Reply to Post

Will You Watch?

1. McTwisted Dreams
   Guest Star
   Posts: 112

   

   Following the controversial Brooke Smith (Erica Hahn) firing, will you continue to watch Grey's tonight and in the future?

   Posted 11/6/2008 5:20:07 AM #
2. McTwisted Dreams
   Guest Star
   Posts: 112

   

   I've read so many threats to discontinue watching Grey's. Although I believe the departure of Brooke Smith will be a loss to the show, there are other storylines to be pursued and Grey's Anatomy will DEFINITELY be my no. 1 show =D

   It'll be interesting to see how Grey's fairs in the ratings and to see if people are dropping out because of the eradication of Erica. :( And I'm disappointed that they had to "de-gay" and change Sadie's storyline as well... even though I would've queried Mer's "history" with Sadie, the possibility of a sexual history would've left all viewers in more suspense.

   Posted 11/6/2008 5:25:25 AM #
3. Nikki
   Recurring Character
   Posts: 701

   

   I think that stop watching grey's anatomy because of this is stupid..  there are so many characters to follow and to see what they turn out.. and not stop watching just because one character was fired.. if it was like that i would've stop seen grey's anatomy when Addison left since she was my favorite character.. it's not one character that makes the show great its the whole group of amazing actors and the interesting cases that appear at SGH.

   Posted 11/6/2008 7:10:41 AM #
4. tvfannyc
   Extra
   Posts: 18

   

   My sentiments as well Nikki. While I can totally appreciate some fans sense of loss and betrayal, on the one hand, on the other hand it is an ensemble show, and not driven by one story line or relationship. That is what I like about it. I agree with the people who make the point that ABC actually has a better track record than most networks on gay relationships.

   Posted 11/6/2008 10:14:14 AM #
5. McV.
   New User
   Posts: 2

   i like hans, but seriously she was starting to get on my nerves... theres NOTHING interesting about her story line!

   and besides HER AND CALLY ISNT AS GREAT OF A THING AS CALLY AND MC STEAMY!!!

    

   I will SOOOOOOO KEEP WATCHING

   Posted 11/6/2008 9:30:42 PM #
6. Goodtimes
   New User
   Posts: 1

   I will continue to watch, I am just abit discusted at the whole situation. This is a total contradictory situation from what happen with Isaiah Washington and the gay thing. You either stand up and say it is ok or ot. I bet if the lesbian relationship was between two hot women it would still be going strong but since Hahn is not a super model men don't want to see it. I thought it was an interesting story line but there is so many places it can go and situations that can come from this relationship it is bogus what they are saying that they have no more story line for her. Look at Mc Steamy he has no story line except for sleeping with Callie every once in awhile and they still keep him. I think it is more for his looks and they bring in the women that bring in the rating. Whatever the reason it is a pretty crappy situation and I feel sorry for Brooke Smith it is unfair to her she is not even getting a proper writing off of the show. 

   Posted 11/6/2008 11:55:41 PM #
7. callicafan
   New User
   Posts: 2

   Absolutely done watching this lame show. The writers completely dropped the ball on a potentially great storyline & maybe Brooke Smith would still be employed if they had been up to par. I just can't understand how it's okay to show professionals having sex with multiple partners while at work but people are so offended at two girls sharing a kiss and discussing their emotions? A very sad situation all around.

   Posted 11/7/2008 1:03:28 AM #
8. xxtwinked-eyesxx
   New User
   Posts: 1

   

   At first I was totally against watching it ever again. I was so distraught. my friedn said just to watch something else. But then I had a semi flashback. thinking of all the greatness. My georgey my cristina. Garar I don't think I could live without them.

   So I probably will continue to watch it because I live Grey's so much but still. Grrr to ABC!

   Posted 11/7/2008 1:20:00 AM #
9. alwaysmkao
   Extra
   Posts: 8

   I didn't like Erica very much, and I don't like Callie very much either. So for me, show must go on. But I can understand that many people are disappointed with the decision of firing her. They shouldn't have done that.

   Posted 11/7/2008 8:21:24 AM #
10. McSeriouslyObsessed!
    Recurring Character
    Posts: 144

    

    i REALLY don't know? because of the whole Brooke thing. if they fire one more member, i'm not going to watch anymore!!

    Posted 11/7/2008 12:54:05 PM #

Guest posting is disabled. Click here to login. Click here to register.