a blast!hahaha


"Charlotte did not leave Dec's jacket at the bar."
^I didn't notice that. Kara's playing Victoria. Gordon was supposed to kill her, but instead he ends up falling for her. So Kara's making Victoria that she(Kara) believes Vic set Gordon up to "save" her. About their initial relationship, we don't know. I suppose we can make our assumptions. I'd say Gordon and Kara did not know each other beforehand, and Kara only knew of Victoria through David talking about her to Kara. "What did Kara mean when she said that she was glad David did not destroy Amanda (to Emily)?"
She seems like a happy girl who's just started a family. She wasn't destroyed by her father's actions. Of course, we know that's not true. The real Amanda is...messed up. Conrad and Victoria were married, they got divorced and they'll be married again.


Charlotte did not leave Dec's jacket at the bar. Kara said to Victoria "why did you save me?" Victoria did not save her.. What was that about? Kara also mentioned the WHM by name. Gordon. Victoria seemed startled by that. What was Kara Victoria Conrad's relationship initially...there seems to have been one. What did Kara mean when she said that she was glad David did not destroy Amanda (to Emily)? We're Conrad and Victoria ever married?? If they were then they should not be testifying against one Victoria was going to do to clear David Clark's name. Can anyone answer these questions?


After the last shock-packed one, this episode was apparently a little slower, but it paves the road for new interesting storyline. Mason Treadwell is SOOOOOO dead, and I think it'll happen very soon - probably Aiden will kill him. I hated her at the beginning, but now I definitely love Faux Amanda, and I'm glad faux Emily told her the tuth about little Carl's paternity. I like when the two girls are friends and allies. Interesting development between Padma and Nolan, and... Madeleine Stowe is a genius. Great episode as usual, they can't all be action-packed like the last one, they also need to prepare future things to come! And some scenes were very moving.

Beverly brooks

When Kara and Ems was on the beach and Kara kept looking at Ems, I am thinking Kara is thinking this is really my daughter but I'm going to let her know just yet.


"Are you seriously reading a book? - It calms me, you should try" Victoria and Conrad are hilarious! Great evil couple!


When Kara and Emily were talking in the hospital hallway, I was wondering if Kara suspected Emily is really Amanda. After Emily and Kara's conversation on the beach I am sure Kara suspects who her daughter really is. What will Kara's reaction be once she realises her daughter killed WHM?

Drea xoxo

i agree with aciel. until treadwell and conrad evil time, i was bored!!been feeling this way for weeks now, writers change it up!!!!

Tags: ,

Revenge Season 2 Episode 5 Quotes

Uh, a shower wouldn't kill you.

Emily [to Jack]

What a beautiful home. It's so smart to build it right on the ocean. You can always see your enemies coming.

Kara [to Victoria]