NCIS Review: Casserole Comfort

at .  Updated at . Comments

While this somber episode didn't complete the Parsa story arc as I'd hoped, it did provide more insight into the family nature of the NCIS team, especially when one of their members is hurting.

Tony & Bishop

NCIS Season 11 Episode 13 carried on where the last previous installment left off: Delilah awakened after surgery to find McGee at her bedside.

Their conversation was short-lived, though, as she had to be sent back to surgery as a result of some internal bleeding. Shortly afterwards, McGee went back to work, despite not yet being cleared by the Navy psychiatrist.

Though he carried a heavy secret, McGee appeared fit and ready for duty. The only clue to his turmoil showed up in his body language: he carried his angst in his neck, which made him appear slumped over, most notably when he walked anywhere. 

Gibbs picked up on it right away and advised him to take it easy. At that point, I had no idea whether he was still in shock over Delilah being hurt in the blast or whether he blamed himself (which as it turns out he did).

We saw yet another side of Tony, who couldn't figure out just how he could help his friend and colleague, so he landed on making him a casserole. I thought that was perfect. He couldn't keep sitting around trying to figure out what to do for him; this was the best he could come up with. Something personal, appropriate, useful and above all, warm.

Yet, there was nothing that could get through to McGee: not Gibbs' constant reminders that he was more important than his job, not Abby's hug and not Tony's casserole. His secret wouldn't allow him comfort of any kind.

McGee wasn't looking for sympathy and in fact tried hard to show himself as being unaffected and ready for work - only because he didn't believe he deserved any kind of warmth or comfort from anyone. He thought it should have been him who was hurt in the blast. It should have been him who was paralyzed and not Delilah.

That's devastating stuff to consider. 

What would he do without Gibbs and his words of wisdom? Gibbs' advice to just talk to Delilah, and in effect just be there for her, was his salvation of sorts: confronting the reality of her horrific injury and holding her hand was far better than avoiding it.

McGee's heartfelt request to Gibbs at the end was tender and gripping.

Boss, would you mind sitting with me?


Final thoughts:

  • Parsa is still in the wind. Finding his driver and learning that Parsa was on a train bound for Miami, but that he was getting off it before the city, brought the NCIS a little closer to the terrorist, but not by much.
  • Abby's discovery that the two bolts that were found in the wreckage didn't match factory parts stretched my ability to suspend disbelief to the snapping point. 
  • Parsa's driver saw himself as somewhat of a moral person, and certainly not a terrorist. Really? I suppose some people have the ability to rationalize their behavior beyond belief too.
  • Tony's flirting with Martinez at the NSA seemed out of place. Granted, he didn't know at the time that Delilah was paralyzed, but still: everyone was concerned about McGee.
  • Did you catch the movie reference between Tony and Sofia, starring Robert Redford and Debra Winger? Tony referenced it out loud. It was the 1986 film "Legal Eagles."
  • Speaking of Tony and Martinez: they are both attracted to each other, yet are annoyed with each other too. What does that mean for the future?
  • Bishop is coming along nicely, learning more about her boss (mostly from Tony) and discovering more about the team as well. And Gibbs has no problem pulling her down from her lotus perch on the desk.


  • There is a new Gibbs rule!  I missed it the first time around.   It showed up when Abby met Gibbs when he was leaving the elevator.  Rule #62: Give people space when they get off of the elevator.
  • Check out our NCIS Round Table discussion for this episode.

What did you think? Were you shocked at the news about Delilah? Is Tony a stand-up guy for Tim or what? Is there anything else he could or should have done for his friend?

Tony has either met the one person with whom he should never have a relationship, or the one person in the world who understands him. What does the future hold for them?


Editor Rating: 4.2 / 5.0
  • 4.2 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 4.3 / 5.0 (94 Votes)

Douglas Wolfe is a staff writer for TV Fanatic Follow him on Twitter



Bishop is growing on me; the only thing I dislike is this (so far) consistent tendency every show she's been in that shows her as smarter than everyone else on the team. I get that she's a whiz - at her skill set; she's good by virtue of her unique abilities, but it shouldn't make her better than this already existing senior team.


Loved the ending with Gibbs and McGee it was so poignant. One compliant I have with the Bishop character is that when she goes to a crime scene she doesn't pull her back in a ponytail or bun like Ziva and Kate used to. I always thought that it was a realistic aspect so that the crime scene wouldn't be contaminated. Can't believe we have to wait two weeks for a new episode when we've only had two new episodes this year. Darn February sweeps!


Sometimes you think Gibbs is a robot who seems almost incapable of human feeling, but then the writers redeem him with scenes like the one that ended last night's episode. It was very Gibbs-ish, given that it didn't take place in his basement. He's not a wordy guy, but just being there means he was able to take his own advice -- that the team members are bigger than the job, not the other way around. Almost wish it was Tony in that scene, but I can understand why it wasn't. Tony is the guy who ultimately still struggles with knowing what to do ... but Gibbs is the guy, when push comes to shove, who is there no matter what. Really nice scene. I thought Sean Murphy was spectacular as well.


My question is... Where was Sofia Martinez sitting when she was in a teleconference with Tony and Bishop?? It looks like the lobby of NSA...Nobody has a secure VTC in a lobby of a building...not even NSA.

@ D Dub

She was in the room of the NSA building where Tony first met her.


I tell you what story arc are saving this show after the dark years of Tiva this show is fixing it mistake So questions how did abby get the picture to show up with out plugging it in? Could Mcgee be gay? I hope Tony do date that woman he need some TLC after being with the biggest bitch in the world


Okay, I really do hate story arcs and "TBC"... but this was a heartbreaker. I actually wanted to cry when Dr. Rachel told Bishop that her desk "was special"...a really wonderful moment. Tony caring so much about Tim, Gibbs willingness to tell him that he was more important then the job, and finally the end image of Gibbs sitting with Tim... A top ten episode!


These story arcs featuring high-profile killers are getting longer and longer. Next week's ep is a repeat, which means CBS we're probably in for a few more eps before the time for Feb sweeps. #TiredOldTrope

@ MrWriteSF

CBS counter-programming Olympics with reruns...


Cue Delilah getting written completely outta the show. Finally something to turn up the Abby-Tim dynamic, and already ruined.


One thing I really like that we've seen for the second time now is how Gibbs reacts during a tragedy involving a team member. What I mean by that is when Vance's wife was in the hospital, Gibbs stood outside the door like a military guard until he heard from Leon. Tonight, when Magee asked him to sit with him, did you notice how Gibbs was sitting? Straight up and no slouching whatsoever. Once a Marine, always a Marine.

Tags: ,

NCIS Season 11 Episode 13 Quotes

McGee: I should have been here when you woke up.
Delilah: You're here now.

Boss, would you mind sitting with me?