Avatar
Castle Round Table: Sexy P.I. Role Play

My friend you need to reconcile how Castle PI with the vows. you haven't.
Pi's depend on their police network for a start and do mostly sordid work as ACCURATELY portrayed in episode 3 of season 1 but like everything else that is forgotten.

Comment modified at

Avatar
Castle Round Table: Sexy P.I. Role Play

The PI arc makes no sense. apparently again all reviewers want to ignore their vows. Being a PI does NOT make him a partner in crime which is essential to the overall ??Caskett relationship, It shows up both Castle and Beckett as extremely stupid people. To be a successful PI you need a police network, Castle does not have one, Typically the writers had done NO research at all Espo nor Ryan do not realise how much in debt they are in to Castle. Typically Castle doesn't bring this up. It just added to the superficiality of the episode. I am indifferent. No it is boring once it has been done. Far too many and asymptomatic of the season thus far. Not thought out at all. It makes the characters ( and reviewers ) look very stupid as no-one can reconcile their wedding vows and Castle being a PI indeed it seems the reviewers don't recall the vows. Well they didn't know Lanie hated her mother either!

Comment modified at

Avatar

Just like last week.
how come Caskett have forgotten their vows. how come no-one wanted to fight the decision made on Castle? A pleasant episode but where does Castle find the time to write? He is always doing something when he comes back to the Loft with Beckett.
Writing was fun but that was said in the first season and thus forgotten by the writers. The best line was Castle saying he was lucky because he was married to Beckett .Very cheesy but very Castle.
Makes it very strange Gina would divorce him. We all know why Meredith had to go. Bring on 3XK and his girlfriend!

Comment modified at

Avatar

Our Roy Montgomery,
What are your thoughts that NO-ONE thought about fighting this absurd, unjust decision made on an extremely lame reason.
It appears Caskett have completely forgotten their vows.

Avatar

Crikey everyone here has forgotten their vows ' Partners in CRIME and LIFE'. roundtable is marloweing Why didn't Caskett realise the implications of this for them and want to fight. What about Espo and Ryan. Are they comrades in arms or not. Why didn't they want to fight the decision.And then we have have the hapless and incompetent Gates, Even she knbows it is an unjust decision but she does...nothing. What a leader. Being a PI is a stupid decision and he is not her partner in crime. Never mind the expense of a long term lease, the fit out and other costs book-keeper, accounting .legal etc. All for what? an indulgence? They are both idiots. None would behave that way to a former colleague who has been the subject of such a manifestly unjust decision. I do not want to see him as a PI. Who would hire him. He has no police network at all and no client to say how 'good' he is. It is an indulgence. What happened to Writing is fun not work. Oh that was said in season 1 and so is forgotten! That the relationship has no substance. If neither understand the meaning of their vows then they are both pretty superficial people. The lack of comradery between the team and Castle. They owe him! This would not occur in Australia. We finally got what should occur after building theory but how come they have clothes on after 'hot sex' and no hair ruffled at all. i must ask them how they do that.

Avatar

I find this so sad. The writer clearly didn't understand the wedding vows, Caskett have forgotten about it already, the reviewer didn't understand them nor has anyone writing thus far. Partners in crime and in life was obviously put in after the disastrous and highly stupid decision to go to DC. Castle near death came about because Beckett had no clue that the Caskett professional relationship is closely interlinked with their relationship at home.
Castle PI is not a partner nor does it even come close. Why didn't Beckett say this is a terrible decision let's fight it.We have to for our relationship.
Why didn't Espo and Ryan say we owe you Bro. Let's get this asinine decision over-turned.
How come Gates didn't say This decision is unjust and made on completely specious grounds we will fight it. We will meet at the Castles tonight and Mr Castle we will need Mr Weldon. He knows where the skeletons are buried and his knowledge of strategy is unparalleled.
This is what would have occurred in real life whether it is overt or covert matters not
Instead we got this.Everyone meekly accepting a manifestly unjust decision made on very lame grounds
The writers are still coming to terms with Caskett ( at least he wasn't gawking at Strippers) and having little idea of the supporting characters. If Espo keeps on like this i want him out and can someone finally sack Gates. She isn't just incompetent but very very stupid. Castle wastes money on leasing an office in Manhattan and fitting it out? Lease would be long term as well. He also has book-keeping, accounting legal fees as well.
A PI cannot be a partner to a detective. No man is that stupid. I agree it was a fun episode ( but you need some semblance of realism and this has very little) but why cannot the writers apart from Winter think about what a relationship is. Can we not have consistent characters please. Only in Ryan have they got there almost. On a funny note can I say Caskett are the only people to wear clothes after a night of hot sex and nothing occurs to their hair. Remarkable! A pleasant passable episode but it could have been so much better, We could have had all the characters enriched. The 12th against City Hall and it doesn't contradict their vows at all and is a much more interesting plot.

Comment modified at

Avatar

I am recanting
This episode has the Creaseys showing they had no idea Becket went to the from in Season 1, they had no idea that Lanie hated her mum in Season 3 and finally they had Castle , a man whose life revolves around Beckett ,showing her complete disrespect with regard to the trip club. Sack them.
How a reviewer could not recognise all this is beyond me as well.

Comment modified at

Avatar

I am with you Our Roy Montgomery.
Indeed I would go further I would sack the Creasys.
They had no idea about the prom, nor Lanie hating her mother and Castle and the Strip Club was simply utterly stupid.
nor did this reviewer either by the way!

Avatar

last episode of season 1. moreover she was with a large group of friends in her LAST year of high school. ( food to die for) so rebel becks is another myth.
It would have seen by everyone she didn't go because she didn't have Brent Edwards. in Aussie terms she would be viewed as four fifths up herself and that would be the correct observation. They should sack writers who have no idea of what has happened in previous episodes.

Avatar

right on Justin