Avatar

As I said Marlowe would love you. Bad memory and all.
well you have got the season you deserve.

Avatar

Shelley please read. Beckett never qualified what prom she went to. She had to to back your interpretation up and i am n\being very generous here.given both She and Ryan were alluding to a senior prom and neither said anything like I went to a junior/Senior prom as well.
Moreover food to die for showed the smelling like a Teen spirit was written by lazy writers for lazy people. In this episode Caskett are at a SENIOR prom. When you groqw up ans marry you wil find if a man gives up a lot of time to help bring money in then the wife doesn't want the husband acting like a twenty year old. He hasn't been at the house because of two jobs to see either Jenny or the kid. Yes VERY basic you open your heart to someone you are in love with but neither do. We know the AU Beckett episode showed she still hadn't told Castle yet she told Sorensen! If you are talking about insults then look in the mirror. If you think saying you enjoy mediocre tv is insulting I enjoyed JAG it is was the same. I think I have shown you do not like to think too much nor remember too much in previous episodes. A bit like Marlowe actually!

Avatar

Yes but Beckett NEVER said that thus you must think she is lying ( again.)
Ryan was practicing AFTER work at the precinct in the episode! They talk so much but not about his divorces, how important her books were to her or even about having children let alone jobs! you miss a lot. no wonder you love mediocrity.

Avatar

but is based on New York today not in 3015. You need some part of reality otherwise it is merely a fairytale

Avatar

that is why it is called science FICTION.

Avatar

Leo, it is impossible to invest in a relationship which bears no resemblance to reality. You have to have some realism in it.

Avatar

really. The only thing i remember is some 'fan' unable to remember Beckett went to the Prom. we learnt this in season 1 The Creaseys were to lazy to understand that. Can you tell me why Ryan would be using his spare timne practicing dance moves instead of being home with his wife and child given the episode before this episode.
How about Beckett? She sung without any problems at the Precinct and at the Hamptons but now we learn she doesn't want to sing in public. How come she and Castle didn't talk about this after the Hamptons.
I forgot they never talk

Avatar

Grow up Grey.
I have a write ( deliberate) to say how I feel.
You like mediocre episodes.
I don't.
I do not nit pick.
Surely the writers should know about Ryan's part-time job.
Surely they should know how a marriage operates. if they don't they should ask their parents.
If I did nitpick then you have pointed it out. If my criticisms were not soundly based some-one would have pointed it out. Yes errors were made in earlier seasons but not in such a consistent manner.That is the point. I might note This site simply has not all the people that used to write here. From its highpoint of Watershed people simply have left.

Avatar

Jennifer you need to understand what a troll is.
I commented on the very issues the roundtable talked about. How anyone could think that is trolling is truly mystifying. I am waiting/ hoping for an episode that reaches the standards we saw back in seasons 1-4.

Avatar

I wasn't surprised because Caskett do not talk nor do they talk about important things. They are the antithesis of a married couple. Castle may have been surprised given her karaoke performance at the Hamptons but if a person doesn't share they have no trust. How did Ryan have time for this. He was saying only the LAST episode his part-time job might mean his daughter may not see him and he has time to practice intricate dancing steps. Some people have no memories! This was stupid as well. No mature man takes a bet on such a thing. Castle is now closer to 50 than 40 and showing it. Can we know at least have a mature married man? not al ot in this episode to recommend itself which is quite common this season.