Reply to Post

Who do you think is A?

1. scentsationsweetie
   New User
   Posts: 6

   

   I get the STRONG feeling that A is Allison's brother. I remember this episode where they showed Allison's brother saying something like "I'm more messed up than Allison." Plus, since Allison and her brother live in the same house, there is a better chance that her brother knows a lot about her. He prolly checked into her stuff, diary, memorabilia, etc.

    

   What do you guys think? 

   Posted 3/28/2011 11:15:12 PM #
2. alisha
   Guest

   i think that A is either monna or it could be ezria.

   Posted 3/29/2011 1:54:57 PM #
3. Rozzy
   Guest

   Mona isn't A in the tvshow. Only the books. THEY CHANGED IT> I personally feel like it's a male character. I sorta think Alision's Brother or....WEll accually i have no idea& IM SUPER EXCITED TO FIND OUT.

   Posted 4/2/2011 11:51:30 AM #
4. j
   Guest

   i hope its ezra, that would be sooo fun to watch!

   Posted 4/2/2011 5:35:47 PM #
5. Aravane
   Extra
   Posts: 42

   

   i'm thinking Ezra, too. or Melissa.

    

   i'd like for A to be any of our four main girls, but that wouldn't make much sense, would it?

   Posted 4/3/2011 8:26:44 AM #
6. scentsationsweetie
   New User
   Posts: 6

   

   No it wouldn't make sense if any of the 4 would kill A. That would be too horrific. How the heck would Ezra be A?

   Posted 4/5/2011 9:16:06 AM #
7. Flora (=liarsunited)
   Leading Character
   Posts: 4989

   

   I don't think Ian is A, I think he knows about A and impersonates A to scare Spencer, such as the "watch your back" note on her laptop and the "shut up or I'll shut you up --A" message on the wall at the festival.

   At the dance where Ian chaperoned, his coat number was 62 and the "A" at the end of the episode had 30 something for his/her number.

   Posted 4/5/2011 3:01:33 PM #
8. Spencer&Toby<3
   Guest

   No, i don't think -A could ever be Ezra! Yes, he would be an unexpected -A, but it just wouldn't make any sense. He truly loves Aria, and could never do anything to hurt her, OR get cought with her and loose his teaching career!

   But i agree that there might be more than one -A, that would make sense. because like Hanna said in the last episode: "A knows everything". And the only technical way -A can know EVERYTHING about ALL the girls is if there are more than one. 

   Right now, I am pretty sure that Melissa is one of the A's. Or at least that she killed Alison. Becuase Ian's story didn't match up to Alisons cause of death, and throughout the entire last segment he kept saying how Melissa would understand that he killed Spencer, and that he is doing the FOR hera and BECAUSE he loves her. And also, Melissa does look very guilty f you watch season one over again. Her marriage with Ian was her idea, she lied about their trip to that golf place, and then she also says to spencer that Alisons lies must have been the reason she died.

   I think Mona is just an insecure bitch. Nothing more. She wants to keep Caleb away from hanna because he hurt her, and she just doesn't realise how deep their connection actually was, and thinks that she needs to keep him away from her. 

   Posted 4/5/2011 5:24:56 PM #
9. Spencer&Toby<3
   Guest

   Wow Flora, I never picked up on the coat number! But i don't think that Ian is/was -A either. I think he thought that he or Melissa killed Alison, and has ever since just tried to protect himself and Melissa. I think that maybe someone else killed Ali. The question is who? And why? And how could Ian think that he killed her, when the news about her cause of death was everywhere in that town?

   Posted 4/5/2011 5:27:41 PM #
10. Flora (=liarsunited)
    Leading Character
    Posts: 4989

    

    and then she also says to spencer that Alisons lies must have been the reason she died.

    That scene where she said that, Spencer gave her a short stare, and at that point I really did suspect for a second that Melissa knew more about Ali. I started to think people were crazy for saying Melissa may be A, and I still think it is, but after rethinking about it, it doesn't sound that ridiculous.

    Wow Flora, I never picked up on the coat number! But i don't think that Ian is/was -A either. I think he thought that he or Melissa killed Alison, and has ever since just tried to protect himself and Melissa. I think that maybe someone else killed Ali. The question is who? And why? And how could Ian think that he killed her, when the news about her cause of death was everywhere in that town? Yeah, when the girls first declared that Toby, Jenna, Noal Ian were A, I didn't believe those assumptions for a second. It was way too fast for them to figure that out. Mystery murder stories have typical storylines, the main characters will always assume the mysterious quiet bad boy (Toby) is the killer, they will always assume the bully (Noel, Ian) is the killer, and they will always assume the enemy or person with a big grudge (Jenna) is the killer. That's why I knew none of them were the killers or "A" And after hearing what Ian told Spencer about Ali, to ME it sounded like Ian believes he killed Alison. If she was strangled AND had blunt head trama, I think Ian may have run away and someone showed up when she unconscious.

    Posted 4/5/2011 10:23:57 PM #

Guest posting is disabled. Click here to login. Click here to register.