Avatar

I am recanting
This episode has the Creaseys showing they had no idea Becket went to the [rom in Season 1, they had no idea that Lanie hated her mu in Season 3 and finally they had Castle , a man whose life revolves around Beckett ,showing her complete disrespect with regard to the trip club. Sack them.
how a reviewer could not recognise all this is beyond me as well.

Avatar

I am with you Our Roy Montgomery.
Indeed I would go further I would sack the Creasys.
They had no idea about the prom, nor Lanie hating her mother and Castle and the Strip Club was simply utterly stupid.
nor did this reviewer either by the way!

Avatar

last episode of season 1. moreover she was with a large group of friends in her LAST year of high school. ( food to die for) so rebel becks is another myth.
It would have seen by everyone she didn't go because she didn't have Brent Edwards. in Aussie terms she would be viewed as four fifths up herself and that would be the correct observation. They should sack writers who have no idea of what has happened in previous episodes.

Avatar

right on Justin

Avatar
Castle Round Table: Rick's Lump of Coal

How come 'critics' cannot remember Lanie whoopsy Espo saying Lanie hated her mother in Set up. you have memories as bad as Marlowe. A clear and obvious error. too many have occurred in recent times. About time, no chemistry whatsoever. Castle was in magnificent form in not taking away the occasion from his wife. something every husband should do. PI is ridiculous. This was the lamest excuse to stop Castle going to the Precinct. It would have been better if the team got together lead by Gates and attempted to overturn this. It would not be hard. This would have the added advantage of Gates telling Castle how wrong she has been about Castle and Castle understanding just how much he is appreciated. A serious episode is needed not badly attempted humour. Castle gawking at strippers whilst with Beckett. His whole life revolves around Beckett. If writers do not understand the character then sack them! The end scene and Castle simply wanting Beckett to enjoy the moment.

Comment modified at

Avatar

have you ever looked at Castle? He has the worst wardrobe around except of course for his mother. it has been consistent for 7 seasons for both!

Avatar

sorry but I do not understand. the DC job proved Beckett took no account of what Castle got out of being her partner.That is one of the reasons he got poisoned

Avatar

He couldn't have taken a break as he was interviewed for two new books, presumably the Storm book was changed somewhat. how he found the time is another error by the writers!
I do wish they would at least watch Castle episodes!

Avatar

This was an episode that could have been great but was let down yet again by errors made by the writer.
Beckett didn't miss the prom we know this from season 1 and Maddie would have said something about it if it occurred in season 2. Beckett would have gained a reputation had she done this and lost more than a few friends. She didn't!
moreover those of us who viewed the dirty bomb episode can remember Lanie saying she hated her mum. give she said nothing about her dad we assumed he was either dead or had separated.
Does anybody really believe Castle would be gawking at alp dancers given his feelings for Beckett and how beautiful she is? And please I am pretty sure Beckett knows how to take a photo from a phone why did she muck it up? When did the Christmas tree start at the precinct? It wasn't around for the Dead Santa why is it now? A small explanation is needed when you introduce a NEW concept. I liked the case but picked the bad guy straight away. The mob link was good. I liked the Romeo and Juliet link as well. Lane and Espo finally breaking up was good. Never any chemistry and both realised they didn't want to marry each other. I liked the Castle poem as well. The 'sacking' of Castle was totally plausible. He was at the Station for pete's sake. How was his shooting Castle's fault? So an episode of good and bad writing. Unfortunately as we have seen since the final arc of season 5 there is no quality control.
Surely all writers should have viewed all previous Castle episodes.

Comment modified at

Avatar
Castle Round Table: The End of an Era

I like quality