Avatar

@David Adamson - One of the things we're talking about here is how real the show is, meaning will they detect an air bubble in the heart? A Google answer: "The detection of air embolisms requires special precautions during autopsy. An aspirometer has to be used for the detection, measurement and storage of gas. The aspirometer has to be filled completely with distilled water containing two drops of Tween 80 to reduce the surface tension of the water and to prevent adherence of small air bubbles to the wall of the aspirometer. Subsequently the gas has to be analysed by gas chromatography. When the results correspond with the main criteria defined by Pierucci and Gherson the diagnosis "air embolism" is justified. The technique for the detection of air embolism is simple but requires a careful procedure."

Avatar

... or, a real example, the New York Yankees honchos thought they were a classy (pinstripe) organization, so they debated trading Mickey Mantle long and hard when the rookie was openly living with a stripper who got him to sign over 10% of his earnings to her, which became public knowledge when the media ran, tongue in cheek, with her story and the way he paid her, but of course Mantle was special; however, to the point @estatica made, several years after Mantle retired, the very same honchos who put up with him early on, ordered him to do some promotional work (he received a stipend for that), saying he hasn't hit any home runs for the Yankees lately!

Avatar

@euterpe - I do agree with your laws of physics thinking. It's a matter of whether or not the audience member liking/disliking an entertainment can suspend their disbelief to enjoy the show or can't and is annoyed by the depicted supposed reality. That said, there are exceptions made in all fields for "characters" who are super highly regarded in reality (BUT, admittedly, way way more so in fiction -- for instance John Sandford's Lucas Davenport, a fictional Minnesota state cop who solves problems for the Governor, and about whom the fictional FBI says Minnesota doesn't have the death penalty except for Lucas Davenport)

Avatar

@watcher - It took awhile to read all this and do see you're not much of a Jane fan (to see no reason not to hold him to the same standards as others in CBI); so, not wanting to ratchet up disagreement, but accept that may be. What I want to add is my sense of how the CBI has treated Jane as their special treasure right from the start, but came right out and had Hightower say it and that Lisbon's job and performance ratings were only on how well she controlled Jane, that if she couldn't, she was gone (and Jane was told that Lisbon was his "whipping boy," and that whatever happened to Lisbon was up to him since he was so valuable to the CBI and she wasn't).

Avatar

Do not like Elizabeth Shue on this show at all. Watched last night's episode (3/20/2013) to see if I could stand her better ... nope, but also thought so many of old cast look old and out of shape (to put it kindly). Danson was a great addition (and has hopefully run out of family to be accused of crimes or kidnapped), but can't imagine how show can continue???

Avatar

I think Glee is over -- just hanging on to their diehard fans. The 5 million could be enough to keep it going on Fox forever (or not), but I don't think, no matter where they're scheduled, they'll jump up again to, for instance, being scheduled to follow the Super Bowl. Lea Michele should still have a super career, however -- when she can get out of her Glee contract!

Avatar
Elementary Review: B leads to A

It was good to see Alfredo back, if even briefly. I like when shows expand the universe a little with recurring peripheral characters -- and wonder/hope Watson's reporter friend could return, either helping them find some information or bringing them a sticky problem. That would be fun!

Avatar

I thought it was good fun to see them dressing up and acting like adults. It even made sense to me that there would be such times/moments with the women in their lives for long enough already to be an influence. There might even be some more fun in them acting like adults in certain situations (or trying to)!

Avatar

I think where they mess up the characters (@womansciencegeek's comments) is the staff sitting around fleshing out the comedy/jokes each episode going to standard fodder (Sheldon's self-worth, Penny's sex life, Penny's IQ, Raj's shyness, etc.) -- running jokes. But they mess up when they sometimes turn Sheldon into really dislikable/despicable or Penny into a slut. However, I like the Penny-Leonard dynamic this season -- how much Penny seems to want Leonard to want her. She seems to be orbiting around him in a way this year that is either a development or a slip of the comedy staff's joke writing (like her friends are now only the women in his friends' lives). She's acting more like she's in love than that Leonard just happens to be the guy she's seeing. I like it!

Avatar

@Ceepee -- great insight. Thanks! Your take makes me wonder what other episode stories I've not even known were there over the years ...