Are you a TV Fanatic?
Sign up for our daily newsletter to receive personalized television news for free!
This is just a theory I've been building up and the more I think of it, the more it seems a possibility. This theory is NOT whom or who I think "A" is, but who I think murdered Alison. Someone who has enough motive to want Alison out of the picture. Right now I think Aria's father, Byron, could in fact be the murder. Why? I have some reasons. When Aria discovered her fathers infidelity she was with none other than Alison. Byron could easily sway Aria not to tell her mother, of course Aria wouldn't want to hurt her Mom, brother and ultimately break up her family. However Alison could quite easily tell Aria's mom as she would have nothing to lose. Alison was hell bent on all the girls telling the truth, or she would do it for them. Maybe she took the same attitude towards Byron and he intially thought she could be paid off with some money ( the unexplained $15000 dollars belonging to Ali found by Jason). Ali couldn't be bought so easily and so the only solution for Byron to keep his family as one was to make sure Alison never talked. Again. Another reason for Ali possibly wanting to tell Arias mom is that perhaps Meredith wasn't the first and only younger woman Byron was fooling around with at that time. We've been told Ali liked to go to college parties to meet older college guys, maybe all these college guys weren't alumni? Could Ali have had an affair with Byron, having taken a page out of her favourite book Lolita? In the flashback where Aria and Ali trash Byrons office, Ali seems alot more hurt by Byrons cheating than Aria and is scapegoating Aria's hurt to justify her own destruction of the office. Not long after Alison's disapperance, the Montgomery clan up and leave Rosewood for Iceland, a million miles away from Rosewood, for a whole year! Was Byron running away not only from his cheating but also from his murder of Alison? Sorry for this being such a long theory! Who do you think killed Ali?
On a side note, why is everyone so suspicious of Aria? Mona wouldn't speak to Hanna at the mental hospital when Aria was there and Jenna doesn't like her either. This couldn't just be coincidence could it?
TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU! In the last episode of season 2 when Mona leads spencer to the motel room Spencer is looking at Ali's diary and it talks about Byron and how attractive she thinks he is! There's definetly more there too my computer screen is not big enough, but you have to check it out! I definetly think this a HUGE possibility, ahh it would be so crazy! I don't about Aria being a part of the A team, but a lot of people seem to think so..
@Emma..omg..u could b rite abt Byron..i always thought it was Spence's dad because he didnt want anyone to know abt Jason being his son and i always thoight that the cash in Alison's draw was given to her by Spencer's dad..Spencer did find a blank cheque for $15,000 or $20,000 (cant remember the exact value)
@Emma..u mite b rite abt Byron killing Alison but I dont think he is A..who do u think A is?
I think you are definitely right.. I have been thinking the same thing! Guess we will just have to wait and see..