A... shocking theory (Spoilers)
I finally figured out who A is and I can bet it's her ... Major clue Keep your Friends close: Hanna thinks she figured out who A is , and sends texts to ONLY to the rest of the LIARS and noone else . And yet 5 minutes later she gets run down by a car , now HOW the heck did A come to know Hanna came to know who A was ... A is not FBI , and can't bug phones(it requires a lot of sophistication to bug them ) ... In fact what Hanna does not realize was that she told A that she knows who A is .... A does not stand for Allison , A does not stand for Anonymous ,it stands for something more obvious .A stands for .......... Aria I know that's a lot to digest and there are a lot of rebuttals coming my way. Firstly she has an accomplice for sure...
And logically Aria does not think Hanna found out about her in Keep your Friends close, she thought Hanna found out about her accomplice .. The same accomplice who ran a car down Hanna on Aria's instructions .. Later when Hanna says A is Noel , Aria is relieved and sends another text to the girls and herself ofcourse :) .. ( Noel is not the accomplice ) The accomplice is a guy obviously , because pushing off Ian , fighting 4 girls requires strength .. And it makes more sense , A does not start torturing again till Aria returns???? I agree If A wasn't Aria , it would have needed all 4 girls to be present , but I guess 3 isn't bad when you are really out of your mind . In short what I meant to say was , A happenings start again in Rosewood , not when another victim returns..... But when A herself returns :) A isn't equipped with mobile bugs and extenndable ears and spy cams . Those require a lot of sophistication .. A is two steps ahead always , because A has the first hand knowledge about what the rest of the girls are doing ... Remember the Chukie dolls task ??? A asks Spencer and Hanna to do , very very harsh tasks , and yet all Aria had to do was blackmail the ex-girlfriend of her boyfriend and make hers and Ezra's a bit life easier A has always had a soft corner for Aria., Now in ep Where the Spencer and Emily pretend to fight , Aria knows about it and yet is dumb enough to send her accomplice ???? Well she sent the accomplice to give the girls another false clue , i.e the infamous mobile of A. Believe me the mobile phone videos are exactly the same thing as the videos of Ian .., The person who is going to get arrested in the season finale is one of the innocent guys in those videos , and the beloved character who is going to die , will be the only one who will figure out the truth of Aria and her accomplice but sadly , will not live to cry it out loud . I have answers to all your questions but sadly can't make this article any longer .., And you guys can figure out the accomplice and PLL sounds a lot like scream 5 now
Again, that doesn't explain why A is most interested in Toby =S I think it might be Spencer because she fits the profile, we keep hearing that Spencer wanted to replace Allison and A is probably the best she can do to replace her. There's an episode in which someone says it's like A has a split personality and maybe that's why Spencer is doing it, perhaps without even knowing that she's A. She's so smart she could fool everyone easily. I hope I'm totally wrong, though, because I'd be so disappointed if she were the bad 'guy' after all this buildup. I know she's not perfect but she was the only one who confronted Ally and told her how horrible she was. If after all Spencer is capable of doing everyting A's done, then this is just too much for me...
It would also explain why Spencer lies when she says she couldn't get to the bathroom because Mona was in there (we see Mona in the kitchen right after Spencer goes upstairs in 1x12).
OR maybe A was answering the questions as if she were Allison, in that case it would make sense that Toby's the one she's most interest in because she didn't know the other boys. But then what's the big old clue in 1x12? I think it can't be Aria because Marlene King said the finale would be Ezria's best episode and when someone asked her why she was ruling out Ezra from the A's suspect list by saying that she said 'Well, I'm a sucker for romance'. So I guess that she was confirming that Ezra's not A and that Aria's not A (because if she were Ezra would leave her, he's so close to doing that already).
A didnt write anything on the back of Ezra's car. NOEL DID.
maybe aria is more than a ho but an attention ho
wasnt aria in the car with ezra when hanna was run over? and also she wouldnt send her dad letters about where her and ezra are..
aria wasnt in the car, aria was with the others.
WHY OH WHY is everyone so convinced that it's one of the girls. THAT DOESN'T EVEN MAKE SENSE. THINK ABOUT WHAT YOU ARE ALL SAYING. There would be ABSOLUTELY no point to this TV show. NONE WHATSOEVER.
I agree with you Angela, it would be stupid for A to be one of the girls.
Maybe if tge show stopped at season 2, it would be a massive shock and just be left at that. But because the show renewed for a 3rd season, and A is revealed tonight, i makes it impossible for it to be on of the girls.
They would have to change the opening scene for starters to show 3 girls instead of 4.
It just doesnt make sense to me.
As for who it, it i think it could be Jenna and someone else maybe jason.
BUT apparently it was a massive shock to all the cast who A was, and jenna and jason seem a bit obvious.
It could be Toby?
It's also stupid when you say it could be Jenna or Jason, because that wouldn't be shocking at all :D