Thursdays 10:00 PM on CBS

Elementary Review: No Matter What

by at .  Updated at . Comments

It has been a bit since Sherlock and Joan have had a truly creepy suspect with which to deal.

And while the writing behind Lucas Bundsch in Elementary Season 2 Episode 9 was supposed to give him that quiet kind of calm-creepy presences. I found Troy Garity's performance of Bundsch lacking.

I could never tell if Bundsch was really playing cat and mouse with Joan and Sherlock or if he was actually supposed to be innocent. Garity’s mostly flat and mild speech didn’t convey "controlled calm," it came across more like “bored actor” to me. Never a true evil smile, or a knowing grin, always just the same "blah" look.

Maybe I’ve just gotten spoiled with Jonny Lee Miller's in-depth and heartfelt portrayal as Sherlock. Take the conversation with Joan at the end of the episode about his true nature and that he is not a nice man. His body language, facial expression and general presence all conveyed the message as much as his words did.

A Frustrating Case

Also, on the flip side from Garity’s seemingly lackluster performance, I really enjoyed Captain Gregson’s discussion about how good Sherlock was with Detective Coventry. It was great to see Gregson take pride in the work that he and Watson do and while he says he sticks his neck out, we never really get to see it first hand.

Speaking of Detective Coventry, Chris Bauer has been playing Andy Bellefleur, a stubborn, hard-nosed, yet kind of lazy town sheriff for the last six years on True Blood... was he really the best choice to play a stubborn hard-nosed, yet kind of lazy police detective?

Don’t get me wrong, he did a great job at the role, in some ways it may have been too good. I found myself yell things like "Jeez Andy, what were you thinking?" at the TV. Who knows, with True Blood wrapping up next season, maybe Bauer will become a recurring character here and I’ll start to remember the right now.

In the end, Sherlock and Joan turned out to be correct: Bundsch was a serial killer and was keeping the women prisoner in his sound studio before killing them. Though we did get a pleasant surprise when they found Kathy Spalding alive and reunited her with her husband.

Elementary Season 2 returns with a new installment on December 5.


Editor Rating: 4.1 / 5.0
  • 4.1 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 3.9 / 5.0 (50 Votes)

Jim G. is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.

Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more Elementary?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic


The Bridge Review: Butterflies

On tonight's The Bridge, the search for Eleanor continues. Will she kill again before she's found?

Extant Review: More Believable Than The Truth

On Extant, Molly reveals her pregnancy to John. However, Sparks' story isn't exactly a plausible explanation.

Graceland Review: Angels and Demons

On Graceland, Mike, Briggs and the team pull out all the stops to get Paige back. Read our review of "The Unlucky One" to find out if they were successful.

Suits Review: Another You Problem

On Suits, Rachel and Jessica's life choices seep their way into the business of the men in their lives, some of which only cause more problems. Read out review of "Litt the Hell Up."


I also found Garity's performance refreshing. I actually doubted they would find anything at his studio ;-)


I actually liked Garity's performance tonight because of the flatness of it. I sort of enjoyed that he never gave on that Sherlock and Joan were right, it let us keep doubt as viewers. I was honestly wondering up until the end if it was really him or not, which I liked as the whole "you and I both know it's me but you can't prove it" dance has been done a lot. To me it was refreshing. And maybe it's just me, but I was a little thrown by Sherlock and Joan's discussion about him at the end. It's not that I disagree with what he said, it was just that it almost seemed to toss all his character growth since the start of the show. He has grown so much and come so far all while still remaining true to himself and while being able to maintain and use his skills, and what he said about making an effort with Joan makes it all seem like an act(for lack of a better word). More than that, it felt uncomfortable and... I don't know, just off. But again, maybe it's me.

@ Allie

I don't think the conversation at the end was weird. He's only nice to Watson and makes exceptions for her. I actually like that he let her know so she can save her energy getting upset. He's only had growth where she was involved.

@ Allie

The conversation at the end did feel a little weird. It was well delivered (as always) but you're right, it seemed that this case has picked open a wound of some sort.