American Idol Review: The Top 28 Guys Revealed!

by at . Comments

It's been a long and sometimes tear-filled journey for the men of American Idol. They've survived auditions, sudden death eliminations, Group Rounds, and tonight they'll sing their final solo number for the judges.

Who will be left standing? Let's find out now...

Matheus Fernandes Picture

Cuts will be made after every 8th performance. 

Leading off the solo round is Paul Jolley who's quite nervous. So nervous he nearly cries before he can even sing and Mariah has to remind him to breathe. He's not able to overcome his nerves and Nicki calls his lack of confidence a "turn off" and unprofessional. 

Lazaro Arbos is the second to sing and chooses Lady Gaga's "Edge of Glory." Curtis Finch, Jr., sings "Jar of Hearts" and his theatrics distract from what could be an otherwise interesting arrangement of the number.

From the first group, Lazaro, Paul, and Curtis all move on. We might only be seeing the performances of those who will move forward, but we'll see.

In group two, Devin Velez dresses up "What A Wonderful World" and impresses the judges. Gupreet Singh Sarin sings "Georgia" and, as this is the first time in the competition that it's been allowed, he plays the guitar.

Cortez Shaw, who struggled in the sudden death round, seems to have found his footing before his final solo number. Matheus Fernandes says he's only used to singing in his car, which isn't true, and then butchers Kelly Clarkson's "Stronger."

Devin, Gupreet, Cortez, and Adam Sanders move on. Matheus is sent home.

As solo day continues, Nicholas Mathis' focus is on winning so that he can provide a better life for his children. He chooses a Bruno Mars number and doesn't do it justice. It's really a rough performance. Papa Peachez sings Lady Gaga's "You and I" and it's not good. 

Jimmy Smith, who struggled through the Group Round, performs "Landslide" and is the best of the three auditions we've seen in this set of 8. 

The judges send Nicholas and Papa Peachez home. Jimmy, returning contestant Johnny Keyser, and Vincent Powell move on.

Also returning from last year is Nick Boddington who takes a risk and plays the keyboard himself. It pays off as the judges are more than pleased with his performance. 

Charlie Askew gave a rambling, "smart" monologue about the girl he still loves as an introduction to Gotye's "Somebody That I Used to Know" after which Nicki calls him an artist. He responds, "I glorify weirdness." Yep, Charlie. Yep, you do.

Nick, Jada Davila, Mathenee Treco, and Charlie all move to the Top 28. 

Burnell Taylor and Marvin Calderon both sing "Jar of Hearts." Both advance in the competition. 

Changing it up with a country number, Micah Johnson sings Randy Travis' "I Told You So." His story, his spirit, and his voice are all amazing. The judges, however, wish he'd done more with the song and send him home. That was kind of shocking.

A list of the remaining contestants includes:

  • Adam Sanders
  • Bryant Tadeo 
  • Burnell Taylor
  • Charlie Askew
  • Chris Watson
  • Cortez Shaw
  • Curtis Finch, Jr.
  • David Willis
  • Devin Velez
  • Elijah Liu
  • Gurpreet Singh Sarin
  • Jimmy Smith
  • Johnny Keyser
  • Joshua “Josh” Holiday
  • Joshua “Josh” Jada Davila
  • Kevin Harris
  • Lazaro Arbos
  • Mathenee Treco
  • Nick Boddington
  • Paul Jolley
  • Peter Garrett
  • Vincent “Vince” Powell

But don't get too cozy with them just yet. Eight more of them will be cut next week after the girls storm Hollywood leaving us with a final Top 20.

What do you think of the list? Did the judges keep the right guys? Did they send the wrong ones home? Sound off in the comments! 

TV Fanatics Love Prime Instant Video
Amazon Prime Instant Video
Catch Up on Old Episodes
of Similar Shows and Old Favorites.

Miranda Wicker is a Staff Writer for TV Fanatic. Follow her on Twitter.

Tags: ,

I feel the same thing... However, it does not make sense to get hooked until the field is narrowed. It is so frustrating to start liking someone in the beginning only to find out they do not have what it takes to move on. I must say that the most refreshing part of this show is not Mariah but Nikki. She is so authentic and genuine. I am SHOCKED that I feel this way about her, being that I had a negative perception in the beginning. She gives HONEST constructive criticism. Simon would be proud of her and her Acerbic tongue with the contestants. She is not syrupy sweet yet she is also the most encouraging for those that need encouragement. Time will tell if the ratings for the Live Shows live up to their predecessors.


WOW nobody is interested in this show anymore.......perhaps it will pick up when the live shows start..........