Criminal Minds Review: Baby Did a Bad Bad Thing Comments (Page 4)
74 Comments
Cindy
January 17th, 2013 9:56 AM
The only thing good about this episode to me is that it's over. I felt it was written by a 12 year old girl. Seriously? The first thing he's going to say is, "I love you?" Awwwww. And when Reid blows up and yells "b*tch"...so unconvincing. The kiss at the end, how he couldn't fool her with that....predictable and stupid. Killing her? Even more ridiculous. Agree with Blue Sunflower..total waste of character and plotline. And I do NOT want to see Reid go down his dark path now. I just prefer to see them solve crimes.
Ann
January 17th, 2013 9:52 AM
I thought the episode was great. The acting was top-notch. I love MMG's character. I was hoping that he would get at least a few episodes to explore a possible relationship outside of the BAU but that didn't happen. Didn't see the ending coming but the look on the faces of everyone and then Reid breaking down bought tears to my eyes. When the camera panned to the two women lying dead, I was in shock. I wasn't surprised that Reid picked Blake to talk to but thought for a minute he might pick Morgan. It will be interesting to see how Reid deals with this tragedy in future episodes.
robert
January 17th, 2013 9:50 AM
last night Criminal Minds Jumped the shark
pointless horrible ending Reids friends story would have been much better if she/it was tied to that wacko keeping tabs on the team
but because nobody on tv is allowed to be happy for more than 35 minutes they killed her off
somebody should tell Hotch's new girlfriend whats going on because she's next to die probably because she is the one stalking the team
or Kevin his numbers up too
Tari
January 17th, 2013 9:48 AM
IF they killed Maeve I'd like to see him go full-on dark for a while. Not UnSub dark, that would never be Reid, but drugs, women, facial hair... the works. I'd like to see JJ show up at his apartment to check on him and he's all dirty and in his bathrobe and his apartment's a mess, and have Spence be really rude to her. I'd like to see him neglect work and not call Diana... all the things we've never seen Reid do. IF they killed Maeve, now they have to be responsible for what that would really do to Reid, they can't just whitewash this. I think it would send him into an abyss for a while. He'd be better eventually, but he has to have some kind of journey resulting from this. Again... IF they killed her. We've yet to see if she's really dead.
Emma
January 17th, 2013 9:16 AM
I was sad that she died, they couldnt just let Reid be happy
Tim
January 17th, 2013 5:05 AM
This was the best episode in ages.
Reid picking Blake wasn't as much of a surprise for me, since Blake was the one person he had already confided in about Maeve, Blake is kind of developing into a mother figure for Reid.
The ending was amazing. @Blue Sunflower: The fact that the writers indeed destroyed a potentially great character and plotline with this ending only goes to show that this ending is fantastic. Not only the characters in the show are horrified by it, viewers are as well. Things really could have gone somewhere between Reid and Maeve, but tragedy struck.
dipdab
January 17th, 2013 3:55 AM
i know most pl didn't want meave to die, and I'm hearbroken over it, but what a great epusode that was. They really shocked me at the end, and I loved how they filmed it.the shock on the teams faces were mirroring mine...I was totally, one hundred percent shocked... really wasn't thinking they'd go and kill her. One of my fave episodes for sure. MMGs acting, along with the others, were just on top form, and I've gotta say that I was also a little surprised that he hadn't chosen jj to talk to...I know blake was the first to find out and had given him advice,was fresh eyes, but I always thought that he'd go to jj for everything...shes his person... rip maeve
Blue Sunflower
January 17th, 2013 3:26 AM
The ending sucked. Total mistake, and a total waste of both a character and a plotline.
Nick
January 17th, 2013 2:19 AM
Great review! I felt absolutely horrible for reid, but was I surprised because I found myself not really liking or sympathizing with maeve, but feeling a little bad for the stalker. I think it was partly because maeve seemed a little cold & self-centered. it bothered me that she didnt tell reid about the (ex) fiance. it bothered me more when she said that she basically developed feelings for reid because she had no one else to talk while in hiding. reid's feelings obviously went much deeper than that. i was hoping they would part ways in the least painful way for reid - having it end the way it did was not what I had in mind.
Hayley
January 17th, 2013 2:15 AM
This episode was amazing,but it left me heartbroken for Reid!!! The question that formed in my mind while watching was why is it always Reid..... I was so happy that he found someone he could be happy with and it was all taken away in an instant......but the actors did some really good acting in this episode!!!
tiva (Tania) Rank: Recurring Character
January 17th, 2013 12:55 AM
It was a good episode but I hated the end I didn't want her to die but we will get good Raid reaction. Next couple of weeks and I will like to see how he griefs and how he deal with.
marissa Rank: Regular Character
January 17th, 2013 12:03 AM
January 17th, 2013 9:56 AM
The only thing good about this episode to me is that it's over. I felt it was written by a 12 year old girl. Seriously? The first thing he's going to say is, "I love you?" Awwwww. And when Reid blows up and yells "b*tch"...so unconvincing. The kiss at the end, how he couldn't fool her with that....predictable and stupid. Killing her? Even more ridiculous. Agree with Blue Sunflower..total waste of character and plotline. And I do NOT want to see Reid go down his dark path now. I just prefer to see them solve crimes.
January 17th, 2013 9:52 AM
I thought the episode was great. The acting was top-notch. I love MMG's character. I was hoping that he would get at least a few episodes to explore a possible relationship outside of the BAU but that didn't happen. Didn't see the ending coming but the look on the faces of everyone and then Reid breaking down bought tears to my eyes. When the camera panned to the two women lying dead, I was in shock. I wasn't surprised that Reid picked Blake to talk to but thought for a minute he might pick Morgan. It will be interesting to see how Reid deals with this tragedy in future episodes.
January 17th, 2013 9:50 AM
last night Criminal Minds Jumped the shark
pointless horrible ending Reids friends story would have been much better if she/it was tied to that wacko keeping tabs on the team
but because nobody on tv is allowed to be happy for more than 35 minutes they killed her off
somebody should tell Hotch's new girlfriend whats going on because she's next to die probably because she is the one stalking the team
or Kevin his numbers up too
January 17th, 2013 9:48 AM
IF they killed Maeve I'd like to see him go full-on dark for a while. Not UnSub dark, that would never be Reid, but drugs, women, facial hair... the works. I'd like to see JJ show up at his apartment to check on him and he's all dirty and in his bathrobe and his apartment's a mess, and have Spence be really rude to her. I'd like to see him neglect work and not call Diana... all the things we've never seen Reid do. IF they killed Maeve, now they have to be responsible for what that would really do to Reid, they can't just whitewash this. I think it would send him into an abyss for a while. He'd be better eventually, but he has to have some kind of journey resulting from this. Again... IF they killed her. We've yet to see if she's really dead.
January 17th, 2013 9:16 AM
I was sad that she died, they couldnt just let Reid be happy
January 17th, 2013 5:05 AM
This was the best episode in ages.
Reid picking Blake wasn't as much of a surprise for me, since Blake was the one person he had already confided in about Maeve, Blake is kind of developing into a mother figure for Reid.
The ending was amazing. @Blue Sunflower: The fact that the writers indeed destroyed a potentially great character and plotline with this ending only goes to show that this ending is fantastic. Not only the characters in the show are horrified by it, viewers are as well. Things really could have gone somewhere between Reid and Maeve, but tragedy struck.
January 17th, 2013 3:55 AM
i know most pl didn't want meave to die, and I'm hearbroken over it, but what a great epusode that was. They really shocked me at the end, and I loved how they filmed it.the shock on the teams faces were mirroring mine...I was totally, one hundred percent shocked... really wasn't thinking they'd go and kill her. One of my fave episodes for sure. MMGs acting, along with the others, were just on top form, and I've gotta say that I was also a little surprised that he hadn't chosen jj to talk to...I know blake was the first to find out and had given him advice,was fresh eyes, but I always thought that he'd go to jj for everything...shes his person... rip maeve
January 17th, 2013 3:26 AM
The ending sucked. Total mistake, and a total waste of both a character and a plotline.
January 17th, 2013 2:19 AM
Great review! I felt absolutely horrible for reid, but was I surprised because I found myself not really liking or sympathizing with maeve, but feeling a little bad for the stalker. I think it was partly because maeve seemed a little cold & self-centered. it bothered me that she didnt tell reid about the (ex) fiance. it bothered me more when she said that she basically developed feelings for reid because she had no one else to talk while in hiding. reid's feelings obviously went much deeper than that. i was hoping they would part ways in the least painful way for reid - having it end the way it did was not what I had in mind.
January 17th, 2013 2:15 AM
This episode was amazing,but it left me heartbroken for Reid!!! The question that formed in my mind while watching was why is it always Reid..... I was so happy that he found someone he could be happy with and it was all taken away in an instant......but the actors did some really good acting in this episode!!!
Rank: Recurring Character
January 17th, 2013 12:55 AM
It was a good episode but I hated the end I didn't want her to die but we will get good Raid reaction. Next couple of weeks and I will like to see how he griefs and how he deal with.
Rank: Regular Character
January 17th, 2013 12:03 AM
I thought the episode was amazing. I was so shocked when we found out the stalker was a woman. The whole time the woman had Maeve and her ex fiancé and the way she talked and what she wanted them to tell just kept making me think she was crazy. I had a pretty good idea that Maeve was going to die because on a thing I read about next weeks episode it said Reid would be dealing with a personal lost but I was still hoping she would live because I really wanted her to. When she died I was so sad and felt so bad for Reid I really wanted them to be together and be happy. Next episode should be interesting.
January 17th, 2013 12:02 AM
Sound like a other good one
Rank: Regular Character
January 16th, 2013 11:59 PM
It was interesting Reid picked Blake..........
I was disappointed that Reid didn't get to explore this relationship......
Damn it, I'm still wanting to know about this mysterious photographer...........