Supernatural Review: Welcome to Cartoon World

at . Comments

Things got a little looney on this week's Supernatural.

Unfortunately, the wascally wabbit didn't make an appearance as a terrorizing toon, but Sam and Dean were on the hunt to figure out why certain robberies and murders felt far more animated than usual.

"Hunteri Heroici" could certainly have been a hate it or love it episode, leaving the dark serious aspects of the show on hold and instead attempting to tickle the funny bone by dropping anvils and making hearts literally beat out of the chest.

Castiel on a Case

The concept was creative and right up Sam and Dean's alley on the weirdness level. How gross was the "X" marks the spot body splatter? And while the final fight sequence stuck to the cartoon rules of using frying pans and guns that shoot out "bang" flags, the noises took me a little bit out of the moment.

Yes, they went right along with it all, but maybe I was hoping that somehow Sam and Dean might end up turning into cartoons? Is that too far fetched for this series? I even thought that perhaps when Sam was pleading with Fred Jones inside his head, that he and Castiel might become animated versions of themselves.

Certainly, allowing a former friend of the brothers' father to be the source of the cartoon world was an interesting aspect, but I kept waiting for the real culprit to be a trickster. Gabriel, perhaps? Who wasn't hoping he would come back?

The whole thought process was reminiscent of Gabriel's antics on the episode "Changing Channels," and while this one contained funny moments, it wasn't nearly on the same level as the former episode.

Yet, it was Castiel that truly stole the show.

Not only did he want to become a hunter (a good third wheel according to him), but he wanted to show Sam and Dean just how useful he could be.

From his hilarious bloodhound sniffing ways to his straight out of every law drama show "bad cop" interrogation, Castiel was nailing the humor. Even trying to get the cat to give up information was a good chuckle.

And to think that I'd been looking at Wile E. Coyote and the Road Runner all wrong these years. Who knew Castiel's analysis about the man chasing God metaphor would be so enlightening? And hilarious.

Dean did manage to sneak out a few moments of his own from checking out the nurse (there's the Dean I know!) to joking about "wabbit" season before being corrected of the pronunciation.

Sam had more flashbacks again and the biggest connection to the main story seemed to focus on chasing dreams.

We definitely got more meat to the backstory with Amelia's father playing the hard ass and questioning Sam. I'm not surprised her dad kept grilling him and providing the "you're not right for my daughter" attitude, but man was he harsh. It is great, though, that we got to see Sam is conflicted about losing his brother at the same time he's trying to live his normal life.

Clearly, Sam and Amelia's situation comes more from an emotional escape for each other that's trying to blossom into something more, but the fact that her husband is alive throws a whole wrench into that relationship. I wonder what that will mean for Sam?

I guess I'm okay with Sam's flashbacks, but for whatever reason, they still feel a bit out of place. And I can't help but think that with Sam playing house and not monster hunting, his apple pie life feels more Gilmore Girls than Supernatural.

But will Castiel be able to find real penance with his mess in Heaven and can he escape the clutches of Naomi? I'm curious about how that part of his journey will play out this season and just how deep the show will take us into his blackmailing angel counterparts. I hope it's a lot more than the mentions here and there of the war in Heaven on Supernatural Season 7 at least.

This was a fair episode of Supernatural that made me laugh, had a bit more backstory for Sam and featured the trio hunting together. Maybe I was expecting a little more out of the cartoon world, but I really do love that the show is willing to take that leap and try for the wacky and new.

What did you think? Was this episode a stinker or a hilarious take on the toon world? Sound off below!


Editor Rating: 4.0 / 5.0
  • 4.0 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.7 / 5.0 (136 Votes)

Sean McKenna is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.


It was so nice to have a break from the tension! I love the way Supernatural always could make the abnormal or scary funny. It is nice to go back to the way things were.. Now...when Bobby comes back as an Angel.. I will be really happy!


@ Dreamrose I'm not sure what the glowing is. I think I heard Castiel is supposed to have some extra powers this season. Maybe that has something to do with it.


I thought that was the best episode for the entire season. It did remind me of Switching channels with Gabriel {Forgive me I can't remember the exact title of that episode} I can't believe no body mentioned the talking cat!!! That was hilarious!!! Do you know why no one is interested in the Sam and Amelia thing? Because the girl is not that cute. She doesn't seem like Sam or Jared's type. This is the guy who married Ruby in real life. I get that he is a brunette kind of guy but she is not that cute. Remember, Ruby {2nd one} Madison, and another brunette from season 1 I can't remember her name. The only blonde was Jessica.


If you want to see where this episode could have gone with more animation, look no further than season three episode 16 of Farscape (Revenging Angel). Featuring D'Argo in the Wily Coyote role chasing Chichton as the Road Runner, it had a number of really great moments.


I'm so sick of seeing Amelia. She's completely uninteresting and if she meant ANYTHING to Sam, he would have called her or at least visited her at some point in this season. Just kill her off and end that crap!
As for the episode, I thought it was hilarious! Though I'm not a fan of Cass, his blunt attitude was just hilarious when it came to him attempting to be a hunter. I'd happily see more of that.


For some reason the line that sticks out to me in the episode was when Castiel said that John Winchester had beautiful handwriting. It didn't mean anything to the story of course, but I thought it was just so sweet.
I think the Sam and Amelia storyline doesn't feel right for me is because I just can't picture Sam with her. I don't know what it is?


I love Castiel's performance. I didn't care much for Sam's backstory. He does need a haircut.


Sams flashbacks are annoying to me and i just want them to go away already.Im wondering where the hell they are leading to,if they're leading to anything at all ??... I agree that it would of been awesome if Sam and Cas were animated versions of themselves in Freds head. Garth has a safehouse boat ? That rules and i hope we get to see it


Naomi blocking Castiel from heaven seems awfully suspicious, as does the rest of her behavior. What is she up to? On a side note, in every previous episode Cas healed people without any light show, just a simple touch and done. Is the glow effect supposed to be something significant, or just the FX guys playing around with post-production? Even more side note: when the crime scene folks dust the (first) anvil for prints, would they come up with the mysteriously missing Jimmy Novak from Pontiac, Illinois, and be mightily confused?

Tags: ,