Tuesdays 8:00 PM on FOX
Glee

Glee Review: Nationals!

by at .  Updated at . Comments

The “That’s what you missed on Glee!” recap is basically everything that the show has cut all season to cover more interesting stuff in NYC.

It looks like Glee Season 5 Episode 11 will be 99.999% Ohio people.

Ooooo, talking about Finn. Is this the first time they’ve done it casually? I feel like it is and it’s sort of sad and sweet and poignant. Followed by MORE talking about Finn. It’s suddenly really really dusty here in my living room.

Clearly the show is worried about depressing everyone, because all the Finn-membering is followed by the most cliched L.A. montage ever. Hollywood sign! Tour bus! Vintage cameras!

Mercedes is famous now and makes a joke about a “lame follow-up Christmas album,” which I can only assume is the show being self-aware.  

Would a teacher really take 12 students to L.A. without a hotel reservation? Do they not have Travelocity in Ohio?

“Throat Explosion” is almost as good as “The Treble Makers" and if you haven’t seen Pitch Perfect you probably won’t understand anything I say for the rest of this review.

We even get a PICTURE of Finn? I wonder if some sort of safe, round number of days has passed since Cory Monteith’s death and now the writers feel like we’re ready.

GOOD LORD, GLEE. Up and down and up and down and my emotions cannot handle this episode.

All the Jake-Marley-Ryder drama happens so long ago that I barely remember it. Or maybe because it was really boring.

The judges are deaf, from the 80's and the Prancersize lady. Clearly this show choir competition is Very Important To Everyone Except Not At All.

OF COURSE Throat Explosion does amazing, because they are the TV version of Pitch Perfect. Who knew a Mr. Roboto/Counting Stars combination would be possible?

Finn’s parents tried to leave but came back to give an inspirational speech. This is the Finn episode to make you feel better about how they tried to erase him from Glee history with that Christmas-Episode-That-Shall-Not-Be-Named.

Depressing thought of the night: None of the New Directions were not born when Boston and Neil Diamond released these songs. YOU probably weren’t born either.Knowing I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For is Finn’s favorite song makes me like Finn more and makes me like the Glee version a lot more.

SO MUCH DUST. OMG. My cold, snarky heart has grown three sizes and this is my favorite episode of the season. This is better than the actual Finn tribute episode, although that’s partly because I haven’t been sobbing so hard I missed half of it. Just some nice, respectable crying.

If Mercedes really wanted to help Marley, couldn’t she just record one of her songs now?

I am actually shocked the New Directions lost. Shocked. After all that set up they’re going to let them just be sad? NOW I’M DEPRESSED AGAIN. Dammit Glee.

I KNEW this “Finn would be proud” speech was coming and I knew it was going to be cheesy, but it’s worse than I thought. I mean, I get it, but it feels like another cliche. I almost wish they had said "Yeah, he'd be SUPER pissed you lost."

Coach Sue is turning the choir room into classrooms and selling the band’s instruments to buy computers. That is the most reasonable she has ever been. I love slightly sympathetic but tough Sue, even if I am pretty sure Mr. Shue doesn’t care about a stupid computer lab and would rather keep his Glee Club.

Next week: 100th episode! Best songs! Britney comes back and I CANNOT WAIT!

Did you like the way this episode paid tribute to Finn?

 

Watch a promo for Glee Season 5 Episode 12:

Review

Editor Rating: 4.5 / 5.0
  • 4.5 / 5.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
User Rating:

Rating: 3.7 / 5.0 (29 Votes)
Tags: ,
Avatar

I agree completely with this review! I was also thinking it was nice to finally have a nice, sweet episode dedicated to Finn. And to actually see flashbacks of him! Though that was a little tough. I was surprised we didn't get any flashbacks or anything in "The Quarterback", so that was a nice surprise for this episode. I just wasn't expecting this one to be all that emotional because it was a total surprise! I really thought New Directions should have won. If they're doing an episode about basically making Finn proud, coming in 2nd is kind of lame. But I get it, it's the set up for the big 100th episode so all the original cast members can come back and fight for the glee club to stay. But I'm sure they could have figured out a different scenario for that. I know the storyline with Sam was kind of out of left field, but it's nice to see him grow a little bit. And he's a really likeable person by his classmates, so it makes sense for him to be a leader. He just needed a push to get there. It was nice to see them focus on the seniors quite a bit during Nationals too. And yes, Throat Explosion was amazing, but I think pretty much anything Skylar Astin does is amazing!! I also thought the Jake/Marley/Ryder scene was pretty boring. Do we even care about them anymore? Not really... Especially if they're going to be done after this season anyways. No point in focusing on that! Oh well, can't wait until next week when Brittany and the whole gang return!

Avatar

I think Glee's purpose in proclaiming Sam the leader of ND was to show some character growth and maturity before they move to NY. The show did a disservice to Sam the last 2 seasons by making him a cliched hot dumb blonde. I think they tried to correct some of that with last night's episode. The question is will his maturity be permanent...I hope so!

Avatar

Using a cheap montage of Finn to cover how mediocre the ND were was an obnoxious move. The U2 cover was horrendous, but America was an insult to Neil Diamond.
Propping Sam as Finn 2.0 by any means, calling him a leader when he never lead anything and doesn't have the IQ to do so? WTF?
What an awful episode.

Avatar

Okay, now that Nationals is over, can we get over with anything blaine, sam etc from Glee? Let's focus on what's promised, more Kurt and Rachel. Actually more Kurt, please, because Rachel already has heavy storyline. Chris Colfer got too much talent to be wasted like this!
please more songs and quality storyline for him...!

Glee Season 5 Episode 11 Quotes

Best of luck New Directions, we really can’t wait to see your set...and crush you like a bug.

Jean-Baptiste

Do you seriously have no idea who that is? Do none of you read the show choir blogs?

Blaine

Glee Season 5 Episode 11 Music

  Song Artist
Glee-cast-vacation Vacation Glee Cast iTunes
Glee-cast-mr-roboto-slash-counting-stars Mr. Roboto/Counting Stars Glee Cast iTunes
Glee-cast-america-glee-cast-version America (Glee Cast Version) Glee Cast iTunes
x Close Ad