Tuesdays 9:00 PM on CW

Supernatural Season 9 Report Card: Grade It!

by at .  Updated at . Comments

Angels on Earth. Crowley fighting to maintain leadership of Hell. And Winchester brotherly drama to the extreme.

After nine years, you'd think fighting the supernatural would be a lot easier for Sam and Dean.

While Supernatural Season 9 seemed overly full of its storylines (some not so great), the trip to find balance on Earth and with Sam and Dean ultimately led right back to what makes this series so exciting. Can you still believe that last minute shot with Dean!?

Join us as we run down Supernatural Season 9 in our latest TV Fanatic Report Card...

Are We Going to Interrogate an Angel?

Best Episode: I'm going with the mid-season finale that ended with dramatic consequences, Supernatural Season 9 Episode 9. This was a snowballing of chaos that included plenty of angel fighting angel actions, some true backstory about Gadreel and the heartbreaking death of Kevin Tran. This was a major turning point for the season that would amp up Dean's desires to take down Metatron, and the hour was just full of Supernatural goodness that included its key players.

Worst Episode: It's really not surprising the CW didn't pick up the Supernatural spin-off after Supernatural Season 9 Episode 20. Maybe outside of the Supernatural realm, it might have had a better chance, but ultimately, this hour was a soap opera that was overly glossy in its efforts to push dramatic family struggles and forbidden love. Yes, Sam and Dean were there, but they too by the end took the first phone call as an excuse to get out of there. The only real redeeming aspect was actor Nathaniel Buzolic, who brought a charm and likeabiltiy to his role.

Best Character: Sam and Dean will ultimately always top the list as great characters, but that's too easy of a choice. So I'm going to mirror my Supernatural Season 8 Report Card choice with Crowley. He's continued to be such a great addition to the show and actor Mark Sheppard nails it every time. Whether he's whipping out clever quips, raging against his enemies, showing some human emotion after his human blood addiction or just being classic Crowley, he's the villain you love to watch.

And his final scene with Dean in Supernatural Season 9 Episode 23 was a mesmerizing one explaining to the brother the circumstances of his "death." He's certainly solidified his mark on Supernatural history.

Worst Character: While there were plenty of angels that barely had time to stick around for me to remember their names, a character like Ennis at least had a whole episode pretty much devoted to him in Supernatural Season 9 Episode 20. Unfortunately, Ennis turned out to be rather uninteresting, and everything he said and did felt extreme and forced.

Even his choice to kill a human (not a supernatural creature) made no sense. It was like the episode was trying too hard, especially with this character, and I'm perfectly OK if we never get back to Chicago to check up on him.

Character I Want to Return: This has to be Cain. His one time appearance (played by Timothy Omundson) was memorable, and I loved the backstory for his character and the dark path he took. Plus, his ominous warning to Dean before transferring the Mark of Cain means he's bound to reappear. Or maybe, I'm just hoping he will.

Hopes for Supernatural Season 10: Jumping right off into Dean as a demon, I hope we see that storyline play out and not necessarily get fixed at the end of the premiere. I'm curious to see Dean with his powers, especially how he'll act now that he's a demon.

Ultimately (and if this does wind up being the last season), I'd at least like to see Sam and Dean reunited for the last half of the season on the same page, together, without some drama in the way, fighting the good fight with all their great banter and brotherly ways right until the last credits roll.

Really, I'd like to see this next season focus on one major thing, so it doesn't become overcrowded in an effort to get to that final moment. But either way, I can't wait to see what happens next. Supernatural always gets me excited for its next season.

Overall Grade: B-

Your turn, TV Fanatics! What would you grade Supernatural Season 9?


Sean McKenna is a TV Fanatic Staff Writer. Follow him on Twitter.

Tags: ,
Like Us On Facebook

Want more Supernatural?

Sign up for our daily newsletter and receive the latest tv news delivered to your inbox for free!

More From TV Fanatic


EXCLUSIVE: Jared Padelecki Scoops Supernatural!

Jared Padelecki sat down with TV Fanatic this week to tease Supernatural Season 10. What's on tap? Fnd out now!

Penny Dreadful Season 1 Report Card: Grade It!

What were the best and worst moments from Penny Dreadful Season 1? Check out our Report Card and give it a grade yourself.

Supernatural Season 10 Synopsis: Down a Dark Path

Supernatural Season 10 kicks off in October. Read the network's official synopsis of what's on tap.

19 TV Shows That Ask... Whodunit?!?

Procedural television shows have come a long way. In this list we'll find not only the expected, but the unexpected. Vote for the best!


B for me..
Agree with the reviewer - Crowley is the best character. Right up there with Dean.
Excited to see demon Dean. Hope he hasn't lost his facial expressions :)


You nailed it on the worst episode, and the character I most want to see return. The episode with Cain in it was like something you'd see on a major network. Very classy and well written.


They should have introduced the whole Demon Dean (and the inevitable Chevy Impala Devil-mobile) in season 4, when he was resurrected from hell. This feels like a resurrected storyline. Notice how Sam was driving around with Castiel in a tired, old Delta 88 on the Season 9 finale? Is he ever going to get the keys for more than five minutes?


I'm not surprised there is no mention of Castiel in the above review. His role during season 9 was utterly unremarkable, as was Misha Collins' acting performances. In short, we've seen better from Castiel (and Misha) in prior seasons. I'm not insulting Misha the actor, who I find to be quite good. I just think Castiel has become dead weight on Supernatural during this past season. We'll see if season 10 corrects that.


His love for Dean? I admit he does love him, but not enough for him to transport and keep Dean from dying.... I thought he would at the last minute.... he didn't.


This may have come out a bit harsh. I DO like Misha the actor quite a bit. I blame the writers really, not him.


FYI, Misha Collins/Castiel won the Best Supporting Actor award at CW for S9 by a landslide. 55% of the vote. So where does he fall in your S9 review? NO WHERE!


Your silence on Cas' SL in S9 is utterly deafening. You write as if he didn't even exist. The culmination of his journey in admitting his love for one man, Dean Winchester, even over Heaven and his own family, sets up an interesting parallel to Sam's brotherly love for Dean going into S10. How could you have missed this?


Oh! I grade this year a C- I did like some episodes.


Sorry, I am so tired of Metatron, Crowley and the plot that these guys always win. It's so redundant and boring. I though this was the last season and was looking forward to it ending. Don't think I will be watching next year. The Innes story is suppose to be a spin off which I will not be watching. The actor is cute but cannot carry a show and his story line is over. The Sam and Dean (love them and why I still watch) plots are always the same they get beat up, killed, resurrected and the bad guys always win. Love Cass but he is on once in a while.


Ditto! You nailed it! Only reason I watch anymore was I hoped it would wrap up nicely, making up for the past 2-3 seasons. Reason for the big CW wins? It's the only CW show outside of the Vampire Diaries that's regularly mentioned by critics and has a significant fan base. Both are way past their prime. Compared to early season it rates a D.


I gave it a B


B- is probably right. The Sam/Dean rift storyline is getting tiresome, especially since we dealt with it during season 8 as well. Also, there were far too many plotlines that were just dropped. For example, shouldn't we have learned a bit more about the other angel factions and Malaki in particular? Another problem was the over-use of camp (for example, Slumber Party and Crawley's son). It got worse towards the end of the seasons, where there were a few unforgivable mistakes the writers made that frankly were an insult to us fans. Bloodlines being one of these mistakes, and also the re-writing of reaper lore turning them into angels. Still, episodes 1-2, 7, 9-11, 14, 16-19 and the season finale were all exceptional.