My theories after a third rewatch.
I've been theorizing that Ezra is A since the start of S2. He is shady, we don't exactly know his background and he's been nothing but a perfect gentleman since the start of the show. (Come on, no one is that perfect! Lol!).
The other "A" must be between the four guys witnessing the fake argument between the liars in "Through Many Dangers, Toils and Snares". Garrett, Toby, Caleb and Lucas. Garrett just seems stupid and too suspicious to be A's accomplice. Lucas is definitely shady and based on the next episode, it looks like Lucas is the other "A". But doors are open for Toby and Caleb too. I mean, it really is not the first in TV, a bad guy-turns-good-guy-then-turns-bad-guy-again.
l maybe A is ezra + lucas, and melissa LOL okay idek
First mona can't be 'A' cause she is 'A' in the books and the producer said its different.
third *Hanna Marin Ashley Benson*
and fourth i do think that ezra is an also did you notice aria never actually gets physically hurt by 'A' and the episode where 'A' puts daisies on a grave at the end on ezra chalkboard it says daisy. and the episode where spencers gets an email saying married for love or an alibi after she hears melissa and Ian fighting on ezras chalkboard it says married for love?..creepy js
lul if Ezra is A I'd lul so hard. I know why A doesnt torture Aria. She's nothing going on in her life anyway. Her blandless will kill her eventually so A thinks why bother fucking with her.
I like the theory of Ezra being A but I do not see a motive of why he would wanna screw with the girls' lives. I remember at the end of one of the episodes in season 1 that A finds and steals the hiding key at Ezra's apartment underneath the door mat in order to secretly place the photo frame in his room so that the girls know that A is watching. So it can't be Ezra.
I do however think that A is Maya. Think about it, Maya is a girl and so she is able to go into the girls bathroom and listen in on the girls; she was sent off to True North where its possible she didnt go anywhere but stayed hidden so she can do A business; when she came back to Rosewood Emily saw her talking to Noel Khan and she said he was helping her with her phone and remember that A dropped their phone! And also when she was away at "True North" and Emily was dating Paige & Samara, A tried hard to break them apart because Maya loves Emily and thats why in recent episodes it seems like Maya is jealous that Emily has more time for Spencer, Hanna & Aria and not her so she wants to screw with the 3 girls so she can have Emily all to herself.
And I definitely think that A is not working alone. Remember when Maya turned her bedroom into an ocean to recreate the swimming pool for Emily & then the next episode Mona did all the computer hacking for Emily so she can get back on the team. Maybe Mona is working with Maya??
LOL maybe A is Maya, Mona, Noel, Ezra and every other suspecct all working together. O ma lawd.
Exactly ! My poor bb Noel. BUT ARIA/NOEL INTERACTION :,) but it was terrifying gawsh
lul i was hoping Noel to get aria fall on her ass