Reply to Post

Elle's father - Different idea

1. blop
   Guest

   I'm rewatching season 1 here and there and I was watching "Company Man" in which we see some Bennet flashbacks.

   Remember Bennet shot Claude by order of the company? Do you remember why he was ordered to kill him?

   Because Claude (the invisible guy) was 'harboring one of them' - he was raising a person who had special abilities.

   Would it not make perfect sense if Claude is Elle's father?

   Now, this doesn't mean for sure that that is who Elle called father. She might have been taken away from Claude by the company after Claude was shot. But I think that Elle's biological father is Claude.

   Even more, this explains why the producers said that Elle had some stuff in common with claire. They were both raised by someone in the company after one of their parents (mother in Claire's case, father in Elle's case) was thought to have died.

    

   Awesome? I think so!

   Posted 11/11/2007 6:11:00 PM #
2. Sara A
   Guest

   Now that is what I like to hear, different ideas. Everyoneis just assuming that Bob is Elle's father, but that would be too easy if you ask me. I like your theory. And maybe she did call him father, maybe she reconnected with him after the exploding man thing and is now working behind the company's back like Ando and Mr. Bennet.

   Anything could happen at this point.

   Posted 11/16/2007 1:26:16 PM #
3. Sara A
   Guest

   Damn! Foiled again! SO bob is Elle's father, WHATEVER. Once again the obvious choice wins out. But it is also obviousthat Bob really doesn't care about elle the way Noah cares about claire. And It has made Elle really grasp the dark side of the force. Excuse my star wars reference, can't help it, we're all nerds here. Did you see how she shot claire and west outta the sky like that for no reason or instruction.

   Posted 11/20/2007 10:51:45 AM #

Forum is closed.