Reply to Post

Ian's video with Allison

1. jenn
   Guest

   I think her hand on the ground wasn't Ian killing Allison, but rather them having sex. Then probably Melissa came in and saw and killed Allison, and she married Ian so he wouldn't tell the police about what happened

   Posted 2/24/2011 8:37:59 PM #
2. Pllfan2
   New User
   Posts: 1

   I think it may have been edited, if you watch when Ian grabs the lens it abruptly cuts straight to the shot of the ground, as if it were meshed together by some camera tricks.

   Posted 4/8/2011 10:23:18 PM #
3. Spencer&Toby<3
   Guest

   I too think that it must have been edited. A would never just give the girls a clue without messing with them a little. A must have edited the video, or removed som essentiel part of it. Either that or Alisan and Ian were just having sex. That would make more sense, than for Ian to kill her while he was filming. Ian is kind of smart, and filming her death would be very stupid. But what makes senze is that they were having sex, because Ian was a pervert who would have loved to film that. Any way, I don't believe that Ian killed her, so I am pretty sure that video is not of him killing her, like the girls first thought. 

   Posted 4/9/2011 2:18:20 PM #
4. Rebeccaaaar
   Extra
   Posts: 18

   

   They could of been having sex. But i think for sure the video was edited. definitly. 

   Posted 4/11/2011 10:07:37 PM #
5. Raaachx (=liarsunited)
   Recurring Character
   Posts: 418

   no if you listen to the last ten minutes or so of the season finale, ian says she fell and hit her head. so probably he just ran off when that happened.

   Posted 4/29/2011 11:44:26 AM #
6. MerDerLover
   Guest Star
   Posts: 21

   

   I think it was Ian and Alison having sex and then Ian kills Spencer.

   Posted 5/28/2011 10:16:47 PM #
7. _Lexi_1180
   New User
   Posts: 1

   I also think it might have been them having sex i had to replay the video over and over.  if you listen carefully you can hear tiny little moans. if it wasn't that i dont know but it could have been edited

   Posted 7/6/2012 8:02:28 PM #
8. Juliette
   Regular Character
   Posts: 3309

   

   I'm pretty sure Ian and Ali were having sex in the woods that night because we see them reajusting their clothes afterwards. As of the falling and hitting her head part, as spencer said to Ian while fighting with him, the cause of death was suffocation! 

   Posted 7/8/2012 10:48:40 PM #
9. Flora (=liarsunited)
   
   Posts: 10484

   
   I don't think that video had anything to do with her death, they need to quit dragging the story of how she died already

   Posted 7/9/2012 12:32:09 AM #
10. Raaachx (=liarsunited)
    Recurring Character
    Posts: 418

    I agree with Flora now, Ali got back to the house before she died I'm pretty sure

    Posted 7/9/2012 6:33:30 AM #