My theories after a third rewatch.
ABC Family made the television series different than the books, but used some of the same plot aspects. Like in the book Alison does have a twin; however, in the television series the twin is Jenna. Jenna is also A. During the Halloween episode Alison tells a scary story about twin sisters where one twin stabs the other and is then put into a mentalinstitution. That story is actually the true story about Jenna and Alison. I haven't figured out every detail yet (like how Toby fits into the equation) but I know Alison did not know who Jenna was when they met in the costume store (Alison introduces herself and Jenna says "I know"). After a while Alison did figure it out though. Someone sent Alison a doll and coincidentally a doll is what caused the fight that prompted one twin to stab the other. After Alison figured that out she deliberately threw that bomb into the garage where Jenna was. Jenna eventually killed Alison. I didn't instantly realize how much Alison and Jenna look alike but after re-watching an episode I cannot believe I didn't see it before!
This quote from Olivia is one of the most convincing I've read. It never occurred to be before, but I could definitely see this being true.Posted 2/17/2012 7:02:15 PM #
if Ali and Jenna are twins..
o m f g that would be shockingPosted 2/18/2012 12:00:56 AM #
The only thing that bothers me: I presumed the twin in the prequel Halloween episode was killed. Meaning Jenna can't be the twin that was stabbed in the beginning.Posted 2/18/2012 11:08:28 PM #
I've read a lot that say that Jenna and Ali are related but after on of the producers said that there was a clue in one of the ep's Salt Meets Wound and after I watched it I now know who "A" is if you go back to the part when Noel and Ezra are in the class room Noel grabs his red pen and puts a big A on the paper. So Noel is A. OR maybe Noel knows that Ezra is "A". What do you think?Posted 2/26/2012 10:31:23 PM #
hahaha Ezra being A
i'm dying stop
what is airPosted 3/2/2012 4:53:41 AM #
i would love for him to be A honestly
and if aria is still with him after finding that out
that is messed up
but i'm convinced he isn't because the writers are in love with ezria ughPosted 3/2/2012 6:42:41 AM #
rofl knowing Aria, she will
she will not stop until she gets to have a shot at his golden dick roflPosted 3/2/2012 8:39:15 AM #
and Aria is being slutty again btw she's like omg Duncan's cute *fake roll eyes* (but her ovaries are popping) roflPosted 3/2/2012 8:39:55 AM #
I finally figured out who A is and I can bet it's her ... Major clue Salt Meets Wound : Hanna thinks she figured out who A is , and sends texts to ONLY to the rest of the LIARS and noone else . And yet 5 minutes later she gets run down by a car , now HOW the heck did A come to know Hanna came to know who A was ... A is not FBI , and can't bug phones(it requires a lot of sophistication to bug them ) ... In fact what Hanna does not realize was that she told A that she knows who A is .... A does not stand for Allison , A does not stand for Anonymous ,it stands for something more obvious .A stands for .......... Aria I know that's a lot to digest and there are a lot of rebuttals coming my way. Firstly she has an accomplice for sure...
And logically Aria does not think Hanna found out about her in Salt Meet Wounds , she thought Hanna found out about her accomplice .. The same accomplice who ran a car down Hanna on Aria's instructions .. Later when Hanna says A is Noel , Aria is relieved and sends another text to the girls and herself ofcourse :) .. ( Noel is not the accomplice ) The accomplice is a guy obviously , because pushing off Ian , fighting 4 girls requires strength .. And it makes more sense , A does not start torturing again till Aria returns???? I agree If A wasn't Aria , it would have needed all 4 girls to be present , but I guess 3 isn't bad when you are really out of your mind . In short what I meant to say was , A happenings start again in Rosewood , not when another victim returns..... But when A herself returns :) A isn't equipped with mobile bugs and extenndable ears and spy cams . Those require a lot of sophistication .. A is two steps ahead always , because A has the first hand knowledge about what the rest of the girls are doing ... Remember the Chukie dolls task ??? A asks Spencer and Hanna to do , very very harsh tasks , and yet all Aria had to do was blackmail the ex-girlfriend of her boyfriend and make hers and Ezra's a bit life easier A has always had a soft corner for Aria., Now in ep Where the Spencer and Emily pretend to fight , Aria knows about it and yet is dumb enough to send her accomplice ???? Well she sent the accomplice to give the girls another false clue , i.e the infamous mobile of A. Believe me the mobile phone videos are exactly the same thing as the videos of Ian .., The person who is going to get arrested in the season finale is one of the innocent guys in those videos , and the beloved character who is going to die , will be the only one who will figure out the truth of Aria and her accomplice but sadly , will not live to cry it out loud . I have answers to all your questions but sadly can't make this article any longer .., And you guys can figure out the accomplice and PLL sounds a lot like scream 5 now . -APosted 3/3/2012 2:59:39 AM #
Ezra maybe Aria's accomplice , but he is definately not A...Posted 3/3/2012 3:00:43 AM #